Scottish Premiership
DundeeDundee1St MirrenSt Mirren1

Dundee 1-1 St Mirren: Penalty call wrong, insists McIntyre

By Jonathan SutherlandBBC Scotland at Dens Park

St Mirren were wrongly awarded a penalty in their draw at Dens Park, insists Dundee boss Jim McIntyre.

Simeon Jackson put the Buddies ahead from the spot against the run of play but Kenny Miller levelled with his first Dundee goal as the Premiership's bottom two ended all square.

"It's definitely not a penalty," lamented McIntyre.

"It's very soft but the reaction was great and the most important thing was my players' response."

Dundee remain bottom of the table, a point behind St Mirren, with the hosts ending a run of five defeats, while the Buddies' losing streak had stood at seven.

"We deserved to win," added McIntyre. "We had the stronger chances.

"We had a far better tempo, the way I want to play, and got ourselves into some really dangerous positions."

St Mirren manager Oran Kearney was disappointed to see his side fall out of the game but thought there should have been a second penalty for a challenge on Danny Mullen late on.

"Danny is between the full-back and the goal, he's on the six yard line about to drill the ball and as he swings contact is made," he said.

"For 25 minutes after we scored we got the wrong reaction. Rabbit in the headlights possibly, 'what's happened here?', that type of thing."

Honours even at Dens Park

This game could have gone either way as a spectacle - a tense nervous affair, or would both sides go for it? Thankfully, it was the latter and it made for a good watch.

Dundee knew they needed to do something about their toothlessness - zero shots on target in their past two matches - and they created the better chances initially. But that must have made going behind all the more galling.

The nature of the St Mirren penalty will also rankle. Jackson went down far too easily under virtually no challenge at all from Cammy Kerr. Unperturbed, Jackson dusted himself down to slam the spot-kick into the net via the crossbar.

It would be an eventful afternoon for the striker who was later booked for simulation.

Simeon Jackson scores a penalty
Jackson scored his second goal for St Mirren

Dundee responded in the best possible way. Benjamin Kallman's ball across the box arrived at the feet of captain Miller, who slammed the ball home high into the net. With the roar that went up around this old stadium it sounded almost as if Dundee had won the Premiership.

Overall, the Dark Blues had the better of things in the second half but they just could not find another goal. Both sides deserve credit for putting so much into the match.

'Stats remain grim for both sides' - analysis

Winning this match would have meant so much for both sides. Equally, losing would have been enormously significant.

The nature of how both sides played must have pleased both managers. There was little sign of the pressure that you might expect from two sides struggling for form and results, most of the play was open and enjoyable to watch.

But the stats remain grim for both sides. Dundee now with just one win in 14 games, St Mirren with zero wins in 13 matches.



Formation 4-4-2

  • 1Hamilton
  • 2Kerr
  • 5Kusunga
  • 6O'DeaBooked at 78mins
  • 3Ralph
  • 27Curran
  • 4Woods
  • 8Kamara
  • 17MillerSubstituted forNabiat 64'minutes
  • 20MillerSubstituted forMcGowanat 79'minutes
  • 19KallmanSubstituted forMoussaat 73'minutes


  • 9Moussa
  • 12Parish
  • 14Nabi
  • 15Inniss
  • 18McGowan
  • 28Spence
  • 47Lambert

St Mirren

Formation 4-4-2

  • 1Samson
  • 2McGinnBooked at 78mins
  • 35Ferdinand
  • 19Jones
  • 39ErhahonSubstituted forSmithat 82'minutes
  • 16McShaneSubstituted forMcGinnat 61'minutes
  • 7Magennis
  • 21Hodson
  • 27EdwardsBooked at 33mins
  • 11JacksonBooked at 69mins
  • 77HammillSubstituted forMullenat 66'minutes


  • 4McGinn
  • 10Smith
  • 15Baird
  • 18Mullen
  • 20Cooke
  • 22Willock
  • 25Rogers
Bobby Madden

Match Stats

Home TeamDundeeAway TeamSt Mirren
Shots on Target

Live Text

  1. Post update

    Match ends, Dundee 1, St. Mirren 1.

  2. Full Time

    Second Half ends, Dundee 1, St. Mirren 1.

  3. Post update

    Attempt missed. Ryan Edwards (St. Mirren) right footed shot from outside the box is close, but misses to the right.

  4. Post update

    Foul by Martin Woods (Dundee).

  5. Post update

    Daniel Mullen (St. Mirren) wins a free kick in the attacking half.

  6. Post update

    Foul by Nathan Ralph (Dundee).

  7. Post update

    Cameron Smith (St. Mirren) wins a free kick on the right wing.

  8. Post update

    Foul by Martin Woods (Dundee).

  9. Post update

    Stephen McGinn (St. Mirren) wins a free kick in the attacking half.

  10. Post update

    Foul by Jesse Curran (Dundee).

  11. Post update

    Kyle Magennis (St. Mirren) wins a free kick in the defensive half.

  12. Post update

    Attempt saved. Kyle Magennis (St. Mirren) left footed shot from outside the box is saved in the bottom right corner.

  13. Post update

    Attempt missed. Paul McGowan (Dundee) right footed shot from outside the box is close, but misses to the right.

  14. Post update

    Foul by Sofien Moussa (Dundee).

  15. Post update

    Kyle Magennis (St. Mirren) wins a free kick in the attacking half.

  16. Substitution

    Substitution, St. Mirren. Cameron Smith replaces Ethan Erhahon.

  17. Substitution

    Substitution, Dundee. Paul McGowan replaces Kenny Miller.

  18. Booking

    Darren O'Dea (Dundee) is shown the yellow card.

  19. Post update

    for dissent Darren O'Dea (Dundee).

  20. Post update

    (St. Mirren) wins a free kick in the attacking half.

As It Stood

4St Johnstone137241618-223
11St Mirren131210626-205
View full Scottish Premiership table

Top Stories

Around Scottish sport