Main content
Sorry, this episode is not currently available

Turner: A Miscarriage of Justice?

Episode 2 of 3

Fiona Bruce and Philip Mould investigate three landscapes once thought to be by JMW Turner, which were bequeathed to the National Museum of Wales.

In the early years of the 20th century, spinster sisters Gwendoline and Margaret Davies spent much of their vast fortune buying the cream of European art as a gift to the people of Wales. When Gwendoline died in 1951, all the paintings in her collection were bequeathed to the National Museum of Wales. Amongst the works most proudly displayed were many by JMW Turner, perhaps the nation's best loved artist. These paintings were the pinnacle of the sisters' collection, carefully selected and greatly valued.

Yet within months of this extraordinary act of generosity, the authenticity of the paintings was thrown into doubt by art world experts who branded them fakes. These prized exhibits were deemed 'unfit to hang on the gallery's walls'. For more than half a century a cloud has hung over three of the landscapes, said by experts to be a hand other than Turner's. But Philip believes this may be a miscarriage of justice. As Philip and Fiona investigate, they enter a murky world as they discover the paintings are connected to Turner's secret lover. In the end it will be down to the latest forensic testing in order to prove if the paintings were by Joseph Mallord William Turner. But will the process restore the Davies sisters' reputations as art connoisseurs and allow the pictures to see the light of day once again?

59 minutes


Music Played

Add music you love and enjoy it with My Tracks

Timings (where shown) are from the start of the programme in hours and minutes


Role Contributor
Presenter Philip Mould
Presenter Fiona Bruce
Presenter Fiona Bruce
Producer Nicky Illis
Director Nicky Illis
Series Producer Simon Shaw
Series Producer Simon Shaw


  • Sun 23 Sep 2012 17:00
  • Sun 23 Sep 2012 19:00
  • Sat 8 Dec 2012 02:00

Meet the Fake or Fortune? team

Discover more about our art sleuths.

About the artists

Discover more about the creators behind the works featured in the series.

Science in the series

Read more about the techniques used in the series