This page has been archived and is no longer updated.Find out more about page archiving.

Mariah Carey Merry Christmas II You Review

Album. Released 2010.  

BBC Review

It’s not particularly clever but it is expectedly big, and sure to make a fan’s Christmas.

Mike Diver 2010

It’s utterly unavoidable at this time of year. Be you in the car or the shopping centre, at work or play, in Britain or Bermuda: someone, close by, will be playing All I Want for Christmas Is You. Mariah Carey’s contribution to the festive season’s slew of ubiquitous-for-two-months singles was originally released back in 1994 – today, it’s her biggest-selling single in the UK, and regularly appears in charts the world over come the year’s end. To some ears it’s a contemporary classic that simply can’t get old; to others, its presence on the radio is a sign that it’s time to switch to the iPod over tuning in to any commercial station, for fear of more of the same.

If you’re the kind of jolly listener who falls into the former camp, and Carey’s enduring hit is more than music to your ears, it’s a brilliant beacon of festivity every bit as vital to the stirring of cheer as a cola-coloured Santa and double-A batteries, you are in luck: here is a brand-new long-player full of similarly styled fare. All I Want… is given a new lick of paint – it’s an "extra festive" version, but beyond beefier production and newly tracked vocals it’s hard to hear how it qualifies as having extra anything over the original – and a selection of traditional numbers are given treatments Carey’s many fans will find appealing. Mercifully for those who aren’t wholly taken with her, those soar-away vocals are kept largely in check, the high-pitched squeal which has ruined several songs in her back catalogue relatively reined in. Indeed, she exercises admirable restraint at times, and the songs benefit from it – before it’s slathered in cheesy beats, Auld Lang Syne is surprisingly tender, and 13th century hymn O Come All Ye Faithful is treated with respect.

There are four new tracks here, amongst the well-performed favourites. Of them, Oh Santa! is a boisterous RnB bopper that makes perfect sense as this set’s lead single – it’s not in the same league as All I Want…, but it’s sure to warrant revisiting 12 months down the line. Christmas Time Is in the Air Again and When Christmas Comes are less instant, but perfectly formed nonetheless, each an unfussy number that complements the surrounding content well. One Child is bogged down in sentiment, but any unpleasantness in the mouth is soon washed clean by the arrival of that hit.

It’s not particularly clever, but it is expectedly big: if you’re a Carey fan with a stocking that needs filling this year, this’ll perk you up better than any alternative speech or sherry trifle could.

Creative Commons Licence This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Licence. If you choose to use this review on your site please link back to this page.