A statue of railway engineer Sir Nigel Gresley has been unveiled at King's Cross station - with the notable absence of a duck to keep him company.
A mallard was originally included as Sir Nigel liked breeding water fowl and locomotives he designed, including Mallard, were named after birds.
But the Gresley Society Trust changed the design because two of his grandsons thought the duck was "demeaning".
It has not been reinstated and three trust members resigned.
The row prompted several people to bring rubber ducks to the unveiling in protest at the decision not to include the bird despite a campaign and petition.
Sir Nigel, who came from a prominent Derbyshire family, was a pioneering engineer in the early 20th Century whose designs are still used on railways today.
Philip Benham, vice-chairman of the Gresley Society Trust, said: "We acknowledge that the duck was quite a clever idea but on reflection we didn't feel it was appropriate.
"If you look at how it would appear your immediate reaction would be one of amusement.
"We felt that it didn't properly portray what this is about, which is a great locomotive and railway engineer."
Network Rail chairman Sir Peter Hendy unveiled the statue with members of Sir Nigel's family.
It was unveiled on the 75th anniversary of Sir Nigel's death, a few yards from where he had his office.
Sir Nigel Gresley
- Born on 19 June 1876
- The family home was at Netherseal in Derbyshire, where he grew up, and there are two places in the county named after the family - Church Gresley and Castle Gresley
- He began as an apprentice after leaving school and rapidly rose through the railway industry
- He is most famous for his big Pacific locomotives, including Mallard, which achieved a world speed record for steam of 126mph in 1938
- Flying Scotsman, acknowledged as the world's most famous steam engine, was also built to his design
- He was knighted for his career achievements in 1936
- He died at home unexpectedly on 5 April 1941 while still in office with the London & North Eastern Railway (LNER)
The decision to remove the duck has divided the Gresley Society Trust, and the previous vice-chairman, Andrew Dow, resigned over it.
Nigel Dant, who had the idea of putting the statue at King's Cross, has also resigned.
The society's former publicity officer Dennis Butler, who resigned too, said removing the duck was "madness".
He said the duck would have drawn people to the statue - including those who have not heard of Nigel Gresley, but have perhaps heard of Mallard.
"Sir Nigel Gresley and Mallard are synonymous around the world," said Mr Butler.
"Of course as a Gresley fan I would want there to be a statue [regardless], but it's a bit pointless putting a long-dead guy up against the wall that nobody knows."
Kevin Tribbensee, a distant relative of Sir Nigel, travelled down from Derbyshire for the unveiling.
"I quite like the idea of the duck to tell you the truth," he said.
"It might get to fisticuffs you know, between the pro and anti-duck lobby.
"Some people think it demeans him but I don't think so."