Birmingham & Black Country

Nechells wall collapse deaths: Families reject inquest verdict

Victims of the wall tragedy
Image caption The workers clockwise from top left: Mahamadou Jagana, Almamo Jammeh, Saibo Sillah, Bangally Dukureh and Ousmane Diaby

The families of five men who died in a scrapyard wall collapse have rejected an inquest's accidental death verdict, believing them unlawfully killed.

The workers died when the 11.8ft (3.6m) concrete partition came down on them at Hawkeswood Metal Recycling in Birmingham in July 2016.

A jury found the risk of its collapse was never identified, despite being "foreseeable".

It also found it going unnoticed had "caused or contributed" to the deaths.

Almamo Jammeh, 45, Ousmane Diaby, 39, Bangally Dukureh, 55, Saibo Sillah, 42, and Mahamadou Jagana, 49, were clearing out a scrap metal storage bay when they died at the plant in Nechells.

Media playback is unsupported on your device
Media captionSmethwick's Gambian Islamic Community Centre has been supporting victims' families

A statement released by the families on Friday said it was clear to them the "deaths were avoidable".

They said they were "extremely disappointed" by the accidental death ruling, and "shocked" the men were killed at a plant in "one of the most developed countries in the world".

"Our loved ones did not expect to die when they went to work on 7 July 2016," the families said.

"They were honest, hardworking, decent human beings whose loss we cannot begin to measure."

The workers - four from The Gambia and one from Senegal - had been working in Spain but came to the UK after finding it increasingly difficult to find employment on the continent.

Media playback is unsupported on your device
Media captionThe widow of Bangally Dukureh has spoken through an interpreter

During two-week proceedings, the jury heard that part of a 263-tonne pile of metal briquettes - stored in an adjacent bay against the wall - had also fallen on the group when the partition gave way.

The wall had been "overloaded" by the metal against it, jurors were told, with the 3m pile stacked twice as high as was safe and proving too powerful a force for the wall's resistance.

The inquest, overseen by Birmingham and Solihull coroner Emma Brown, heard from Martyn Ostcliffe, an engineering expert at the Health and Safety Executive (HSE).

He said there were no risk assessments in place at the site and called safety inspections a "tick-box exercise", adding the wall "could have gone at any time".

Image copyright PA
Image caption It took a huge operation to recover the bodies of the five men

The HSE has told the BBC its own investigation is proceeding.

During the inquest, the jury heard from HSE investigator Paul Cooper who said "common sense" was enough to suggest the wall was at risk of collapsing and the site could have "most definitely" identified it.

Mr Ostcliffe said only a small "trigger" was needed to bring down the wall, suggesting the men's work in the neighbouring bay was enough.

Wayne Hawkeswood, managing director of Shredmet Ltd, which runs the yard, said in a statement read to the inquest on Monday that he "simply cannot comprehend how this happened".

He added: "I am absolutely devastated by the deaths of the five men and constantly think about the loss their family and friends have suffered."

The inquest heard the workers had "devastating blunt force injuries" and were identified by their fingerprints.

Related Topics

More on this story

Related Internet links

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites