UK Politics

English councils short-changed by UK spending formula, says LGA

Media playback is unsupported on your device
Media captionSir Merrick Cockell: "We have got to have equity"

England's communities are being "short-changed" by £4.1bn a year under the model used to allocate central government funding across the UK, the Local Government Association has said.

This money needed to be "repatriated", demanded the LGA, which represents councils in England and Wales.

It should then be used to address the "crisis engulfing adult social care", the body argued.

The UK government disputes the LGA analysis.

The model used to determine how central government funds are divided up is called the Barnett formula, after former Chief Secretary to the Treasury Lord Barnett.

Critics note that the formula is based on population and not need.

LGA chairman Sir Merrick Cockell said: "The Barnett formula has passed its use-by date. It is an historic relic from a time when the government stopped people taking more than £50 on a holiday abroad.

"What was only ever intended as a stop-gap solution has now become a major problem which is short-changing English communities and underfunding their public services by £4.1bn a year."


He argued that a "fair and equitable distribution of public money" across the UK was now needed.

"The crisis engulfing adult social care demands a shift to a needs-based formula for distributing funding," Sir Merrick continued.

"Our ageing population means that there is an enormous increase in demand for council-run adult social services, which must be met to ensure people retain dignity as they get older.

"The major political parties should all make the introduction of a needs-based formula a cornerstone of their pre-election manifestos and the chancellor should look to lay the groundwork for it in his Autumn Statement."

Debate on the Barnett formula goes to the heart of the debate on Scottish independence.

Nationalists argue Scotland gets a raw deal from the Barnett formula, but some unionists believe the formula needs changing to give Scotland more financial powers.

The Welsh government also believes it is not well served by Barnett.

Welsh ministers advocate a new needs-based formula, taking into account such things as the age of the population and poverty levels.

The Northern Ireland Executive says it is difficult to assess whether the level of funding it receives under the formula is fair.

The LGA said that England's ageing population was increasing demand for council-run adult social care services by 3% each year, meaning councils would have to find an extra £400m per annum.

Meanwhile councils' central funding was "being cut by 43%", the LGA claimed, "placing social services under enormous strain and leading to reductions in services and a tightening of eligibility criteria".

The UK government disputes the LGA's analysis, arguing that central government funding cuts are offset by increases in "spending power".

This term encompasses a number of factors, including the retention by councils of a higher proportion of taxes levied on local businesses, and "bonus" funds for councils that approve the construction of new homes.

More on this story