OFT orders crackdown on 'poor value' pensions

Media playback is unsupported on your device
Media captionThere is concern that high charges are eroding the eventual value of a pension, as Simon Gompertz reports

The Office of Fair Trading (OFT) has ordered a crackdown on pension schemes that offer poor value to millions of savers.

It is recommending a series of reforms, including new powers for the Pensions Regulator.

But it has stopped short of recommending a cap on management charges, for the moment at least.

However the government said it would go ahead with a consultation on a possible cap, regardless of the OFT's report.

The OFT said pension schemes containing £40bn worth of savings are, or may be, delivering "poor value for money".

The complexity of some defined contribution schemes makes it difficult for individuals and employers to make the right choices, the OFT concluded.

Employers "lack the capability or the incentive to assess value for money", it said.

As a result it is advising the government to consider improving the transparency and comparability of different schemes.

Charge cap

Some older schemes set up before 2001 have annual management charges as high as 2.3%.

Such charges can erode the final value of a pension quite dramatically.

Clive Maxwell, the OFT's chief executive, said he might still consider a cap on management charges in the future.

"We're holding off on that for now," he told the BBC.

"But it may be that a cap is the right thing to do," he added.

However, the government has decided to go ahead with a consultation on a cap for auto-enrolment schemes, after the Pensions Minister, Steve Webb, expressed his support for the idea earlier this week.

Media playback is unsupported on your device
Media captionOFT head Clive Maxwell: "There could be an argument for introducing this cap"

He suggested that the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) might consider a 1% cap on management fees.

"We will be consulting on a range of options, including a cap on charges (including management charges) in default funds in qualifying schemes used for automatic enrolment," a DWP spokesperson told the BBC.

Consumer group Which? called for such a limit to be brought in as quickly as possible.

"The government must go further and set high-quality minimum standards for all workplace pensions as soon as possible, including a cap on all charges," said Richard Lloyd, the executive director of Which?.

Improving value

In the meantime the Pensions Regulator has agreed to assess which smaller pension schemes are not delivering good value.

If the government agrees, the regulator could also be given new enforcement powers.

The Association of British Insurers (ABI), whose members offer pension schemes, has agreed to carry out an audit of the larger schemes, some of which are charging up to 2.3% in annual management fees.

Pension providers will also have to set up governance committees to help protect savers.

The OFT has also asked the government to consider banning certain schemes being used for its auto-enrolment programme which make high charges when savers stop paying into the schemes.

The government is worried that such excessive costs could discourage people from taking out pensions, when it is trying to persuade people to participate.

Since last October, workers have been gradually signed up to workplace pensions, unless they deliberately opt out.

Over the next five years, nine million extra people are expected to join so-called "defined contribution" schemes.

Five million people are already saving into such pension schemes, which invest the monthly contributions in stock and bond markets.

Savers' retirement income is dependent on the investment returns made by such schemes, and the charges they levy.

The pension pot that savers end up with is then used to purchase a retirement annuity, which provides an income for the rest of their lives.

The government has said it will now go ahead with some of the consultations recommended by the OFT.

Related Topics

Related Internet links

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites