This page has been archived and is no longer updated.Find out more about page archiving.

Emmy the Great First Love Review

Album. Released 2009.  

BBC Review

Debut album is worth the wait.

Zofia Niemtus 2009

As vitriol-attracting stage names go, Emmy The Great is up there with the worst. Perhaps even more troublesome is the hype that’s gathered around Emma-Lee Moss in the four years she’s been working her way up from the indie underground. Lucky then, that her debut album is worth the wait.

The London-based singer-songwriter falls into the already crowded bracket of quirky, folky types interpreting the contents of their hearts with acoustic guitars, pianos and various twinkly extras. But First Love is a deceptive collection; while Emmy’s wavering, girlish vocals give the impression of a lightweight tone, her lyrics are unexpectedly heavy.

Take 24. Ostensibly a drawn-out moan about a boyfriend who watches too much Jack Bauer, the track blossoms into an epic existential crisis, lamenting, ''24 for every year that I have slipped day by day into the neck of the abyss’'.

Things shift stylistically too – moving from the sparse contemplation of Museum Island to fiddle-tinged Celtic folk on Dylan and We Are Safe. A foray into 60s-style sugar-pop on single We Almost Had A Baby is less convincing, and the overblown choral work of Easter Parade outstays its welcome long before the three and a half minutes are up.

The strongest indication of Emmy’s greatness comes in the title track; an intricate, winding work of near-brilliance, made all the more powerful by its reworking of what the singer herself attributes in the song as ''Hallelujah, the original Leonard Cohen version'’. It’s not quite a flawless debut, but a sign that great things are to be expected.

Creative Commons Licence This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Licence. If you choose to use this review on your site please link back to this page.