Premier League
Man UtdManchester United0Man CityManchester City0

Manchester Utd 0-0 Manchester City

By Phil McNultyChief football writer at Old Trafford
Jesse Lingard
Jesse Lingard hit the crossbar for Manchester United

Manchester United and Manchester City played out a dull deadlock in their derby at Old Trafford.

City returned to the top of the Premier League ahead of Arsenal on goal difference - but there was little else to celebrate in a dire game devoid of attacking quality.

What few chances there were fell to United. Substitute Jesse Lingard hit the bar late on and City keeper Joe Hart saved well from Chris Smalling.

United defender Marcos Rojo and City's Nicolas Otamendi were both outstanding as Old Trafford's atmosphere was muted long before the final whistle.

Rooney lacking spark

Wayne Rooney graphic

Wayne Rooney celebrated his 30th birthday on Saturday, but did not produce a performance to get the home supporters in the party mood.

It was not for want of trying as Rooney tirelessly tried to exert influence on a game where both sides cancelled each other out for long periods.

His performance prompted more post-match questions from the media, which United boss Louis van Gaal said he was "sick" of answering.

There is no doubt, however, that some of the old snap and spark is currently missing, ending in Rooney treading the familiar territory of a player almost trying too hard to make things happen.

Rooney having a head wound stapled on the touchline was arguably the most eye-catching moment of a dreadful first half, where his struggles were underlined with one wayward pass that ended a promising United move.

And there were howls of frustration from United's fans after the break when he decided against trying to pick out an option further forward, turning to pass back.

Rooney has had such fallow spells before and has invariably ended them in spectacular style so only a fool would write him off - but this was not his best day.

City wide men fail to fire

Kevin de Bruyne and Raheem Sterling
De Bruyne's passing accuracy was only 60.9% - although Sterling actually completed 93.8% of his

Manchester City spent in excess of £100m on Raheem Sterling from Liverpool and Kevin de Bruyne from Wolfsburg to add extra potency to their attack.

The £55m Belgian De Bruyne and Sterling, who cost £49m, have both sparkled since the start of the season but failed to flourish in their first Manchester derby, with the latter only lasting 55 minutes before he was replaced by Jesus Navas.

Sterling's main contribution was to almost give away a very soft penalty when he tangled with United's Ander Herrera in the second half. He wore the look of a very relieved man when referee Mark Clattenburg ignored the appeals of Old Trafford.

De Bruyne saw more of the ball, especially on the right flank before he was switched to the left in the second half. However, his delivery was uncharacteristically poor.

There is plenty more to come from both of these fine young players but, like so much else on offer at Old Trafford, they were unable to rise above the general mediocrity.

Old Trafford bored into submission

The empty seats and relative silence around Old Trafford in the closing moments illustrated just how poor this 170th Manchester derby was.

It took 82 minutes for a shot on target, or an apology of one - a Navas effort that rolled through to United keeper David de Gea.

United control remarkable - Van Gaal

Smalling brought that good save out of Hart late on but this was one of the worst derbies in recent memory.

City have had spectacular wins such as the 6-1 thrashing of United here in October 2011, and they were arguably even more convincing in a 3-0 win over David Moyes' team in March 2014.

Van Gaal's United were outstanding in a 4-2 derby win at Old Trafford last April. All of those were games contained the elements of excitement this bore draw did not.

Lacking attacking ambition and cutting edge, both sides cancelled each other out for long periods in a game that will have been forgotten by most fans as soon as the final whistle blew.

Man of the match - Nicolas Otamendi (Manchester City)

Nicolas Otamendi
Otamendi had 76 touches and won 71.4% of his duels - both more than any other City player

Powerful in the air and on the ground, the £32m summer signing from Valencia was a reassuring presence alongside returning captain Vincent Kompany, justifying Manuel Pellegrini's decision to pick him ahead of Eliaquim Mangala.

'Not an attractive game' - managers react

Manchester City boss Manuel Pellegrini: "We are back at the top of the table.

"It was a very tactical game. I prefer to play in another way but we defended well.

"Unfortunately for the fans it was not a very attractive game. We are two creative teams but we could not do it today."

Manchester United manager Louis van Gaal: "We had 90 minutes control of the game against a side like Manchester City. I cannot complain. But you want to win and we did not.

