Premier League: Which three clubs could go down?

Norwich head coach Daniel Farke, Sheffield United manager Chris Wilder and Aston Villa head coach Dean Smith
Norwich head coach Daniel Farke (left), Sheffield United manager Chris Wilder (centre) and Aston Villa head coach Dean Smith (right) will be looking to make their mark in the Premier League

Over the past 10 seasons, two of the three promoted sides on average have survived, with 19 of the 30 teams finishing above the bottom three.

Only three times in Premier League history have all the promoted sides stayed up - in 2001-02, 2011-12 and 2017-18 - while only in 1997-98 have all three been relegated - Bolton, Barnsley and Crystal Palace.

With it likely then that a mix of promoted and current sides will go down, we take a look at the three clubs that came up and three whose place in the Premier League could be under threat.

When all three promoted teams stayed up (final position in brackets)
2001-02Blackburn (10th) Fulham (13th)Bolton (16th)
2011-12Swansea (11th)Norwich (12th)QPR (17th)
2017-18Newcastle (10th)Brighton (15th)Huddersfield (16th)

Norwich: Goals galore

Last season: Championship winners

Norwich scored an impressive 93 goals in the Championship last season, with only Bournemouth in 2014-15 scoring more on their way to the top flight since 2006.

However, such an attacking approach saw them concede 57 goals in return, meaning that their games involved the most goals of any promoted side since Kevin Keegan's Manchester City in 2001-02.

Most goal-filled Championship/First Division promotion seasons
ClubSeasonScoredConcededCombinedSurvived?
Man City2001-0210852160Yes
Bolton1996-9710053153No
Norwich2018-199357150?
Bournemouth2014-159845143Yes
West Brom2007-088855143No
Aston Villa2018-198261143?

Head coach Daniel Farke made the fewest changes to his starting XI in the Championship last season and with the lack of spending this summer, will continue to trust the side that won promotion in such daring style.

After his 29 league goals saw him crowned Championship Player of the Season, much will depend on 29-year-old striker Teemu Pukki. The former Celtic striker has limited experience in Europe's top five leagues, with a single game for Sevilla and a few seasons as a substitute at Schalke.

Sheffield United: More than they seem

Last season: Championship runners-up

After conceding the joint-fewest goals and keeping the most clean sheets in the Championship last season, Sheffield United are the most impressive defensively of the promoted sides.

But that's not to say they're predictable or dour. Their 3-4-1-2 formation and use of overlapping centre-backs last season - with Jack O'Connell and Chris Basham running beyond the wing-backs - suggests manager Chris Wilder's tactics could catch a few Premier League teams out this season.

Sheffield United's first XI in 2018-19

Going forward, the club focuses on quality over quantity. While 13 sides had more shots in the Championship last season, the Blades created the best chances according to expected goals, scoring the fourth-most goals overall.

As with Pukki at Norwich, the club's goalscoring hopes will rest on captain and boyhood fan Billy Sharp. The 33-year-old striker scored 23 league goals last season, although his only Premier League experience is two substitute appearances for Southampton in August 2012.

Aston Villa: Are they 'doing a Fulham'?

Last season: Championship play-off winners

With their spending spree this summer, the club have been compared to previous play-off winners Fulham and as the table below shows, there are similarities to what the London club did last summer before being relegated back to the Championship.

Are Aston Villa 'doing a Fulham'?
Fulham 2018-19Aston Villa 2019-20
% minutes 'lost' by players leaving36%35%
Money spent£103m£120m+
Summer signings1212
On loan the previous season13
% minutes played by new signings53%?

However, considering that three of Aston Villa's signings were at the club last season and five of Fulham's signings had yet to join this time last year, Villa's business does seem less chaotic, although the proof will ultimately come at the end of the season.

While Norwich and Sheffield United head into the season with their star scorers, the loss of 25-goal striker Tammy Abraham is a blow for Dean Smith's side and puts a lot of pressure on club record signing Wesley, who scored 13 league goals for Club Bruges last season.

One player who will be key to Villa's survival hopes is 23-year-old captain and boyhood fan Jack Grealish. After missing three months through injury, his return to the side in March coincided with the start of the club's incredible 10-game winning run that took them to the play-offs and the Premier League.

Brighton: Flight risk

Last season: 17th in Premier League

After finishing just two points above the bottom three last season, Brighton will be hoping new manager Graham Potter can get the club flying again.

For while the club's poor form last season began in December - winning just three of their final 23 games - their earlier results masked a side that struggled throughout the season, with their form eventually catching up to their performances by the final game.

A major problem is the club's reliance on striker Glenn Murray, who scored the highest percentage of goals for a Premier League club last season (37%) and who turns 36 next month. The club's signing of Neal Maupay could solve that, as the striker scored 25 goals in the Championship for Brentford last season.

Since only three Championship teams had more possession than Potter's Swansea last season and only three Premier League teams had less than Brighton, it's clear that the Seagulls will look to spread their wings with a more expansive approach this season, but there is little room in which to manoeuvre.

Burnley: A siege mentality

Last season: 15th in Premier League

Burnley survived in the Premier League last season despite taking the fewest shots and conceding the most.

In fact, since Opta records began in 2003-04, only Reading in 2012-13 were more heavily out-shot by the opposition than the Clarets last season.

Worst Premier League shot differences since 2003-04
ClubSeasonShot differenceRelegated?
Reading2012-13-312Yes
Burnley2018-19-292No
Norwich2004-05-292Yes
Sunderland2016-17-289Yes
Birmingham2010-11-286Yes
Burnley2016-17-280No
Leeds2003-04-279Yes
Cardiff2013-14-274Yes

Yet Burnley avoided a similar fate to other teams under siege due to the quality of the chances they created and conceded. According to expected goals, only Arsenal and Liverpool created better chances on average last season, while only Wolves and Liverpool conceded more difficult ones at the other end.

Whether Burnley can maintain such quality this season remains to be seen, although the club's improved form after Christmas meant the Clarets didn't need to rely on it as much as in the first half of last season.

Newcastle: Where are the goals?

Last season: 13th in Premier League

Despite finishing 11 points clear of the relegation zone last season, the departures of manager Rafael Benitez, top scorer Ayoze Perez and Salomon Rondon could see Newcastle in trouble this season.

Those two players scored 23 of the club's 42 goals in the Premier League last season, meaning that, along with the exits of Joselu and Kenedy, the club has lost almost two-thirds of its goals over the summer.

League goals in 2018-19 scored by players no longer at the club
RankClubGoals goneDeparted scorers (goals)
1Newcastle62%Perez (12), Rondon (11), Joselu (2), Kenedy (1)
2Aston Villa44%Abraham (25), Adomah (4), Bolasie (2), Hutton (2), 3 players (1)
3Chelsea41%Hazard (16), Higuain (5), Morata (5)
4West Ham25%Arnautovic (10), Perez (3)
5Crystal Palace10%Batshuayi (5)

The signings of £40m striker Joelinton and £16.5m winger Allan Saint-Maximin - who scored seven and six league goals last season respectively - will need to fill that goalscoring void, as will the returning Dwight Gayle, who scored 23 goals in the Championship on loan at West Brom last season.

With two top-half finishes and two relegations, Steve Bruce's record in the Premier League averages out to around 43 points a season, slightly worse than Benitez's record at Newcastle of 45 points a season.

Top Stories