Hong Kong 'cardboard granny' has case overturned

By News from Elsewhere...
...as found by BBC Monitoring

  • Published
An elderly woman collecting rubbishImage source, AFP
Image caption,
Thousands of elderly women collect cardboard in Hong Kong and sell it on to recyclers to make money

An elderly Hong Kong woman who was fined for "setting down a bag of rubbish" has had her case overthrown following local protests, it's been reported.

According to the South China Morning Post newspaper, 63-year-old Chen Kung-lan was fined HK$1,500 ($191; £150) by officials at the Food and Environmental Hygiene Department (FEHD) on 23 July, after she temporarily placed a bag of cardboard on the ground.

She was collecting scrap cardboard in a trolley, but had temporarily set a bag on the ground within sight of an FEHD officer, who told her that she had broken the law.

Ms Chen is what is known locally as a "cardboard granny" - an elderly street scavenger who collects rubbish and sells it on to recyclers as a means of making a living.

"I told the officer I did not dump the rubbish on the street," she told the paper. "But he said 'No, if your bag of rubbish touches the ground, you have already violated the law.'"

The authorities in Hong Kong can charge and prosecute rubbish collectors for a number of offences, including causing obstructions and unlicensed hawking.

You might also be interested in:

The Waste Picker Platform concern group submitted a letter of appeal to the FEHD and began an online petition on 26 July to rally support for Ms Chen's cause. It received over 1,600 signatures, and the FEHD overturned her prosecution on Monday.

And the case has ignited local concern about the exploitation of such groups.

Hong Kong is one of the most expensive cities in the world, and home to an estimated 2,900 "cardboard grannies". The majority of these rubbish collectors are over 60-years-old, and they earn on average some HK$716 ($91; £71) a month, South China Morning Post says.

Image source, AFP
Image caption,
Hong Kong's elderly have protested before about health and unemployment conditions, forcing them to collect rubbish

Reporting by Kerry Allen

Use #NewsfromElsewhere to stay up-to-date with our reports via Twitter.