Blog Reaction to 25million Lost Records
From BBC News Online: Two computer discs holding the personal details of all families in the UK with a child under 16 have gone missing. The Child Benefit data on them include name, address, date of birth, National Insurance number and, where relevant, bank details of 25m people.
Reaction from blogs has been swift and mostly unforgiving. Professor Ross Anderson a leading security expert writing in the Light Blue Touchpaper blog says:
It’s surely clear by now that the whole public-sector computer-security establishment is no longer fit for purpose. The next government should replace CESG with a civilian agency staffed by competent people. Ministers need much better advice than they’re currently getting.
The Spy Blog says:
Why was one junior civil servant allowed to have access to download the full database, when the National Audit Office didn't even request all of that data, only a small sample for audit purposes e.g. a dozen records ?
Mr Euginides links to a worrying view of the consequences:
UK banks could be forced to close the accounts of all child benefit claimants affected by an HMRC “operational failure” that resulted in the loss of 25 million records stored on discs, a Gartner analyst has warned.
The Impact legal blog notes that this isn't the first problem to have recently affected the Government:
Central government doesn't seem to be having much luck complying with its data protection obligations at the moment. As we reported last week, the
Treasury [actually the Foreign Office] has recently had to give undertakings to the ICO that it will comply with the Data Protection Act following an incident involving disclosure of personal data on a visa applications website. In the BBC report on the current issue, the ICO says it is already investigating two incidents involving the Treasury.
UPDATE: Oh the irony. Just noticed this. At the 2007 Civil Service Awards earlier in the month there's an interview with a person described as the "HMRC Chief Executive" talking about the need to celebrate success..
UPDATEII: And some wag has put a fake advertisement for "the discs" up on Ebay.