Could the discovery of the Brown Hairstreak be the turning point for the campaign against Route B? Dr Martin Warren of Butterfly Conservation explains the significance of the find.
The Brown Hairstreak is one of Britain’s rarest and most elusive butterflies. The wings are dark brown above, with a distinctive orange mark on the forewing, while the undersides are a rich dark orange. It lives along hedgerows and small woods, usually on heavy clay soils where there is abundant blackthorn, the caterpillar food-plant.
The Brown Hairstreak is found in several regions of southern and western England and Wales, typically where there is still a dense patchwork of hedges and small woods. The butterfly has declined rapidly over recent decades and its range has contracted by 60%. It is now listed as a top conservation priority.
The reason for the butterfly’s decline is the loss of hedges, over 50% of which have been removed in the last 60 years in England, and annual flailing. The eggs are laid on the young growth of blackthorn and are very susceptible to annual cutting by tractor mounted flails. This is now the normal way that hedges are managed but is disastrous for this butterfly and many other hedgerow insects.
Before such mechanised cutting, hedges were managed by hand by periodic cutting and laying. This suited the butterfly well, as new growth was left for several years before re-laying.
The conservation of the butterfly is quite simple. All hedges should be retained and cut on a rotation so that each stretch of hedge is cut every other year, or preferably every 3-4 years. This leaves a good proportion of the hedges uncut, so that the eggs and caterpillars can complete the life-cycle. This management is also good for a wide variety of other insects, as well as for birds that rely on berries during the winter.
New habitat can also be created by planting hedges using a good proportion of blackthorn. In areas where the butterfly still survives, new hedges are colonised very quickly, helping populations to thrive. Where possible, it is even better to let the hedgerow produce small suckers into the field margin, as such low growth is often favoured for egg-laying.
Female butterflies disperse widely across the landscape, laying eggs in hedges as they go. Colonies can cover several square kilometres of farmland. So farmers play a crucial role in the conservation of this beautiful butterfly and can contribute by managing their hedges sensitively.
Most surveys of Brown Hairstreak are done by searching for eggs. Local Branches of Butterfly Conservation organise a series of egg searches through the winter to check on colonies and give feedback to farmers.
Tips for spotting the butterfly
The best way to spot the butterfly is to go to a good locality and look up into ash trees with binoculars. You might see the spiralling flight as the adults chase each other. The other way is to walk slowly along a hedgerow or wood edge where there is lots of blackthorn, and search the foliage and flowers for a basking adult.
Tips for spotting eggs
The Brown Hairstreak is one of the few butterflies that is easier to find in the egg stage than as an adult. Although the eggs are tiny (around 1mm across), they are brilliant white and surprisingly easy to find if you know where to look. Eggs are laid on clean new growth of Blackthorn twigs. They can be found throughout the winter and are best looked for when leaves have fallen.
Dr Martin Warren is Chief Executive of Butterfly Conservation
Photo is from Butterfly Conservation and is used with permission.