A-level and GCSE results to be decided by teachers

By Sean Coughlan
BBC News family and education correspondent

Published
comments
Comments
Related Topics
image copyrightGetty Images
image captionThere will be optional question papers for each subject set by exam boards

GCSEs and A-levels cancelled in England by the pandemic will be replaced by grades decided by teachers, the exams watchdog Ofqual has confirmed.

Schools can determine grades this summer by using a combination of mock exams, coursework and essays.

There will be optional assessments set by exam boards for all subjects, but they will not be taken in exam conditions nor decide final grades.

Results will be published earlier in August to allow time to appeal.

Schools minister Nick Gibb said the government had devised "the best system possible to ensure there is consistency and fairness in how teachers submit grades for their students".

Asked whether he accepted grades would be inflated this year, he told BBC Breakfast the government had put in place "different checking mechanisms" to ensure there was "consistency".

He added ministers had devised the "best system possible" to ensure "fairly awarded grades at a time when we don't think it's fair for [students] to sit the exams in the normal way."

media captionSchools minister Nick Gibb: 'There will be consistency and fairness'

Meanwhile, Prime Minister Boris Johnson tweeted on Thursday that "no child should be left behind as a result of learning lost during the pandemic", which was why government had devised a "fair and flexible system" that would ensure all young people "can progress to the next stage of their education or career".

The new arrangements, which will be set out by Education Secretary Gavin Williamson in the House of Commons later, come after a consultation into how best to assess pupils after months of school and college closures.

Last summer, thousands of A-level students had their results downgraded from school estimates by a controversial algorithm, before Ofqual announced a U-turn which allowed them to use teachers' predictions instead.

There will be no fixed share of grades and schools will not be expected to keep in line with last year's results or any earlier year.

But the Education Policy Institute think tank has warned the plans for this year risk "extremely high grade inflation".

Scotland,Wales and Northern Ireland have already announced that exams will be replaced by teacher-assessed grades.

How will the grading system work?

After last year's chaos, the exams watchdog Ofqual and the Department for Education say there will be no algorithm calculating results.

Instead, the grading system will be built around teachers' judgements - with schools allowed to decide on the evidence to be used, such as mock exams, coursework and essays.

image copyrightPA Media
image captionThere will be no algorithm used this year for results, after protests and U-turns last year

If students are unhappy at the outcome of what their school and teachers have decided, they can appeal, with no financial charge expected.

For those still wanting to take written papers, there will be an option of exams in the autumn.

A-level results day will be 10 August, with GCSEs results given out on 12 August.

They are earlier this year to create a "buffer" for appeals, ahead of decisions over university places in the autumn.

Students awaiting the result of an appeal before being granted a university place will be prioritised under this year's system, Mr Gibb said on Thursday.

Before the end of the school year, teachers can tell pupils how they got on in the test papers set by exam boards - but not their final grades.

Will students still have to sit exams?

There will be test papers set by exam boards for each subject, which are intended to inform the judgement of teachers, but will not decide the final grades.

These have been labelled "mini-exams", but Ofqual says the tests, which will be optional for schools to use, should not be seen as exams.

image copyrightPA Media
image captionAssessments will be in classrooms rather than exam halls

Question papers, which could be from previous exams, will be sent to schools before the Easter holidays and can be taken before 18 June, when schools have to submit grades to exam boards.

The intention is that regardless of how much time pupils might have missed out of school, they will have questions on a topic they will have studied.

These tests will be taken in class rather than exam halls, there is no fixed time limit for their duration and they will be marked by teachers.

What checks are in place?

There will be no fixed share of grades - and schools will not be expected to keep in line with last year's results or any earlier year.

Instead teachers will be expected to award grades based on their professional judgement, drawing on whatever evidence is available.

image copyrightGetty Images
image captionThis is the second year of exam results being disrupted by the pandemic

Schools will be given detailed information about grading and will be expected to ensure consistency between teachers.

Exam boards will check random samples and if there are specific concerns about unusual results, they can investigate and change grades.

What about vocational exams?

Teachers' grades will be used to replace written vocational exams, in the same way as GCSEs and A-levels.

But where there are practical, hands-on skills to be tested, such as for a professional qualification, some of these exams will continue in a Covid-safe way.

The results of some vocational qualifications will be released in the week of 9 August.

What do students think about it?

Caitlyn in Wigan, aged 15, is taking nine GCSEs and has been studying at home where it's hard to concentrate and the wi-fi keeps crashing. She is glad she won't have to sit exams.

image captionCaitlyn is relieved not to be taking exams this summer after missing so much school

"You feel relief because there's not so much pressure," she says, especially when they had missed so much time in school.

"It's not the same as face-to face interactions with teachers," she says.

The mock exams she sat in November she found particularly hard. "You had that fear of going into a hall with 200 people around you.

"It was really stressful as obviously, we'd been online learning so then you had to quickly cram everything in which made quite a few people drained."

image captionKori is worried that how this year's results will be treated when students have not taken exams

Kori from Blackburn, aged 16, is taking five GCSES.

He says learning from home was "in a way better for me, so I could concentrate and there was no-one to distract me". Although he did miss the support of teachers when he got stuck.

Kori feels the assessments, the so-called "mini exams", that will be offered "are going to be better for me".

Although he worries all the pupils this year might be judged unfairly because they didn't sit the full exams.

What's the reaction?

The Education Policy Institute warned of a "high risk of inconsistencies" between schools - and if there are large numbers of successful appeals or widespread grade inflation it could be difficult for universities and employers to distinguish between applicants.

But the ASCL head teachers' union supported giving schools "flexibility over the assessments they use". While the National Education Union said it was probably the "least worst option available".

Parenting charity Parentkind said "teacher assessment is, under the circumstances, the fairest way to test pupils".

Labour's Shadow Education Secretary Kate Green said delays to deciding a replacement for exams had "created needless stress for pupils, parents and teachers".

Are you a teacher or a student? Please share your thoughts and experiences by emailing haveyoursay@bbc.co.uk.

Please include a contact number if you are willing to speak to a BBC journalist. You can also get in touch in the following ways:

If you are reading this page and can't see the form you will need to visit the mobile version of the BBC website to submit your question or comment or you can email us at HaveYourSay@bbc.co.uk. Please include your name, age and location with any submission.

More on this story