BBC HomeExplore the BBC
This page has been archived and is no longer updated. Find out more about page archiving.
Listen to Radio 3 - BBC Radio Player

Free Thinking : The world

From New Delhi, writer Rana Dasgupta

Hospitality And The City

  • Rana Dasgupta
  • 30 Oct 06, 05:43 AM

The beginning of a folktale, which all of us know:

A weary traveller arrives in a town at night. He is a stranger from afar, and he is alone. He knocks at doors, asking where he can stay, until he finds someone who has room to house him for the night. He is given food and lodging, and stories are exchanged: stories of here, and stories of there. The traveller leaves again in the morning to resume his journey.

Perhaps the traveller reveals himself to be a king, or a magician, and the host family receives an astonishing reward. Perhaps he is a figure of darkness, a disturbing new presence in the town's otherwise humdrum life. Either way, a tale can begin from there.

Contemporary, capitalist, society is conspicuous in its indifference to the virtue of hospitality, which has lain at the centre of most other cultures. Across history, and in many different places, the idea of providing food, shelter and cash to strangers in need has played an obvious and important economic role. More than this, it has brought together strangers in intimate settings, and provided a vital channel for news, culture and ideas to be exchanged.

The magnificence of many of the caravanserais built across the medieval Muslim empires lay not in the private quarters provided to travellers, but in the prominence of the poets, musicians and philosophers who congregated in the courtyards to talk to guests and provide entertainment. Through the sarais, musical styles travelled across enormous geographical zones, politics and new technology were transmitted and discussed, poems and stories were spread, and philosophical ideas were communicated.

The ethos of hospitality was considered to be central to those earlier forms of globalisation, not just because it made journeys economically viable for those who could not afford to pay for weeks or months of accommodation, but also because it demanded a certain openness of spirit, both in those who provided hospitality and in those who received it. It demanded that both parties expose themselves to the foreign and walk away, possibly, changed.

In the production of modern European societies, a great value was placed on distance. The modern European "man" needed space around him to think and achieve his greatness, and to be able to enjoy distance, therefore, from society. The welfare society was imagined according to the principle that individuals would subcontract their responsibilities to each other to the state, and that they would therefore not be entangled as they had been before. Modern European culture respects all the forms of politeness that maintain distance between citizens, and treats as shameful all lifestyles that require an individual to "impose" on others: begging, accepting charity, squatting abandoned land, etc.

Ironically, this same culture also worships the extraordinary creativity that sometimes arose from an earlier ethos of hospitality. Many of the great modern European thinkers and artists, if they were not independently wealthy, were only capable of their achievements because other people took care of their material requirements. Marx was supported throughout much of his life by his friend Engels. The Wikipedia entry on James Joyce says

"His expert borrowing skills kept him from ever becoming completely destitute ... In Paris, Maria and Eugene Jolas nursed Joyce during his long years of writing Finnegans Wake. Were it not for their unwavering support (along with Harriet Shaw Weaver's constant financial support), there is a good possibility that his books might never have been finished or published."

while the entry on Van Gogh says

"The central figure in Vincent van Gogh's life was his brother Theo, an art dealer with the firm of Goupil & Cie, who continually and selflessly provided financial support."

That the much-maligned "freeloader" actually lies at the centre of European culture, and has been responsible for some of its most profound ideas and works of art, reminds us of a number of things.

Firstly, that any idea of freedom must include the freedom to be poor - that a free society cannot call itself such if it removes every possibility for people without money to create an existence for themselves. Secondly, that in seeking to do away with the need for such dependencies as those enjoyed by Marx, Joyce and Van Gogh, European societies also struck at the heart of their own creativity. And thirdly, that contemporary societies might have much to learn from all those other cultures in which willful poverty - as chosen by hermits, ascetics, monks etc - and the hospitality that sustained it were prominent social forms.

To this I add just a few notes:

-- Jains in India are among the most wealthy and successful businesspeople. They control the majority of the diamond trade, and are prominent in most industries, and have a culture of money and display. In line with the ascetic, non-violent strain that is also crucial to their culture, however, it is not uncommon for Jains to give away their entire fortune and to wander for the rest of their lives as ascetic monks, sometimes electing, as an ultimate form of non-violence against the world, to end their lives through starvation. Suketu Mehta's recent book, Maximum City, contains an amazing account of a billionaire diamond merchant from Bombay who, with his entire family, has renounced life, given away their money and become travelling Jain monks who walk barefoot across India. Quite obviously, this ascetic way of life has its own culture and lifestyle, and a large body of people inside and outside it who create it, help it, and allow it to exist.

