Prime Minister's Questions: The key bits and the verdict
By Brian Wheeler
Political reporter
- Published
- comments
- Comments
Theresa May and Jeremy Corbyn have gone head-to-head in their final House of Commons Prime Minister's Questions clash of the year. What happened?
Jeremy Corbyn ended the year with an all-out attack on what he said was the winter funding crisis in the NHS. Theresa May hit back with a blizzard of statistics on cancer survival rates, diagnostic tests and operation numbers. Mr Corbyn's anger about this core Labour issue went down well with his MPs, but the prime minister was in resilient form, taunting him about the fact that she is still in her job and he will not be "prime minister by Christmas" as he had once predicted.
"Is the PM satisfied that the NHS has the resources it needs this winter?" @jeremycorbyn
— BBC Daily Politics and Sunday Politics (@daily_politics) December 20, 2017
“The health service has prepared more extensively for this winter than ever before“ @theresa_may quoting chief exec of NHS Providers #pmqs pic.twitter.com/VNM6oAWB3j
Mrs May did not address any of the figures raised by Mr Corbyn and he did not acknowledge any of her statistical claims. The two seemed to be talking about entirely different healthcare systems.
“50,000 people were left waiting no trolleys in hospital corridors last month” @jeremycorbyn
— BBC Daily Politics and Sunday Politics (@daily_politics) December 20, 2017
“He knows NHS funding is at record levels” @theresa_may #pmqs pic.twitter.com/2YfKu7tpau
"A+E depts bruising at the seams because the govt has failed to see people can get a GP appointment when they need one” asking where extra 5,000 GPs are @jeremycorbyn
— BBC Daily Politics and Sunday Politics (@daily_politics) December 20, 2017
“He should look at what Labour are actually delivering before he comes to this House and complains” @theresa_may pic.twitter.com/NOM38FcKBh
The Labour leader broadened out his litany of alleged NHS failings under this government to social care - a touchy subject for Mrs May, as it torpedoed her general election campaign.
“2.3 million older people have unmet care needs” says @jeremycorbyn asking why “not one penny” was in Budget for social care
— BBC Daily Politics and Sunday Politics (@daily_politics) December 20, 2017
"We have put £2bn into social care, we did that in Spring Budget” @theresa_may #pmqs before using a quote from Mr Corbyn saying NHS legacy was "a mess" pic.twitter.com/BOs1swTMWa
In what was increasing sounding like a greatest hits medley from both leaders, Mrs May then attacked the Labour-run NHS in Wales - Mr Corbyn said it got its money in a block grant from London.
“The PM has shown today just how out of touch is, the truth is our NHS is being recklessly, recklessly put at risk by her government” @jeremycorbyn
— BBC Daily Politics and Sunday Politics (@daily_politics) December 20, 2017
“Labour wrong, wrong, wrong” says @theresa_may while her government is delivering “a Britain fit for the future" #pmqs pic.twitter.com/1EYo8m1XaV
What else came up?
For the second week running, the SNP's leader at Westminster Iain Blackford questioned the PM about bank branch closures, and for the second week running the PM told him it was an "operational matter" for the banks. She then threw in an attack on the SNP's tax plans.
“The PM is supposed to at least try and answer the question” @IanBlackfordMP asking about bank closures telling her to “show some leadership, stand up for our communities”
— BBC Daily Politics and Sunday Politics (@daily_politics) December 20, 2017
PM said the SNP was set to raise taxes on 1.2m Scots, adding: "Conservatives back you, SNP tax you” #pmqs pic.twitter.com/42J16U5wON
Labour's Rosena Allin-Khan got the session off to an interesting start with a question on the 2,500 children in her Wandsworth constituency she said would be waking up homeless on Christmas morning. Theresa May said being homeless did not mean sleeping rough.
"When will this austerity-driven government say ‘enough is enough’ and put an end to this tragedy" @DrRosena
— BBC Daily Politics and Sunday Politics (@daily_politics) December 20, 2017
“The government has lifted hundreds of thousands of children out of absolute poverty” @theresa_may disputing claims about homeless numbers in Wandsworth #pmqs pic.twitter.com/hiB3fmtrcL
It was a long old session. Speaker John Bercow even managed to squeeze in some wedding congratulations.
The Speaker congratulates @JackLopresti on his wedding to fellow Conservative MP @andreajenkyns, before hearing his #pmqs question on defence pic.twitter.com/22GIQ8UbEg
— BBC Daily Politics and Sunday Politics (@daily_politics) December 20, 2017
Theresa May managed an ad-libbed joke at Mr Corbyn's expense at one point during the 52 minutes of exchanges.
Will the PM name her Christmas goose “Michael or Boris”, asks @CliveEfford
— BBC Daily Politics and Sunday Politics (@daily_politics) December 20, 2017
But @theresa_may replies she will “resist the temptation to call the goose Jeremy” #pmqs pic.twitter.com/kFsKlKdUyq
And finally, former Lib Dem leader Tim Farron made a rare appearance at PMQs, to be greeted by a predictable barracking from the non-Lib Dem ranks.
Former Lib Dem leader @timfarron asks @theresa_may about radiotherapy services and the travel distances for those in rural areas who need the “life-saving utterly urgent treatment” #pmqs pic.twitter.com/Xiavvf2s5g
— BBC Daily Politics and Sunday Politics (@daily_politics) December 20, 2017
And finally finally, it wasn't from PMQs, but this was an intriguing point of order from Tory MP Robert Halfon straight afterwards, whose staff found someone sleeping under a desk in his office.
The Verdict
"Mr Corbyn presents one set of statistics that look pretty bad. Mrs May presents a different set which look better, and so it goes on. You may find that illuminating, others may not" @afneil on #pmqs exchanges about the NHS pic.twitter.com/vZZ082XaLF
— BBC Daily Politics and Sunday Politics (@daily_politics) December 20, 2017
What pundits are saying on Twitter
Glum faces all round on the Labour benches as Tory MPs shout “more” at the end of the Corbyn/May ding-dong. The PM ends the year on a high. How the hell did that happen? #PMQs
— Kevin Schofield (@PolhomeEditor) December 20, 2017
May can’t escape her social care cuts, missed A&E + cancer targets, NHS unfilled vacancies & fall in GPs #PMQs
— Kevin Maguire (@Kevin_Maguire) December 20, 2017
Here is Theresa May today at #PMQs. She started and finished the year beating Jeremy Corbyn in the House of Commons. What a lot has happened in between. pic.twitter.com/63OT2n9i7h
— Christopher Hope 📝 (@christopherhope) December 20, 2017
Mother Theresa is back. “More”, shout Tory MPs. Corbyn took a proper end of term tonking from her, his Qs inexplicably weak #PMQs
— Tom Newton Dunn (@tnewtondunn) December 20, 2017
Jeremy Corbyn: 50,000 patients waiting on trolleys last month alone. Has the NHS got resources it needs to get through winter? I doubt it. #pmqs
— Jane Merrick (@janemerrick23) December 20, 2017
- 13 December 2017
- 6 December 2017
- 29 November 2017