Main content
Sorry, this episode is not currently available


Episode 2 of 4

Art series with Fiona Bruce and Philip Mould. The team investigate whether a painting is really the work of celebrated impressionist Pierre-Auguste Renoir.

Nicky Philipps, a portrait artist renowned for her pictures of the royal family, has asked the Fake or Fortune team to investigate a painting which hangs on the walls of Picton Castle, once the Philipps family seat. The work was bought in the 1930s by Nicky's great-grandfather, Sir Laurence Philipps, who believed it to be by celebrated impressionist Pierre-Auguste Renoir. But the painting has been dogged by doubt for half a century, and two art world authorities can't agree whether it's genuine or fake.

Nicky's late Aunt Gwen used to tell a tantalising story that the painting came from Claude Monet's house in Giverny and was a gift to the artist from Renoir at a time when they painted together. But a family anecdote isn't enough to convince the art world's toughest judges - the team must find hard evidence.

The trail takes Philip to Argenteuil, a suburb of Paris which was once an impressionist playground. During the 1870s, Renoir and Monet worked here together, often painting the same views side by side. But can Philip find any evidence that Nicky's picture was painted here?

Fiona picks up the provenance trail at Monet's house in Giverny, where she tries to find proof that the painting once hung in his personal art collection. To find out, she must access some closely guarded archives in Paris.

Philip travels to Berlin to see if cutting-edge technology can determine whether the pigments in Nicky's painting match up to those listed by Renoir himself. Can a special camera see through the canvas to reveal clues hidden from view?

Along the way, Fiona discovers that the picture is caught between two rival art world authorities - the Bernheim-Jeune Gallery and the Wildenstein Institute, who both believe their word is the last word when it comes to Renoir.

59 minutes


Music Played

Timings (where shown) are from the start of the programme in hours and minutes

  • 00:01

    Nic Raine, City of Prague Philharmonic Orchestra


  • 00:28

    City of Prague Philharmonic / Raine



Role Contributor
Presenter Fiona Bruce
Presenter Philip Mould
Expert Bendor Grosvenor
Producer Nicky Illis
Series Producer Robert Murphy


  • Sun 12 Jul 2015 20:15
  • Sun 19 Jul 2015 20:05
  • Sun 17 Sep 2017 20:00
  • Mon 28 Sep 2020 20:00
  • Tue 29 Sep 2020 00:30

Meet the Fake or Fortune? team

Meet the Fake or Fortune? team

Discover more about our art sleuths.

About the artists

About the artists

Discover more about the creators behind the works featured in the series.

Science in the series

Science in the series

Read more about the techniques used in the series

Have you found a sleeper?

Have you found a sleeper?

Read our top tips on finding a sleeper and get in touch.