Business

Carlos Ghosn: Five charts on the Nissan boss scandal

Carlos Ghosn Image copyright Getty Images

The downfall of Carlos Ghosn has sent shockwaves through the global car industry.

Last week he was arrested on suspicion of financial misconduct and dismissed from his post as chairman of the Japanese car giant Nissan.

His detention has thrown into doubt the future of the Alliance - a global carmaking group that includes Renault, Nissan and Mitsubishi.

It has also exposed fractures in the very close relationship between Renault and Nissan

1. The Alliance - three companies acting as a single entity

The Alliance was formed in 1999, when Renault rescued Nissan from the brink of bankruptcy. The French carmaker has a 43% stake in its Japanese partner, while Nissan has a 15% stake in Renault.

In 2016, Mitsubishi was added to the mix. Damaged by scandal and struggling financially, it was effectively bailed out by Nissan, which acquired 34% of its shares.

Today, although the three companies retain distinct identities, they act as a global car grouping. They develop and use common technologies, buy parts from the same suppliers, and are developing systems for building cars from common "modules". Together they employ more than 450,000 people, and sell more than 10 million vehicles a year.

Before this scandal erupted, Carlos Ghosn was chairman of both Nissan and Mitsubishi, as well as being chairman and chief executive of Renault. He was and remains chairman and chief executive of the Alliance, which has its own board.

2. Nissan has grown faster than its partner

Although the three Alliance companies already have very close links, Carlos Ghosn had plans to bring them closer, and in particular to reinforce the already strong links between Renault and Nissan.

The BBC understands that while this would have fallen short of a full merger, with both companies maintaining their separate corporate identities, it might well have involved Renault taking a majority stake in its partner.

This is believed to have caused concern and resentment at Nissan - and looking at the graph below, it is easy to see why. When the partnership between the two was first established, they were building cars at a similar rate.

Since then, Renault has nearly doubled its output, helped in part by the acquisition of the Russian manufacturer Avtovaz in 2014.

But Nissan has grown even more quickly. It now makes nearly 6 million cars and light vans every year - roughly a third more than Renault. Last year it made a profit of $5.8bn, and accounted for a sizeable chunk of Renault's own earnings.

So seen from that perspective, Nissan and its executives could be forgiven for asking why they risked losing status and influence within the Alliance, despite providing the lion's share of production and profits.

3. The Ghosn effect

That said, Carlos Ghosn can justifiably claim a great deal of credit for Nissan's current strength. When he joined the company in 1999, he already enjoyed the nickname "le Cost Killer" in France for his actions at Renault.

He brought a similar ruthlessness to Nissan, closing factories, cutting jobs and transforming the way it operated. As the chart below shows it was an effective strategy. Operating profits soared and remained high until the financial crisis, when like other manufacturers Nissan saw its earnings plummet.

Nissan recovered from the crisis quickly but since then the road has been rockier. In recent years, its margins have been hit by declining sales, rising costs, and a quality control scandal in Japan. In the six months to the end of October, operating profit was down by a quarter compared to last year. So had Mr Ghosn already lost his Midas touch?

4. Mr Ghosn was well paid for his efforts

Nissan claims that Mr Ghosn had been systematically under-reporting his earnings to security regulators and had been misusing company assets for personal benefit. Those allegations are being studied by prosecutors, while Mr Ghosn himself remains in custody.

There are many colourful stories about what exactly he is alleged to have done circulating within the Japanese media, although there has been no response so far from Mr Ghosn or his lawyers.

But one thing we can be sure of is that, under-reported or not, he was earning plenty of money. Last year he was paid about $17m in salary, share options and bonuses.

In fact there has been plenty of controversy about his pay packet in the past, but mainly in France, where it has been the subject of an annual showdown with shareholders. Those shareholders include the French state, which voted against his latest package in June.

5. Shares have been lagging

It hasn't been a great year for investors in the Alliance companies. Renault's stock did surge briefly in the early part of the year, first on reports of a possible merger with Nissan and then amid speculation the French government could sell its stake to the Japanese manufacturer. But in recent weeks all three have been in the doldrums.

That's partly to do with the state of the market globally. But it may also reflect uncertainty about the future of the Alliance - and Mr Ghosn's role in it - which was apparent well before the news about Mr Ghosn erupted.

That news prompted steep falls in all three companies' stock. If the future was uncertain before, it is even more so now.

More on this story