Women's World Cup - Group D

Women's World Cup: Scotland's late rally falls short as Japan inflict second defeat

Media playback is not supported on this device

Scotland lose 2-1 to Japan despite late Clelland strike

Scotland's chances of qualifying from their Women's World Cup group hang by a thread after defeat by Japan.

Shelley Kerr's side had rarely been out of their own half by the time Mana Iwabuchi blasted a shot past goalkeeper Lee Alexander after 22 minutes.

With Japan dominating, Rachel Corsie was ruled to have hauled down Yuika Sugasawa and the striker sent the spot-kick low into the corner.

A late Scotland rally produced a fine long-range Lana Clelland finish.

But consecutive 2-1 defeats leave Kerr's side bottom of the table without a point and needing to beat Argentina in their final game if they are to have a chance of making the knockout stage as one of the four best third-placed sides.

For former world champions Japan, who opened with a disappointing draw, it ends a run of five games without a victory and puts them second in the group.

Tale of three penalty claims and insipid starts

There is no doubt that Japan, ranked 13 places above Scotland at seven in the world, deserved their victory at Stade de la Route de Lorient in Rennes, but Kerr's side were left to rue another insipid first half and three penalty decisions that went against them.

The Scotland head coach obviously had a gameplan in mind to beat the Japanese, with her starting XI showing four changes from the one that lost to England, including the dropping of winger Claire Emslie to the bench despite her goal in the opener.

Scotland were looking to be more of a threat up front, having restored top goalscorer Jane Ross, but Japan coach Asako Takakura had different ideas.

Having been criticised for Japan's own lack of attacking intent in their opening goalless draw with Argentina, Takakura made three changes, including fielding an extra forward.

It was Scotland's turn to look passive. There was a lack of tempo, imagination, movement, belief and, strangely, determination, with the likes of Kim Little and Erin Cuthbert looking far short of their world-class reputations.

Japan had already been knocking on the door by the time Alexander looked slow to react as Iwabuchi - the forward handed a start after impressing as a substitute against Argentina - fired straight through the goalkeeper high into the net following a poor headed clearance from Corsie.

Media playback is not supported on this device

Clelland's superb 20-yard strike isn't enough as Scotland lose 2-1 to Japan

Their high press was forcing Scotland into aimless long balls forward, while their tiki-taka football was leaving their opponents looking disheartened and bewildered.

Rather than being Scotland's creative force, Little's biggest contribution was to head a Saki Kumagai header off the line after Alexander made a mess of coming for a cross.

When Sugasawa crumpled dramatically to the ground, it looked like a soft penalty award, but the video assistant referees agreed with referee Lidya Tafesse's view that Corsie's ill-advised hand on the striker's shoulder was enough to award the spot kick.

It took 41 minutes for Scotland to threaten through Cuthbert's 20-yard drive on to the roof of the net, while Japan went close to going into the break three ahead when Hina Sugita found the face of the crossbar.

As against England, it was only in the last 15 minutes, having thrown caution to the wind and having introduced Emslie then Clelland, that Scotland began to look like a side deserving of a place at the World Cup finals.

Cuthbert found the outside of a post from close range and looked to be clipped from behind by Sugita only for the officials to ignore Scottish pleas.

Lisa Evans had a shot pushed wide by goalkeeper Ayaka Yamashita before another cry for a penalty failed to even win a VAR review after Risa Shimizu looked to halt Cuthbert's progress with a hand ball.

Scottish pressure eventually told when Clelland gathered Nana Ichise's poor pass across the face of her own goal and produced a sublime finish from 18 yards, but the two minutes remaining quickly passed without an equaliser.

Player of the match - Mana Iwabuchi (Japan)

Media playback is not supported on this device

Iwabuchi's shot from the edge of the area loops over Alexander to put Japan ahead

Claire Emslie topped our Player Rater as voted by the public. However, while the Scotland winger did make a big difference after coming on as a substitute with 30 minutes remaining, it would be churlish to suggest she outshone anyone in the blue jerseys that dominated the majority of the match.

With her 21st international goal, Japan forward Mana Iwabuchi not only set the tone with her fine finish but was the lynchpin of intricate passing that constantly had the Scots defence chasing shadows.

Match stats

  • Japan have now won all three of their meetings with Scotland
  • Japan have now won six World Cup matches against European sides in a row
  • Japan's only defeat in 12 games at the tournament came in the 2015 final against the United States
  • They have won their second group stage game in each of their last four World Cups
  • After six games without defeat, Scotland have now lost two in a row

What next?

With Argentina losing 1-0 later in the evening as England secured their place in the last 16, they will fight it out with Scotland for third place on Wednesday.

A win is a must for Kerr's side when both matches kick-off at 20:00 BST if they are to have the chance of prolonging their World Cup debut.



