This page has been archived and is no longer updated. Find out more about page archiving.
Search BBC
BBC World Service
BBC BBC News BBC Sport BBC Weather BBC World Service Worldservice languages
spacer gif
You are in: Home > Grammar, Vocabulary & Pronunciation > Ask about English
Learning English
spacer gif
subject - verb inversion in questions
Sydney Opera House

Bav from India writes::

I'm not sure about word order in questions. Which is correct:
How many people are coming? OR How many are people coming?
How soon can I be released? OR How soon I can be released?

Roger Woodham replies:

auxiliary verb + subject + main verb

In questions, if there is an auxiliary verb (be, do, have, will, can, should, etc), it is placed before the subject:

I've lived here a long time. ~ How long have you lived here?
The house was built a long time ago. ~ When was it built exactly?
I can see the Sydney opera House from my window? ~ Can you see the bridge too?
I'll take you there one day. ~ Will you take me there tomorrow

Note that if there is more than one auxiliary verb, it is only the first one that is placed before the subject:

I will be living in Geneva next year. ~ Will you be living on your own?
I should have moved there last year. ~ Could you have moved there without Jenny?

 

 

be or have as main verbs

When be is the main verb, there is a similar subject-verb inversion:

She was happy when she was living in London. ~ Was she really happy, or did she just pretend?

When have is the main verb, we normally form the question with Have…got…? or Do…have…? Simple subject verb inversion is possible, but it sometimes sounds rather formal or unnatural. Compare the following:

I love animals. I have two cats at home. ~ Have you a dog? / Have you got a dog?/ Do you have a dog?

I have a sister, but she's younger than me. ~ Have you any younger brothers? / Have you got any younger brothers? / Do you have any younger brothers?

      do as auxiliary verb

Remember that when there is no auxiliary verb in an affirmative sentence as in the present simple or past simple, it is normally necessary to place do/does or did before the subject in questions:

I saw Tom about four weeks ago. ~ When did you last see James?
I visit my grandparents once a month. ~ Do you visit them when Tom is with you?

The exception to this rule is when who/what/which is the subject. Compare the following:

Beth phoned her mum last night. ~ Who did Beth phone? ~ She phoned her mum.
Somebody phoned Beth. ~ Who phoned Beth? ~ I've no idea. They didn't leave a message.
Which buses go to Trafalgar Square? ~ The 36 and the 21 go to Trafalgar Square.
Which bus did you take? ~ I took the 36. The 21 wasn't running.

Thus in your example, Bav, some people or how many people is the subject of the sentence, so no inversion is needed in the first question. When it becomes the object of the sentence, as in the second question below, subject-auxiliary verb inversion is required:

I forgot to tell you. Some people are coming for dinner tonight. ~ How many people are coming? How many people have you invited?

 
     

questions through intonation

In spoken English, we can sometimes ask questions by using a rising intonation and no subject-verb inversion when we think we have understood something but want to make sure or find it surprising. Tag questions have a similar purpose. Compare the following:

This is your car? I didn't know you were going to buy a new car. Where did you get the money from?
You're coming to lunch tomorrow, aren't you? And Tom is coming with you?

Note that this word order is not possible after question words such as who/what/which.

 
     

indirect questions: no subject-verb inversion

In indirect questions we do not put auxiliary verbs before the subject and there is normally no subject-verb inversion. There is no question mark either in indirect questions. Compare the following:

What's the problem? ~I asked her what the problem was.
Have you seen Tony recently? ~She wanted to know if I had seen Tony recently.
When did you last see him? ~She enquired when I last saw / when I had last seen him.
Will he be coming back, do you think? ~She wondered if he would be coming back.

 

 

If you would like more practice more please visit our Message Board in the You, Me and Us part of our website.

more questions
l

BBC copyright
 
Learning English | News English | Business English | Watch and Listen
 
Grammar and Vocabulary | Communicate | Quizzes | For teachers
 
Downloads | FAQ | Contact us