Why the Henry Cavill rumours could give Superman and DC a fresh start

By Helen Bushby
Entertainment and arts reporter

image copyrightWarner Bros

Henry Cavill's cryptic response to rumours he's hung up his Superman cape has prompted fan reactions ranging from "I am so confused" to "don't leave us".

His Instagram video sees him stare into the camera, slowly lifting and then lowering a boxed Superman doll, while The Blue Danube - which features barking dogs - plays in the background.

It follows The Hollywood Reporter saying the British actor is "parting ways with Warner Bros".

Warner has not confirmed the story.

View this post on Instagram

Today was exciting #Superman

A post shared by Henry Cavill (@henrycavill) on

"While no decisions have been made regarding any upcoming Superman films, we've always had great respect for and a great relationship with Henry Cavill, and that remains unchanged," they said in a statement to CNN.

Anna Smith, film critic and president of the Critics' Circle, told the BBC that if the speculation about Cavill leaving the role is true, she'd "love to imagine it's because he is preparing take on the role of James Bond".

She added: "The DC movies have been squandering his gift for suave comedy, which we saw in The Man from U.N.C.L.E. and which would take Bond back to the old school (minus the sexism, I hope)."

What, if anything, happened here?

Hollywood Reporter suggested negotiations with Cavill broke down over scheduling problems for a cameo appearance in upcoming film Shazam!, about a teenage boy who transforms into a superhero.

However, the actor's manager Dany Garcia suggested those reports may be premature, urging fans to "be peaceful, the cape is still in his closet".

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.View original tweet on Twitter

Many fans were keen that he should stay in the role.

image copyrightEPA
image captionCavill has a loyal following among his Superman fans

One called the speculation "a ridiculous rumour", with other comments such as "hope to God you're staying on as Superman, if not be the next Bond. Ur amazing actor".

One said: "I have decided to shift to Marvel... because Henry Cavill is the only reason for me to become DC fan..."

Some, however, had other ideas.

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites.View original tweet on Twitter

The BBC has asked Warners and Cavill's representatives for comment.

Why might Superman need a reboot?

IGN Entertainment's senior editor Scott Collura wrote that "it's insane, if not surprising, that Warner Bros doesn't have a Superman any more".

He said Warner Bros "don't know what to do with the Man of Steel".

"With Cavill apparently out, and [Batman actor] Ben Affleck rumoured to also be ready to hang up the cape and cowl, Warners and the folks behind the DC films are presented with an opportunity to soft-reboot the series," he added.

DC may be looking for a major change of direction for Superman after the runaway success of Wonder Woman, which smashed box office records last year and will be followed by a much-awaited upcoming sequel.

image copyrightWarner
image captionGal Gadot starred in Patty Jenkins' DC movie Wonder Woman

Cavill's Man of Steel "did good blockbuster business" in 2013 but "studio expectations were higher", according to Forbes.

Things didn't improve with 2016's Batman V Superman: Dawn of Justice, which got a mixed critical response and was seen as "relentlessly bleak" as well as a financial disappointment, according to Deadline Hollywood.

Roll on to 2017's Justice League, powered by a DC Comics superhero team seeking some of the huge popularity of the Avengers ensemble films.

But Justice League, with a cast including Cavill, Affleck and Gal Gadot, was an "undeniable failure" according to Forbes, because it "didn't recoup its costs".

Anna Smith adds: "In recent years, DC has found it hard to compete with the might of the Marvel movies - the Avengers gang are much sunnier and teen-friendly, while the Superman films have struggled to find the right balance between deliciously dark and downright sombre.

"Wonder Woman struck a much more upbeat and exciting tone (and in the hands of a female director, take note!)."

image copyrightWarner Bros
image captionJustice League took $229m at North American box offices

Forbes concluded: "If you're Warner Bros, you cannot simply ignore the fact your Superman has repeatedly failed to live up to expectations critically, financially, or in sheer popularity."

What could happen next?

Deadline is reporting that this could be a chance to shift DC's focus to Supergirl, as well as continuing to ride the success of Gadot as Wonder Woman, with its upcoming sequel set in 1984 (look out for those flicked hairdos).

Another forthcoming film out of the DC stable will be Aquaman, starring Game of Thrones' Jason Momoa as Arthur Curry, who learns he's the heir to the underwater kingdom of Atlantis.

And of course Shazam! is due out next year as well.

These films are brighter in tone than their bleaker Superman/Batman predecessors.

Who could replace Cavill as Superman, if he really has hung up his cape?

image copyrightGetty Images
image captionCould Michael B Jordan soon be wearing the red cape?

Deadline is reporting that Black Panther's Michael B Jordan could be in line for the role, while bookmaker William Hill is touting Once Upon A Time's Colin O'Donoghue, followed by Sam Claflin, Armie Hammer, Channing Tatum, Cillian Murphy and Donald Glover.

image copyrightWarner Bros
image captionSam Claflin starred alongside Emilia Clarke in Me Before You

Follow us on Facebook, on Twitter @BBCNewsEnts, or on Instagram at bbcnewsents. If you have a story suggestion email entertainment.news@bbc.co.uk.

Related Topics

More on this story