  • 18Yamashita
  • 22Shimizu
  • 4Kumagai
  • 5Ichise
  • 3SameshimaBooked at 19mins
  • 7Nakajima
  • 17Miura
  • 6Sugita
  • 19EndoSubstituted forKobayashiat 66'minutes
  • 9Sugasawa
  • 8IwabuchiSubstituted forHasegawaat 82'minutes


  • 1Ikeda
  • 2Utsugi
  • 10Sakaguchi
  • 11Kobayashi
  • 12Minami
  • 13Takarada
  • 14Hasegawa
  • 15Momiki
  • 16Miyagawa
  • 20Yokoyama
  • 21Hirao
  • 23Miyake


  • 1Alexander
  • 2Smith
  • 4CorsieBooked at 36mins
  • 5Beattie
  • 7Lauder
  • 11EvansSubstituted forBrownat 85'minutes
  • 8Little
  • 9Weir
  • 23ArnotSubstituted forEmslieat 60'minutes
  • 22Cuthbert
  • 13RossSubstituted forClellandat 76'minutes


  • 3Docherty
  • 6Love
  • 10Crichton
  • 12Lynn
  • 14Arthur
  • 15Howard
  • 17Murray
  • 18Emslie
  • 19Clelland
  • 20Brown
  • 21Fife
Lidya Tafesse

Match Stats

Home TeamJapanAway TeamScotland
Shots on Target

Live Text

Match ends, Japan 2, Scotland 1.

Full Time

Second Half ends, Japan 2, Scotland 1.

Attempt saved. Hina Sugita (Japan) right footed shot from the centre of the box is saved in the top centre of the goal. Assisted by Rikako Kobayashi.

Foul by Hina Sugita (Japan).

Erin Cuthbert (Scotland) wins a free kick in the defensive half.

Yuika Sugasawa (Japan).

Erin Cuthbert (Scotland) wins a free kick in the defensive half.

Corner, Japan. Conceded by Kirsty Smith.


Goal! Japan 2, Scotland 1. Lana Clelland (Scotland) left footed shot from outside the box to the top right corner.

Attempt missed. Caroline Weir (Scotland) right footed shot from outside the box misses to the right.

Attempt blocked. Fiona Brown (Scotland) right footed shot from outside the box is blocked.

Corner, Scotland. Conceded by Hina Sugita.

Foul by Yui Hasegawa (Japan).

Erin Cuthbert (Scotland) wins a free kick on the right wing.


Substitution, Scotland. Fiona Brown replaces Lisa Evans.

Corner, Scotland. Conceded by Ayaka Yamashita.

Attempt saved. Lisa Evans (Scotland) right footed shot from outside the box is saved in the bottom left corner. Assisted by Erin Cuthbert.

Attempt missed. Risa Shimizu (Japan) right footed shot from outside the box is too high. Assisted by Narumi Miura.


Substitution, Japan. Yui Hasegawa replaces Mana Iwabuchi.

Corner, Scotland. Conceded by Aya Sameshima.

Attempt missed. Erin Cuthbert (Scotland) header from the centre of the box misses to the left. Assisted by Caroline Weir with a cross following a corner.

Corner, Scotland. Conceded by Mana Iwabuchi.

Erin Cuthbert (Scotland) hits the left post with a right footed shot from the left side of the six yard box. Assisted by Jennifer Beattie following a set piece situation.

Foul by Mana Iwabuchi (Japan).

Lana Clelland (Scotland) wins a free kick on the right wing.


Substitution, Scotland. Lana Clelland replaces Jane Ross.

Attempt blocked. Erin Cuthbert (Scotland) right footed shot from the right side of the box is blocked. Assisted by Jane Ross.

Attempt missed. Jennifer Beattie (Scotland) header from the centre of the box misses to the left. Assisted by Kim Little with a cross following a corner.

Corner, Scotland. Conceded by Risa Shimizu.

Offside, Scotland. Hayley Lauder tries a through ball, but Jane Ross is caught offside.

Foul by Rikako Kobayashi (Japan).

Claire Emslie (Scotland) wins a free kick in the defensive half.

Corner, Japan. Conceded by Rachel Corsie.

Attempt saved. Aya Sameshima (Japan) right footed shot from outside the box is saved in the bottom left corner.


Substitution, Japan. Rikako Kobayashi replaces Jun Endo.

Attempt missed. Lisa Evans (Scotland) right footed shot from outside the box is too high following a corner.

Corner, Scotland. Conceded by Narumi Miura.

Corner, Japan. Conceded by Hayley Lauder.


Substitution, Scotland. Claire Emslie replaces Lizzie Arnot.

Narumi Miura (Japan) wins a free kick in the defensive half.


As It Stood


4South Korea200206-60


4South Africa200214-30






4New Zealand100101-10


View full Women's World Cup tables

Top Stories