BBC News

Africa internet: Where and how are governments blocking it?

By Christopher Giles and Peter Mwai
BBC Reality Check

Published
Related Topics
  • Reality Check
image copyrightGetty Images
image captionCases of countries restricting internet access have been rising

No Facebook, Twitter or WhatsApp.

That's becoming more and more common in some African countries, where governments have periodically shut down the internet or blocked social media platforms.

Digital rights activists say it's censorship, but governments argue it helps maintain security.

So where and how in Africa is internet access being restricted?

Which African countries are blocking access?

A government can restrict access by ordering internet service providers (ISPs) to limit access to their subscribers.

In the first instance, this is likely to be a block on commonly used social media sites.

As a more extreme measure, the authorities can order service providers to block all internet access.

image copyrightGetty Images
image captionTanzania polling station: Internet access was restricted during the elections

Cases of internet shutdowns in Africa have been rising.

Tanzania restricted access to the internet and social media applications during the recent elections.

In June this year, Ethiopia imposed an internet shutdown which lasted for close to a month in response to unrest which followed the killing of a prominent Oromo singer and activist Hachalu Hundessa.

Zimbabwe, Togo, Burundi, Chad, Mali and Guinea have also restricted access to the internet or social media applications at some point this year.

In 2019, there were 25 documented instances of partial or total internet shutdowns, compared with 20 in 2018 and 12 in 2017, according to Access Now, an independent monitoring group.

Internet shutdowns in Africa. .  This includes complete outages, social media shutdowns and throttling..

And the group says that in 2019, seven of the 14 countries that blocked access had not done so in the two previous years.

The new countries were Benin, Gabon, Eritrea, Liberia, Malawi, Mauritania and Zimbabwe.

This is part of a global trend, where more and more countries are restricting internet access, up to 213 shutdowns globally compared with 106 in 2017.

The group says in Africa, most lockdowns tend to affect entire countries as opposed to specific regions or groups of people.

Last year, 21 out of the 25 shutdowns recorded by the group affected entire countries or most parts of the countries.

Only Sudan and Ethiopia had targeted shutdowns.

"This indicates that shutdowns are not only growing in number, but are also expanding in scope and affecting more and more people in Africa," the group says.

How is internet access blocked?

In each country, it's down to the individual service providers to carry out instructions from the authorities to block access.

One method used is known as URL-based blocking.

This is a filter which prevents access to a list of banned sites.

A user trying to access these sites might see various messages such as "server not found" or "this site has been blocked by the network administrator".

image copyrightGetty Images
image captionAccess to the internet was tightly controlled during protests in Zimbabwe

Another method is called throttling.

This approach severely limits traffic to specific sites, giving the impression that the service is slow, thereby discouraging access.

This is more subtle, as it's difficult to know whether sites are being actively restricted or whether poor broadband infrastructure is to blame.

As a final measure, telecoms companies can be required to shut down their services entirely, preventing all data access.

Can service providers say no?

The ability of governments to censor the internet depends on their ability to exercise control over telecommunications companies.

Internet service providers are licensed by governments, which means they risk fines or the loss of their contracts.

image copyrightGetty Images
image captionMore and more people own smartphones in African countries

Operators may have the right to appeal to the courts, but in practice they rarely do.

However, there have been exceptions.

Last year, the courts in Zimbabwe ruled in favour of reinstating internet access after the government ordered restrictions.

In response, the government implemented new regulations allowing them greater control over the internet.

Zimbabwe's information minister Monica Mutsvangwa says this will "ensure that internet and related technologies are used for the good of society, not to violate national security."

There are also examples where governments wishing to shut down the net have an easier task.

"There are exceptions like Ethiopia where telecommunications is still not liberalised", says Dawit Bekele, Africa Regional Bureau Director for the Internet Society.

"There is a de-facto single gateway owned by the government operator that can easily be used to block the Internet," he says.

image copyrightGetty Images
image captionInternet shutdowns are becoming more common, like in the Democratic Republic of Congo

Unless access to the internet has been shut down completely, there are ways that individuals can manage to evade these barriers.

The most common method is the use of virtual private networks (VPNs). These encrypt data paths, making it difficult for service providers to block access to restricted sites.

Governments can also block VPNs, but are less inclined to do so because this also severely inconveniences foreign diplomats and large companies which use them.

Some African governments have pointed to the rise of "fake news" online as a reason for enforcing restrictions.

But some analysts and opposition figures consider this an excuse for suppressing groups critical of the government, which often organise on Facebook and WhatsApp.

"Before, during and after elections, governments tend to block the internet because of dissent," says Mr Bekele.

What do you want BBC Reality Check to investigate? Get in touch

Related Topics