-- When I was in Turkey I discovered that most of the academics I met in Istanbul were sponsored by other people: friends, ex-lovers, patrons. The $400-a-month wages at the state universities are inadequate for a city whose prices are not much lower than Barcelona, and yet corporate wages may be very high. A number of people doing corporate jobs supplement the wages of friends doing academic jobs so that they may devote themselves to this work.

-- Squatting has been in the news a lot recently (Paris and London). This is not the place to give a history of squatting in the west - the Wikipedia entry is a start - but it is clear that squatting is a deeply interesting counter-culture in the current context. Like the culture of free software, which is closely associated with it, squatting calls into question the nature of the property-society, the accepted goals of people in such societies (e.g. to own property), and the idea of scarcity that underpins much of the rhetoric of such a society. Like free software again, squatters have tried to resurrect ideas of sharing and hospitality in societies where those ideas have been significantly marginalised.

Comments

  1. At 01:21 PM on 31 Oct 2006, Fitz wrote:

    Why can't you accept that this is the internet for goodness sake and not a place to print a whole book full of stuff,

    As a writer surely you must understand that keeping it short and pithy is the way to go. Have a look at the other threads around and so how the long drawn out drawl gets left behind!

    We're not reading books here ya now!

    Post a complaint

    Please note Name and E-mail are required.

    Contact details
  2. At 02:54 PM on 01 Nov 2006, Roberto Carlos Alvarez-Galloso,CPUR wrote:

    Great Blog.

    Post a complaint

    Please note Name and E-mail are required.

    Contact details
  3. At 04:10 PM on 01 Nov 2006, Teju wrote:

    This is a very important discussion, and I'm especially gratified to see it being taken up by a young writer.

    May we never forget our solidarity with the poor.

    Post a complaint

    Please note Name and E-mail are required.

    Contact details
  4. At 04:29 AM on 02 Nov 2006, Fitz wrote:

    see what I mean?

    Post a complaint

    Please note Name and E-mail are required.

    Contact details
  5. At 02:15 PM on 03 Nov 2006, jason wrote:

    folk are nicer in small villages than big cities, well, perhaps not, strangers are scary, look at all those stories on the news... arghhhh scary !

    Post a complaint

    Please note Name and E-mail are required.

    Contact details
  6. At 10:24 PM on 03 Nov 2006, Fitz wrote:

    me thinks there is an exponential law at play here - as the dissetations get longer the replies get smaller - anyone noticed that?

    Or to put it another way - when we are asked to read books on the internet we give up!

    we still prefer to curl up in an armchair with one and a glass of chardonnay!

    Post a complaint

    Please note Name and E-mail are required.

    Contact details
  7. At 09:54 AM on 08 Nov 2006, jason wrote:

    Sit and sigh during the debates as someone says 'cities are not ecologically sustainable' and watch folk ignore that and chat about their future.

    ER, WHAT FUTURE ?

    Post a complaint

    Please note Name and E-mail are required.

    Contact details
  8. At 11:47 AM on 09 Nov 2006, Fitz wrote:

    I think Rana's gone to sleep underneath a pulawalla!

    Post a complaint

    Please note Name and E-mail are required.

    Contact details
  9. At 12:58 PM on 10 Nov 2006, Fitz wrote:

    or is that punkawalla - I'm sure he'll spot the deliberate spelling error - he always does!

    Post a complaint

    Please note Name and E-mail are required.

    Contact details
  10. At 10:45 PM on 14 Nov 2006, Lee wrote:

    People simply travel more & faster, lifestyles have changed, it is unsafe and our population density is way up.
    This is simply a way of travelling that is going away as time moves on. It does not mean that people are necessarily less friendly or there are not good things about the way we travel today just different.
    I do agree that it was a way of life that brought interesting exchanges where the journey itself was as important as the destination.

    Post a complaint

    Please note Name and E-mail are required.

    Contact details

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites



About the BBC | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy