Europa League - Group E

Rennes 1-1 Celtic: Christie's penalty earns visitors Europa League point

By Kheredine IdessaneBBC Scotland at Roazhon Park
James Forrest won the penalty which Ryan Christie converted
James Forrest won the crucial penalty for Celtic, which Ryan Christie converted

Ryan Christie's second-half penalty earned Celtic a deserved draw in Rennes in a frenetic opening Group E match in the Europa League.

M'Baye Niang fired the hosts in front from the spot after Kristoffer Ajer's lunge brought him down in the box.

But James Forrest won Celtic the penalty for Christie to convert.

That set up a tense finish, and substitute Vakoun Bayo was dismissed in stoppage time after picking up a second booking.

Forrest drew the foul from Rennes captain Damien da Silva in what looked a soft award, though Celtic had a clear shout for a penalty turned down moments earlier when Christie was tripped.

With CFR Cluj shocking Lazio 2-1 in the other Group E match to top the section, it leaves Celtic level with their hosts as they welcome the Romanian champions back to Celtic Park in two weeks' time.

Margins fine in pulsating match

It is all about small margins in European football. Margins, and mistakes.

Had Mohamed Elyounoussi been a couple of inches further forward in a first half which ebbed and flowed nicely, he would have tapped Boli Bolingoli's beautiful cross into an empty net.

Had Celtic's Norwegian defender Ajer not been so determined to go to ground on Niang rather than stay on his feet, Rennes would not have won a first-half penalty, expertly despatched by the Senegalese striker himself into the corner of the goal vacated by the diving Fraser Forster.

The wall of noise that greeted the goal inside a raucous Roazhon Park was the aural equivalent of a mighty slap in the face for a Celtic side who had settled into the game well. That said, they did not overly test home goalkeeper Edouard Mendy, whereas Forster had to be lively to repel a powerful Raphinha shot and was mightily relieved to watch midfielder Clement Grenier head over and wide.

But there could not have been many inside the stadium who would have complained if Celtic had gone in level at the break.

The Scottish champions would have to be clinical. But when a chance came the way of captain Scott Brown from a free-kick early in the second half, he headed over.

And after conceding a penalty, Celtic might legitimately ask why they were not awarded one within five minutes of the restart when Christie appeared to be tripped just inside the area. Margins once again, and possibly a mistake from the match officials.

They did not have to wait long to claim for another one. Lovely trickery and footwork by Forrest bamboozled Da Silva, whose furious protests that he had not touched the turf-bound Scotland winger were dismissed by referee Jose Maria Sanchez Martinez. The penalty was superbly converted by the left foot of Christie to re-establish parity for Neil Lennon's side before the hour.

A brilliant free-kick from Grenier looked to be beating Forster at his near post as both sides probed. But it went just by the post, possibly aided by some goalkeeping fingertips, although a goal-kick was the ultimate result.

There was late drama, too. A pair of yellow cards in quick succession for Celtic's substitute Bayo, the second for what television pictures showed as minimal contact on Rennes goalkeeper Mendy, meant the visitors had to play three minutes of injury time with 10 men, with the home crowd venting their disapproval. There was nearly a late winner for Christie but a shot with the outside of that left boot was deflected away for a corner.

However, Celtic emerge from Rennes with a 1-1 draw, as they did under Lennon eight years ago. He said that result gave him a platform to build upon in Europe, and he'll be hoping history is once again repeating itself.

Christie graphic

Man of the match - Ryan Christie

For a skilful, forward-thinking display full of energy and creativity, and for a coolly-taken penalty to make sure Celtic did not leave with nothing, the award goes to Christie, although he was ably assisted by some good performances around him.

The 24-year-old was up against a high-quality Rennes midfield, with Grenier and Benjamin Bourigeaud catching the eye, and the Scot was quite happy to do his shift when it came to any defensive duties. Penalties bring pressure but Christie looked like he didn't have a care in the world as he made sure Celtic got off the mark straight away in Group E with a good point away from home.

Celtic end losing Europa streak - statistics

  • Rennes have now lost just one of their last 16 home games in European competition (Including qualifiers - W8 D7), going down 1-2 against Dynamo Kiev in last season's Europa League group stage.
  • Celtic have ended a run of three straight Europa League defeats since beating Rosenborg in November 2018. Incidentally, it's their first draw in the competition since sharing the points against Fenerbahce in December 2015.
  • With a red card for Vakoun Issouf Bayo, Celtic have received red cards in back-to-back Europa League games for the second time, having done so in 2015 against Ajax and Inter Milan.
  • Rennes' M'baye Niang scored his first Europa League goal since February, netting in a 3-1 win against Real Betis. He has scored three goals in his last four games in all competitions for Rennes.
  • Celtic's Ryan Christie has scored his ninth goal of the season (four in CL qualifiers and four league goals), netting from Celtic's first shot on target in the match.

Scores, Results & Fixtures

Thursday 19th September 2019

As It Stood


2F91 Dudelange11004313
3Apoel Nicosia100134-10
4FK Qarabag100103-30


1Dynamo Kyiv11001013
2FC Copenhagen11001013
4Malmö FF100101-10


1FC Basel11005053
4FK Krasnodar100105-50


1PSV Eindhoven11003213


1CFR Cluj11002113


2Standard Liege11002023
3Vitória Guimarães100102-20


1FC Porto11002113
3Young Boys100112-10


2Ferencvárosi TC10101101
4CSKA Moscow100115-40


2KAA Gent11003213


1RZ Pellets WAC11004043
3B Mgladbach100104-40
4Istanbul Basaksehir100104-40


1Slovan Bratislava11004223
2Sporting Braga11001013


1Man Utd11001013
2AZ Alkmaar10102201
3Partizan Belgrade10102201
4FC Astana100101-10
View full Europa League tables

Top Stories