"We should have had a penalty on Ander Herrera. It is easy to see for me but I have a replay. The referee has one second.

"I always say we need the modern technology but I am the only one in the desert calling for it."

The stats you need to know

  • This is only the third goalless Manchester derby in the Premier League era.
  • It is the first time in 13 Manchester derbies in all competitions where the game has ended in a draw.
  • It is Manchester City's first goalless Premier League draw in their last 61 games, the last draw was 0-0 v Norwich in February 2014.
  • It is only the second Premier League game this season not to have a shot on target in the first half, along with United v Liverpool.
  • Manchester United failed to muster a single shot in the first half of a Premier League game for the first time since the 2003-04 season.

What's up next?

Both sides are in League Cup fourth-round action on Wednesday - United are at home to Middlesbrough and City host Crystal Palace.

On Saturday in the Premier League United go to Palace, while City host Norwich.


Man Utd

  • 1de Gea
  • 25A ValenciaSubstituted forDarmianat 81'minutes
  • 4Jones
  • 12Smalling
  • 5Rojo
  • 28SchneiderlinBooked at 89mins
  • 31SchweinsteigerSubstituted forFellainiat 75'minutes
  • 8MataBooked at 39minsSubstituted forLingardat 67'minutes
  • 21Herrera
  • 9Martial
  • 10Rooney


  • 7Depay
  • 16Carrick
  • 17Blind
  • 20Romero
  • 27Fellaini
  • 35Lingard
  • 36Darmian

Man City

  • 1Hart
  • 3Sagna
  • 4KompanyBooked at 45mins
  • 30Otamendi
  • 11Kolarov
  • 6Reges
  • 25FernandinhoBooked at 15mins
  • 17De Bruyne
  • 42Y TouréSubstituted forDemichelisat 77'minutes
  • 7SterlingSubstituted forNavasat 55'minutes
  • 14BonySubstituted forIheanachoat 83'minutes


  • 5Zabaleta
  • 13Caballero
  • 15Navas
  • 20Mangala
  • 26Demichelis
  • 27Roberts
  • 72Iheanacho
Mark Clattenburg

Match Stats

Home TeamMan UtdAway TeamMan City
Shots on Target

Live Text

  1. Post update

    Match ends, Manchester United 0, Manchester City 0.

  2. Full Time

    Second Half ends, Manchester United 0, Manchester City 0.

  3. Post update

    Corner, Manchester City. Conceded by Matteo Darmian.

  4. Booking

    Morgan Schneiderlin (Manchester United) is shown the yellow card for a bad foul.

  5. Post update

    Foul by Morgan Schneiderlin (Manchester United).

  6. Post update

    Kevin De Bruyne (Manchester City) wins a free kick in the attacking half.

  7. Post update

    Attempt blocked. Wayne Rooney (Manchester United) right footed shot from outside the box is blocked.

  8. Post update

    Corner, Manchester United. Conceded by Joe Hart.

  9. Post update

    Attempt saved. Chris Smalling (Manchester United) right footed shot from the centre of the box is saved in the bottom right corner. Assisted by Marouane Fellaini with a headed pass.

  10. Post update

    Marouane Fellaini (Manchester United) wins a free kick in the attacking half.

  11. Post update

    Foul by Vincent Kompany (Manchester City).

  12. Post update

    Foul by Ander Herrera (Manchester United).

  13. Post update

    Aleksandar Kolarov (Manchester City) wins a free kick on the left wing.

  14. Post update

    Foul by Wayne Rooney (Manchester United).

  15. Post update

    Nicolás Otamendi (Manchester City) wins a free kick in the defensive half.

  16. Post update

    Jesse Lingard (Manchester United) hits the bar with a right footed shot from the centre of the box. Assisted by Anthony Martial with a through ball.

  17. Post update

    Marouane Fellaini (Manchester United) wins a free kick in the defensive half.

  18. Post update

    Foul by Fernando (Manchester City).

  19. Substitution

    Substitution, Manchester City. Kelechi Iheanacho replaces Wilfried Bony.

  20. Post update

    Foul by Wayne Rooney (Manchester United).

As It Stood

1Man City107122481622
3West Ham106222213920
4Man Utd10622158720
7Crystal Palace105051211115
10West Brom10424811-314
20Aston Villa10118917-84
View full Premier League table

Top Stories