US & Canada

Why is in-flight turbulence so unpredictable?

A Boeing 777-333 is pictured

An Air Canada flight bound for Toronto from Shanghai made an emergency landing after severe turbulence injured 21 passengers, including three children.

The plane was diverted to Calgary after turbulence hit and the injured are in a stable condition.

Turbulence injuries cannot always be prevented by passengers wearing seatbelts when instructed to do so, and turbulence cannot always be predicted.

So what causes plane turbulence in the skies? The list is long.

According to to the Federal Aviation Administration, turbulence can be caused by:

  • air movement not normally seen
  • atmospheric pressure
  • jet streams
  • air around mountains
  • cold or warm weather fronts
  • thunderstorms

In-air turbulence is the leading cause of injury to people on flights, according to the FAA, and on average 58 people in the US are injured during turbulent flights when not wearing seatbelts every year.

Most turbulence accidents happen at 30,000 ft (9144m) or above.

Passengers on the Air Canada flight said the turbulence happened suddenly, with blankets flying up to the ceiling, people screaming and the plane feeling "like a rollercoaster".

Media playback is unsupported on your device
Media captionPassengers described blankets and even people "flying" up to the plane's ceiling

'It happens in all types of weather'

Turbulence can happen unexpectedly at any time, no matter the weather, Mark Weiss, a former American Airlines pilot of 23 years, told the BBC.

"It's just a natural phenomena of weather," he said. "You can't always predict it. It could be as clear as could be, and you could get caught in a jet stream."

Airlines are diligent about turning on the "fasten seatbelt" sign if turbulence is predicted, but sometimes it comes out of nowhere, and a seatbelt can only do so much, he said.

Pilots can be tipped off to upcoming turbulence by fellow pilots flying ahead, in some cases.

A passenger can be wearing a seatbelt too loosely and still be knocked out by severe turbulence-by horizontal or vertical lifting, even getting thrown to the ceiling.

People with children on their laps need to be especially careful. Those children are basically "flying objects," he said.

Image copyright Getty Images
Image caption Sometimes seatbelts cannot prevent injury

Turbulence can cause baggage bins to unlock and suitcases to fall on people, causing injury, or food and beverage carts can get loose.

Mr Weiss recalls flying from Puerto Rico and experiencing severe turbulence.

"There were broken glasses from dishes... one flight attendant hit the ceiling, landed on arm rest and detached a retina in her eye."

Mr Weiss has seen broken arms, broken noses and back and neck injuries from turbulence.

Despite warnings, some people are always going to stand up on a long flight to go to the restroom, retrieve water or stretch out, even if the seatbelt sign is on.

The best thing for passengers to do is listen to the crew when turbulence hits, he said.

More on this story