South East Wales

Gay clergy: Jeffrey John should be made bishop in Wales, says friend

Very Reverend Jeffrey John
Image caption Jeffrey John has twice been put forward as a bishop in the Church of England

A gay rights campaigning clergyman has called for a leading Welsh gay cleric to be made a bishop in Wales.

It follows the revelation that the Church of England has dropped its opposition to gay clergy becoming bishops if they agree to stay celibate.

The Reverend Martin Reynolds says his friend Jeffrey John, the Dean of St Albans, has been made a "whipping boy" in the row.

He told Radio Wales it would be great if he could now become a Welsh bishop.


Dr John, from Tonyrefail in Rhondda Cynon Taf, has been at the centre of the row over gay bishops having twice been put forward for the role in the Church of England.

In 2003 he declined the position of Bishop of Reading in the face of protests from traditionalists.

He was also rejected as a candidate for the Bishop of Southwark in 2010, with evidence emerging it was because of his sexual orientation.

Media playback is unsupported on your device
Media captionRev Martin Reynolds says Jeffrey John has been made a 'whipping boy' by the church

On Friday, however, it was revealed that after a decision taken last month the Church of England would allow gay men in civil partnerships to become bishops as long as they promise to be celibate.

Unlike the Church of England, the Church in Wales has never had a ban on gay clergy in civil partnerships becoming bishops.

Mr Reynolds, an Anglican priest in Newport, claimed the reason the moratorium in the Church of England was introduced 18 months ago was because Dr John was about to become Bishop of Southwark.

He told BBC Radio Wales: "Rowan [Williams, the former Archbishop of Canterbury] didn't want another furore ... they shafted Jeffrey yet again - introduced this rule that you couldn't be in a civil partnership which of course Jeffrey is with Grant [Holmes, a hospital chaplain].

"Poor old Jeffrey's been more than just a whipping boy - he's been assassinated really several times."

'Sleeping together'

Asked if there was now any realistic chance of his friend becoming a bishop in the Church in England, Mr Reynolds said: "Wouldn't it be nice if he became a bishop in the Church in Wales?"

He added that gay clergy in civil partnerships in Wales are not asked "if we do anything naughty in bed".

Asked about the question of policing the celibacy of gay clerics, Mr Reynolds said he believed honour still exists in the church.

"When Jeffrey said he and Grant weren't actually sleeping together anymore I think we all believed him.

"I don't think there was a single person ... that I ever spoke to said Jeffrey wasn't telling the truth."

Mr Reynolds also praised the Church in Wales approach on the celibacy issue.

"In Wales we've never bothered, we've never tried," he said.

"Our bishop has never introduced any such a role and, of course, we know that the archbishop of Wales has said if there was a gay man who was in a relationship who was nominated, he'd be happy to ordain him."

More on this story

Related Internet links

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites