Main content

Musselburgh, East Lothian

Jonathan Dimbleby chairs a live discussion of news and politics from Loretto School in East Lothian with Michael Moore, Margaret Curran, John Swinney and Lesley Riddoch.

Jonathan Dimbleby chairs a live discussion of news and politics from Loretto School in Musselburgh, East Lothian with Secretary of State for Scotland, Michael Moore; Shadow Secretary of State for Scotland, Margaret Curran; journalist and broadcaster, Lesley Riddoch; and Scottish Finance Secretary, SNP MSP John Swinney.

Producer: Victoria Wakely.

Available now

48 minutes

Last on

Sat 14 Jan 2012 13:10

Chapters

  • British identity

    Question One: Do all the members of the panel feel British?

    Duration: 10:47

  • Scottish Referendum

    Question Two: Scotland is part of a United Kingdom. Why is it democratic to exclude the majority of the electorate in England, the Six Counties and Wales from a referendum on that Union?

    Duration: 06:08

  • Voting age in the Referendum

    Question Three: Does the panel believe that sixteen or seventeen year-olds should be able to vote?

    Duration: 05:25

  • Scottish Independence and finance

    Question Four: Can Scotland afford to be independent?

    Duration: 13:06

  • Devo-max

    Question Five: Will devo-max really secure Scotland's economic, social and political future?

    Duration: 10:21

Broadcasts

  • Fri 13 Jan 2012 20:00
  • Sat 14 Jan 2012 13:10

Download: Political Thinking with Nick Robinson

Download: Political Thinking with Nick Robinson

High-powered discussions that explore the big themes which are shaping our politics.

Jonathan Dimbleby’s Seven Surprising Moments from Any Questions?

Jonathan Dimbleby’s Seven Surprising Moments from Any Questions?

A 70th-birthday look at the ups and down of Any Questions?

Any Answers?

Any Answers?

Listeners respond to the issues raised in the preceding edition of Any Questions?