Premier League
CardiffCardiff City0NewcastleNewcastle United0

Cardiff 0-0 Newcastle: Kenedy misses late penalty for 10-man Magpies

By Dafydd PritchardBBC Sport Wales at the Cardiff City Stadium
Isaac Hayden
Newcastle's Isaac Hayden was sent off 21 minutes after coming on as a second-half substitute

Cardiff City goalkeeper Neil Etheridge saved an injury-time penalty from 10-man Newcastle United's Kenedy, as the newly promoted hosts earned a first point of the Premier League season in dramatic fashion.

A full-blooded and evenly contested first half contained chances at both ends, and Kenedy was lucky not to be sent off for kicking Victor Camarasa off the ball.

Backed by a raucous home crowd, Cardiff dominated after the break and should have led when Kenneth Zohore headed wide, before Newcastle substitute Isaac Hayden was dismissed for scything down Josh Murphy from behind.

Zohore had another chance to score with a close-range header that was cleared off the line by Jacob Murphy, but Rafael Benitez' side reorganised efficiently and were awarded a penalty deep into added time when Bluebirds captain Sean Morrison handled a cross from Yoshinori Muto.

However, for a second match in succession, Etheridge saved a spot-kick to prompt jubilant celebrations among Cardiff fans who minutes earlier had seemed disappointed by the prospect of a goalless draw.

It was a memorable moment for the home side, albeit one which perhaps masked their attacking deficiencies as they failed to score and managed just one shot on target for a second game in a row.

Kenedy's match to forget

Graphic showing that Newcastle midfielder Kenedy failed to complete a pass during the first half

Newcastle's loss to Tottenham on the opening weekend was set against a backdrop of discontent among the Magpies' supporters, who protested against Mike Ashley's ownership before kick-off after another acrimonious summer during which the club had to defend their transfer strategy.

That ill feeling was offset slightly by the team's competitive display against Spurs, though they struggled to play at the same level in south Wales.

Benitez's men created a handful of chances - with Etheridge making some decent saves - but they were fortunate not to be reduced to 10 men before half-time.

After losing possession, midfielder Kenedy lunged towards Cardiff's Camarasa and, after the ball had gone, he took a wild swipe at the Spaniard's legs - which referee Craig Pawson somehow missed.

It capped a first half the Brazilian is likely to want to forget - as he became the first player since 2010 to play 45 minutes or more in a Premier League match without completing a single pass.

Keeping Kenedy on the pitch was a reprieve for Newcastle, but they had no such fortune when Hayden - filling in at right-back after replacing the injured Javier Manquillo at half-time - caught Murphy above his ankle with a reckless lunge from behind.

Hayden may have trudged off the field fearing he would be cast as the villain of the piece, but Kenedy's final act of the game - a tame penalty comfortably saved by Etheridge to deny Newcastle an improbable win - meant that role would be his.

"Kenedy struggled today, he didn't complete a pass in the first half" said former England defender Alex Scott on Final Score. " Sometimes as a player when things are not going your way you think 'I'll step up and score to get me on my way', but that didn't happen for him today.

Etheridge to Cardiff's rescue

Picture of Cardiff keeper Neil Etheridge saving Newcastle midfielder Kenedy's stoppage-time penalty
Neil Etheridge saved his second successive penalty this season

Cardiff had endured a chastening re-introduction to the Premier League when they were outplayed for much of their 2-0 defeat at Bournemouth on the opening weekend.

Their brief moments of encouragement on that occasion came from set-pieces - and it was a similar tale here, with Sol Bamba close to scoring with a header which was blocked by Ayoze Perez.

While their threat from corners and free-kicks remained, Cardiff were vastly better in open play on Saturday.

Debutants Harry Arter and Camarasa gave them control and a greater share of possession in midfield, while winger Josh Murphy - twin of Newcastle's Jacob - was a handful on his first start for the club.

And although the new signings were integral to Cardiff's improvement, it was one of the players who helped them win promotion from the Championship who proved to be their saviour.

Etheridge had marked his top-flight debut with a penalty save from Callum Wilson last weekend, and while that did not affect the outcome, his stop from Kenedy was a match-defining intervention.

Having become the first Filipino to play in the Premier League against the Cherries, it was also another bit of history for the goalkeeper - denying Kenedy made him the first keeper to save a penalty in each of his first two appearances in the division.

Man of the match - Josh Murphy

Josh Murphy in action for Cardiff City against Newcastle
Harry Arter and Victor Camarasa improved Cardiff's midfield but it was Murphy who provided the greatest goal threat, running at Newcastle's defenders with pace and purpose

'A poor penalty'

Newcastle manager Rafael Benitez on Match of the Day: "It was a difficult game against a physical team, and we played a lot with 10 players.

"We had Javier Manquillo who was injured and then Hayden came in and got sent off - so we had too many problems. In the end to get a point, it could be better, but we cannot complain too much."

On Kenedy's miss: "It was a poor penalty, he's not happy he missed a good chance. We win as a team and lose as a team. I am not concerned about the fact he missed a penalty - he has to take responsibility."

