Syria: Lord Carlile urges return of control orders

Aseel (l) and Nasser Muthana
Image caption Nasser Muthana (r) features in an apparent recruitment video for jihadists in Iraq and Syria. His brother Aseel (l) was said by their father to have also travelled to Syria

The UK should reintroduce tougher measures to restrict terror activities, a former independent reviewer of terrorism laws has said.

Lord Carlile said the government needed to act to protect the public.

His call comes as an ex-MI6 director said security services would not be able to track all Britons who return to the UK after fighting in Syria.

The Metropolitan Police has insisted it has the tools to monitor British jihadists returning from that country.

Several Britons - including Reyaad Khan and Nasser Muthana from Cardiff - have featured in an apparent recruitment video for jihadists in Iraq and Syria.

Nasser Muthana's father, Ahmed Muthana, told the BBC his younger son, 17-year-old Aseel, had also gone to Syria.

The BBC has learned a third Briton in the video is from Aberdeen. The man, named locally as Raqib, grew up in Scotland but was originally from Bangladesh.

This coincides with claims from Labour MP Khalid Mahmood that up to 2,000 Britons may have been recruited by extremists.

Media playback is unsupported on your device
Media captionThis footage purports to show Reyaad Khan (C) and Nasser Muthana (R) from Wales

Former MI6 director of global counter-terrorism Richard Barrett has said security services would be unable to monitor all of the Britons who had fought in Syria when they returned.

He said the number of those posing a threat would be small but unpredictable.

Lord Carlile said Mr Barrett was "absolutely right" in his claims and that the UK "should be worried".

"The evidence is that up to 10% who go on jihad will return to this country and be interested in domestic terrorism," the Liberal Democrat peer told BBC Radio 4's World at One programme.

"It's impossible to provide surveillance for that number of people. So we need to look at preventing violent extremism before people leave the country and also we need to look for further measures."

Image copyright other
Image caption The BBC has learned a man from Aberdeen, named locally as Raqib, is identified in the video as Brother Abu Bara' al Hindi

Lord Carlile suggested reintroducing "something like control orders", which were scrapped in 2011 and replaced with the less restrictive Terrorism Prevention and Investigation Measures (TPims).

Control orders were much more restrictive, giving authorities power to relocate suspects to towns far from their home, impose 16-hour curfews and ban them from meeting named individuals and using mobile phones and the internet.

Image caption Nasser Muthana's family said it was "heartbroken"

As with TPims, those subject to control orders had to wear electronic tags and report regularly to the police.

TPims restrictions include overnight residence at a specified address and restrictions on travel, movement, association, communication, finances, work and study.

However, the Met has rejected Mr Barrett's claims and insisted it does have the power to monitors fighters returning to the UK from Syria.

Assistant Commissioner Cressida Dick told the BBC a large number of people have been either stopped from travelling to Syria or held on their return.

Police have urged Britons not to travel to Syria to fight.

They warned would-be jihadists they were likely to be killed or kidnapped if they took part in the conflict, or were likely to be arrested if they returned to the UK.

Image copyright Other
Image caption Nasser Muthana's brother Aseel, 17, is also said to have travelled to Syria

Usman Nawaz, a former member of the Young Muslim Advisory Group, described as "incredibly disturbing" a video posted by internet accounts linked to the Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant (Isis) - which has a presence in Syria and is fighting government forces in Iraq.

He told the BBC it was "extremely worrying" that young British Muslims were appealing to their peers with a "rosy, romantic HD picture of jihad".

The news that two of the Britons in the video are from Cardiff prompted claims from academic Dr Suraj Lakhani that there was an ongoing problem with the radicalisation of young Muslims in the Welsh city.

Meanwhile, Chancellor George Osborne has rejected suggestions that the monitoring of returning fighters would be hampered by a shortage of funds.

He said: "I don't think it's a question of the money, because we've not only protected the counter-terrorism budget, we've increased funding for the security services."

Have you been affected by the issues raised in this story? You can send us your experiences by emailing using the subject line "Isis".

Or you can get in touch using the form below.

Your contact details

If you are happy to be contacted by a BBC journalist please leave a telephone number that we can contact you on. In some cases a selection of your comments will be published, displaying your name as you provide it and location, unless you state otherwise. Your contact details will never be published. When sending us pictures, video or eyewitness accounts at no time should you endanger yourself or others, take any unnecessary risks or infringe any laws. Please ensure you have read the terms and conditions.

Terms and conditions

The BBC's Privacy Policy

More on this story

Related Internet links

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites