Main content

Feedback - Moral Maze

Roger Bolton

Tagged with:

Editor's Note: You can listen to Feedback online or download it here.

The Moral Maze is the toughest BBC programme I have ever presented.

I have only done so twice, because Michael Buerk, its regular presenter, has hardly missed an edition since it began in 1990, almost 25 years ago.

Michael Buerk

Why is it so difficult?

Well it is live and has four highly intelligent very independently minded panellists who spend most of the time with their backs to the presenter as they interrogate witnesses at the opposite end of the table. The presenter has to try to shut them up if they overrun their allotted time or start to browbeat a witness, and, towards the end of the programme, chair a discussion about the key points which have been made, and then finish the programme on time.

I was shattered by the end of the editions I presented. Michael, by contrast, seems to negotiate all those hurdles without breaking sweat.

One of the panellists I had to deal with was Dr David Starkey, sometimes called ‘the rudest man in Britain’. Off air he was quite delightful. On air he could be terrifying, particularly if you tried to rein him in. He made Melanie Phillips seem almost bashful. (Another member of the panel was a young journalist called Michael Gove. Don’t know what has happened to him.) In one edition, not chaired by me, Dr Starkey’s then producer walked into the live studio, stood behind his presenter, and placed his hands round the Doctor’s neck in an effort to shut him up. It had no effect.

I also appeared as a witness in an early edition. I can’t remember what it was about but I would prefer to face an eminent QC in the High Court on a murder charge than do it again. As a witness you don’t get the chance to talk to the panel  beforehand and are led into the studio while the programme is on air, put in the very hot seat and  cross-examined. After what seems a very short time you are told to leave, having hardly got out a fraction of what you intended to say. Or that is what it feels like.

In the early years the live broadcast was followed by an enjoyable dinner at a local restaurant with Hockney drawings on the menu. Much wine was imbibed. Today sandwiches, coffee and crisps are all that is on offer. The Roundheads are now in charge.

Here is our Moral Maze feature.

Don’t forget that the Editor of Today is coming onto Feedback soon. Please keep letting me have your comments and questions about his programme.


Roger Bolton presents Feedback on Radio 4.

Listen to this week's Feedback

Tagged with:

More Posts


In Our Time - The Trinity


In Our Time: Bishop Berkeley