Wales women earned two draws in their three matches against Italy in Rome, but the hosts' won the series thanks to a 1-0 opening game triumph.
Abi Welsford and Leach Wilkinson scored the goals that secured a 2-2 draw on Sunday.
A day earlier former captain Tina Evans celebrated her return following a three-year absence in style.
Evans, who won the first of her 75 caps in 2005, struck late on to ensure a 1-1 draw.
Wales women squad
Abi Welsford (capt; Swansea City Spartans), Beth Bingham (Loughborough University), Danni Jordan, (Clifton HC), Ella Jackson (GK; University of Exeter), Hannah Cozens (Loughborough University), Joanne Westwood (Swansea City Spartans), Julie Whiting (FC Lyon), Leah Wilkinson (vice capt), Holcombe HC, Lisa Daley (Swansea City Spartans), Natasha Marke-Jones (Swansea City Spartans), Phoebe Richards (Buckingham HC), Roseanne Thomas (GK; Wimbledon HC), Sarah Jones (Holcombe HC), Sarah-Jane Thorburn (Swansea City Spartans), Sian French Bowdon (Hightown HC), Sophie Clayton (Swansea City Spartans), Tina Evans (University of Birmingham), Xenna Hughes (East Grinstead).