BBC HomeExplore the BBC
This page has been archived and is no longer updated. Find out more about page archiving.
Listen to Radio 3 - BBC Radio Player

Free Thinking : The world

From New Delhi, writer Rana Dasgupta

Images Of The Global City From China

  • Rana Dasgupta
  • 27 Sep 06, 11:08 PM


The images that capture most interestingly the uncanny, amnesiac intensity of the contemporary global city come usually, for me, from China. Here I'll just mention two artists in this regard, but there are many others who spring to mind. One place to check out more such people is an interesting recent book, Out of the Red.

The image above is taken from Jia Zhangke's Shijie ("The World", 2004). The film depicts the lives of workers in a theme park outside Beijing where the world's great monuments are spectacularly recreated and where, as the park's slogan goes, you can therefore "See the world without leaving Beijing".

The long commentary on the film on IMDB is titled, "A Sad Picture of How Modernization is The Same the Whole World Over". But this is to reduce the complexity of this film. The park may contain replicas of the Eiffel Tower and Tower Bridge; it may recreate the old urban order in this city of galloping newness. But it is always apparent that this park is a thoroughly Chinese creation - it would never have existed in Paris or London.

The film is not about homogenization. It is about a particular, wry, relationship to the fading urban grandeur of Europe. It stages, simultaneously, a Chinese awe for the iconic power of the urban past - from the pyramids to the Twin Towers - and the power of new Chinese productivity to easily replicate all those triumphs and thereby evacuate them of their aura.


In the soundtrack, Beethoven becomes muzak, a mere soundtrack to the theme park, which is a musical metaphor for what has happened visually through these buildings. The buildings - St Peter's in Rome, Pisa's leaning tower - are also recreated much smaller than original size, as if there is a literal belittling of the grandeur of the past. But the park's performers - from all over China and also Russia - are still struggling to hold their heads up to the world, for the cool spectacle conceals a human reality of great turbulence.


Li Wei, whose photograph is shown above, is a young photographer whose interest is precisely this latter point. What kind of relationship can a human being have with this monstrous reality all around? How do the tender assurances of intimate life connect to the raging unpredictability of what lies beyond the window pane? His photographs stage the playful desires of our relationships to enormous cities, and the almost suicidal danger that accompanies them.


He has a beautiful way of understanding the ambiguity of the human being in this new urban environment. The human is poised between steel and flesh, always trying to keep up with the merciless ballistics of contemporary life, and yet so obviously, fundamentally, flesh.


The passion and intensity of this imagery is, I find, spellbinding. It raises the possibility for me that, much as China produces all the goods we consume, it might also begin to produce the ideas and images through which we can understand the world we have entered into. These ideas and images will be uncomfortable in many parts of the world, however. There is something in them that flattens out European history completely, for instance, and reduces Europe, humiliatingly, to empty cypher.


  1. At 02:05 PM on 28 Sep 2006, Esther Wilson wrote:

    I just wanted to say the Li Wei photographs are
    quite astonishing.

    It's amazing how art can - in it's simple/complex

    way - get to 'the root of something' with such
    utter clarity.

    'pause for humanity(s)' & 'the pain of the world'-


    They made me weep.

    Your point about China is very interesting.

    How has it felt -producing more and more 'things' - for an ever increasing appetite?

    How has consumerism effected us, spiritually?

    (In this culture, depression related suicide is the

    second biggest killer of our young men - after

    road accidents)

    Yet more young people go to university than ever before?

    So a 'privileged' education doesn't seem to be doing us much good.

    It has to be something else. As Venice is on the brink of sinking Li Wei hangs on for dear life.

    Is being further removed from the natural world slowly killing us?

    I try to imagine what it would feel like to be 'detached' from a world where half the

    population is dying of obesity & the other half is

    starving to death.

    I can't.

    We can read books on economics and politics &

    try to make sense of history & the way the 'world

    (western) has been ordered' thus far but.... we need a fresh eye to point out

    that the emperor is really just standing there

    stark naked?

    Post a complaint

    Please note Name and E-mail are required.

    Contact details
  2. At 03:00 PM on 28 Sep 2006, Roberto Carlos Alvarez-Galloso,CPUR wrote:

    Rana: I read your article and saw the photos. I am in agreement with what you wrote, and what Esther wrote. The Photos were excellent.Roberto

    Post a complaint

    Please note Name and E-mail are required.

    Contact details

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites

About the BBC | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy