Government could intervene in running of Nottingham City Council

By Liam Barnes & Matt Jarram
BBC News

  • Published
Loxley House
Image caption,
The council's finances are already under the watch of a government inspector

Independent commissioners could be brought in to intervene in the running of Nottingham City Council, the government has said.

The Labour-run authority is already being monitored by a government-appointed board after the collapse of Robin Hood Energy in September 2020.

An investigation has found up to £40m was mis-spent on the wrong services.

Council leader David Mellen said the government's decision was "clearly disappointing".

The council's failed experiment with Robin Hood Energy lost taxpayers about £38m, and an improvement board was set up to monitor its recovery plan.

Earlier this year it was revealed up to £40m of ringfenced cash from the council's housing revenue account (HRA) had been misused, an increase on the estimated £16m outlined in an investigation last year.

A report found the council mis-spent up to £22.8m since 2014/15, while Nottingham City Homes - which manages the council housing stock on behalf of the authority - misused up to £17.1m.

'Minded to intervene'

In a letter published on Thursday to Sir Tony Redmond, chairman of the independent board overseeing the authority, Kemi Badenoch MP said the Secretary of State for the Department for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities, Michael Gove, "is minded to intervene" in the city council's case.

"He is satisfied on the basis of the evidence provided that Nottingham City Council is failing to comply with its Best Value duty," she said.

"He is therefore minded to exercise his Best Value powers under the Local Government Act 1999 and appoint commissioners."

Ms Badenoch's letter said all "interested parties" have until 7 July to contact Mr Gove over the proposed intervention.

Image source, LDRS
Image caption,
Council leader David Mellen said the government's decision was "clearly disappointing"

David Mellen, leader of the council since 2019, said the authority had made improvements since discovering the "significant setback" of misallocated funds last year.

"It's important to understand that we brought the matter to light ourselves," he said.

"In light of the improvements we have been making, it's clearly disappointing that the [HRA] issue has led to the government taking the action it has.

"We understand that it will be a major concern for city residents, council staff, our partners and local businesses but we are committed to working with commissioners on any further improvements we need to make."

Christina Sanna, Unison branch secretary for Nottingham City Council workers, said the union "wholly opposes" the government's proposals, labelling it "undemocratic".

"All council services should be delivered by staff working alongside the city's democratically elected representatives to deliver in the best interests of the citizens of Nottingham," she said.

'Very uncertain'

Opposition councillors said they feared for the future of the city.

Kevin Clarke, leader of Nottingham Independents, said: "When government commissioners come in, everything stops, apart from essential services so it is a pretty bleak time for the residents of Nottingham, if things were not bad enough.

He told the Local Democracy Reporting Service the blame lay with the city's Labour administration.

"They put us into this situation with Robin Hood Energy and the [HRA] was the nail in the coffin," he said.

"Does the Broadmarsh development stop? Does the fit out of the new Central Library stop? What are we going to get and not going to get? It is very uncertain times."

Councillor Andrew Rule, opposition leader of the Conservative Group, said: "This means there will now be extra levels of scrutiny on spending decisions and if they do not meet best value for money they have veto over them.

"It is nothing to do with politics - it is mismanagement and unlawful spending which has led us into this tragic situation."

When asked what it would mean for future council projects and developments, he said: "We are in uncharted territory and nothing is off the table."

Follow BBC East Midlands on Facebook, Twitter, or Instagram. Send your story ideas to

Related Internet Links

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.