Kenedy penalty was poor, but we lose as a team - Rafael Benitez

Cardiff boss Neil Warnock on Match of the Day: "I don't think the lads deserved to lose with a penalty like that.

"Kenedy was a lucky lad [when he kicked out]. There is stuff to work on for us - we were disappointing with our free-kicks.

"No disrespect, but having watched Birmingham last night, thank goodness we came out to a full house to play Newcastle in the Premier League."

Warnock says Kenedy penalty miss was 'poetic justice'

Benitez's milestone and Cardiff's goal drought

  • Cardiff have failed to score in three consecutive league games for the first time since November 2015.
  • Newcastle are now unbeaten in their past 11 league meetings with Cardiff - winning 10 - since a 0-1 defeat in February 1981.
  • Cardiff have failed to score in their opening two games of a top-flight season for the first time since 1952-53.
  • Benitez oversaw his 50th Premier League game as Newcastle manager - he has won 15, drawn 13 and lost 22.
  • Cardiff manager Warnock is now winless in his past 10 matches against Newcastle (W0 D3 L7), since a 1-0 win as Sheffield United boss in November 2006.
  • Only Everton (nine), Blackburn (seven) and Southampton (six) have had more substitutes sent off in the Premier League than Newcastle (five, also Manchester City, Manchester United and Sunderland).
  • Etheridge is the first goalkeeper to save a penalty in two consecutive Premier League appearances in the same season since Thomas Sorensen for Stoke (against Arsenal and Wigan Athletic) in December 2009.

What's next?

Cardiff travel to Huddersfield next Saturday (15:00 BST kick-off), while Newcastle host Chelsea on Sunday, 26 August (16:00).



Formation 4-3-3

  • 1Etheridge
  • 5Ecuele Manga
  • 4Morrison
  • 22Bamba
  • 3Bennett
  • 21CamarasaBooked at 62minsSubstituted forReidat 76'minutes
  • 8Ralls
  • 7ArterBooked at 80mins
  • 33HoilettSubstituted forPatersonat 83'minutes
  • 10Zohore
  • 11MurphySubstituted forMendez-Laingat 78'minutes


  • 6Richards
  • 12Smithies
  • 13Paterson
  • 14Reid
  • 18Cunningham
  • 19Mendez-Laing
  • 24Madine


Formation 4-4-1-1

  • 12Dubravka
  • 19ManquilloBooked at 30minsSubstituted forHaydenat 45'minutesBooked at 66mins
  • 6Lascelles
  • 2Clark
  • 3Dummett
  • 11RitchieBooked at 3minsSubstituted forMurphyat 70'minutes
  • 8Shelvey
  • 10Diamé
  • 15Kenedy
  • 17PérezSubstituted forMutoat 65'minutes
  • 21Joselu


  • 4Ki Sung-yueng
  • 7Murphy
  • 9Rondón
  • 13Muto
  • 14Hayden
  • 18Fernandez
  • 26Darlow
Craig Pawson

Match Stats

Home TeamCardiffAway TeamNewcastle
Shots on Target

Live Text

  1. Post update

    Match ends, Cardiff City 0, Newcastle United 0.

  2. Full Time

    Second Half ends, Cardiff City 0, Newcastle United 0.

  3. Post update

    Penalty saved! Kenedy (Newcastle United) fails to capitalise on this great opportunity, left footed shot saved in the centre of the goal.

  4. Post update

    Penalty conceded by Sean Morrison (Cardiff City) with a hand ball in the penalty area.

  5. Post update

    Foul by Kenneth Zohore (Cardiff City).

  6. Post update

    Ciaran Clark (Newcastle United) wins a free kick in the defensive half.

  7. Post update

    Joe Bennett (Cardiff City) wins a free kick in the defensive half.

  8. Post update

    Foul by Yoshinori Muto (Newcastle United).

  9. Post update

    Foul by Bruno Ecuele Manga (Cardiff City).

  10. Post update

    Kenedy (Newcastle United) wins a free kick in the defensive half.

  11. Post update

    Attempt missed. Joselu (Newcastle United) right footed shot from the left side of the box misses to the right following a set piece situation.

  12. Post update

    Attempt blocked. Kenedy (Newcastle United) left footed shot from outside the box is blocked.

  13. Post update

    Foul by Harry Arter (Cardiff City).

  14. Post update

    Mohamed Diamé (Newcastle United) wins a free kick in the attacking half.

  15. Post update

    Attempt missed. Kenneth Zohore (Cardiff City) header from the centre of the box misses to the right. Assisted by Callum Paterson.

  16. Post update

    Attempt blocked. Kenneth Zohore (Cardiff City) header from the left side of the six yard box is blocked.

  17. Post update

    Attempt blocked. Callum Paterson (Cardiff City) header from the centre of the box is blocked. Assisted by Joe Ralls with a cross.

  18. Post update

    Corner, Cardiff City. Conceded by Jamaal Lascelles.

  19. Post update

    Attempt blocked. Joselu (Newcastle United) left footed shot from the centre of the box is blocked. Assisted by Jonjo Shelvey.

  20. Post update

    Foul by Harry Arter (Cardiff City).


Join the conversation

These comments are now closed.


Top Stories

Elsewhere on the BBC