Talk about Newsnight

A blog and forum.

Friday, 13 October, 2006

  • Newsnight
  • 13 Oct 06, 07:51 PM

dannatt1_203.jpgThe aftershocks from the comments from Sir Richard Dannatt; our diplomatic editor Mark Urban has been in Basra with British troops examining the very question that the Army's top general has raised: whether the British presence exacerbates violence.

We hear from the senior Iraqi officer who says the security situation would actually be better if the British were not on the streets in contact with the civilian population, and from the British commander who admits that every day since the liberation of Iraq, consent for the British presence has gradually waned.

All of this raises an interesting question. If this is what the troops on the ground know, and Sir Richard has had the courage to say, are British troops really in southern Iraq now not to provide security but to provide some kind of political solidarity with President Bush, who is facing some very difficult elections within the next few weeks?

Comment on Friday's programme here.

Newsnight Review - 13 October, 2006

  • Newsnight
  • 13 Oct 06, 07:44 PM

cabaret_203.jpgThe panel, chaired by Kirsty Wark, discuss:

The History Boys; Cabaret; Test Site at the Tate Modern; David Hockney Portraits; plus there’s music from The Lemonheads.

Comment on the latest edition of Newsnight Review and let us know if you agree with our panel Julie Myerson, John O’Farrell, Natalie Haynes and Kerry Shale.

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites