BBC HomeExplore the BBC
Advertisement
BBC Weather
 Thursday November 12, 2009Accessibility help | Text only |  Print  |  Send to a friend | Make this my homepage | Contact Us | Help
Skip this navigation panel Skip to BBC Weather's introduction to this feature.

Could it really happen?

Watch and listen to the latest World and UK weather broadcasts
Tornadoes rip through Los Angeles in 'The Day After Tomorrow'
Following the release of the film 'The Day after Tomorrow', we ask, is abrupt climate change really possible?

Key Points
  • The Gulf Stream brings warm water from the Caribbean to the UK and north west Europe.
  • It is driven by differences in the temperature and salinity of sea water.
  • The melting Greenland ice cap and increased rainfall, caused by Global Warming, could disrupt the Gulf Stream.
  • Some climate models indicate that the Gulf Stream could slow by 20-25% by 2100.
bbc.co.uk Links

BBC Climate Change - The Gulf Stream
BBC Films - The Day After Tomorrow
BBC News - Films
BBC Teens - The Day After Tomorrow

External Web Links

The Day After Tomorrow
Hadley Centre
NERC Rapid Climate Change programme


Disclaimer
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external websites.

According to Al Gore, former Vice President of the USA, this is likely to be the question on millions of people's lips after seeing 20th Century Fox's new disaster film 'The Day After Tomorrow', and one that deserves an answer.

Fortunately, rapid climate change is one area that the UK has taken the lead in researching, by funding the Rapid Climate Change programme (RAPID), the aim of which is to determine the probability of rapid climate change occurring.

The film
The Day After Tomorrow focuses on the research of climatologist Jack Hall, which indicates that global warming could trigger a rapid change in the global climate as a result of the Gulf Stream shutting down. Reports soon come in that this is already happening and a dramatic sequence of extreme weather events follow, which include a new Ice Age engulfing most of the Northern Hemisphere.

The facts
The Gulf Stream is a branch of the global thermohaline circulation (THC), driven by differences in temperature and salinity of sea water, that brings warm water north from the Caribbean to the UK and north west Europe.

Global Warming will cause the Greenland ice cap to melt.
Global Warming will cause the Greenland ice cap to melt which, when combined with increased rainfall at high latitudes, will potentially disrupt the THC by adding freshwater and decreasing sea water salinity in the North Atlantic.

The experts
The Gulf Stream is a branch of the global thermohaline circulation (THC), driven by differences in temperature and salinity of sea water, that brings warm water north from the Caribbean to the UK and north west Europe.

Dr Geoff Jenkins, senior climate researcher at the Hadley Centre, said that the film does have a basis in theory. "If the Gulf Stream did shut down, the UK and northwest Europe would become colder, but over a much longer timescale - the film makers have crammed what would happen in a decade into a few hours".

Winters would be much colder than now "along the lines of the winter of 1962-1963"...
However, the UK would still be habitable! Some climate models suggest that average temperatures could be 3-4°C lower following a slowdown or shutdown of the THC. Winters would be much colder than now "along the lines of the winter of 1962-1963" suggests Jenkins, with summers being cooler and shorter. This would have many social implications including (not surprisingly!) transport and agriculture.

3-4°C may not sound much, but the average air temperature difference between the 'Medieval Warm Period' when vineyards thrived in southern England and the 'Little Ice Age' when the River Thames regularly froze over was only 1-2°C.

Some good news though, Dr Jenkins doesn't believe that the extreme follow-on of events such as snow in New Delhi, tornadoes destroying Los Angeles and grapefruit size hail in Tokyo are likely to happen.

...in May 2003, 562 tornadoes were recorded in the USA...
In fact extreme events, such as those described above, can potentially happen in our current climate. The largest hailstone ever recorded (measured by circumference rather than weight) fell from a storm in Aurora, Nebraska on June 22 2003. It measured 17.8cm wide and 47.6cm in circumference. And in May 2003, 562 tornadoes were recorded in the USA, with almost 400 of those in one week - a new record!

Dr Meric Srokosz is Science Coordinator of RAPID. "Greenland ice cores and North Atlantic marine sediments show that rapid climate changes have occurred repeatedly in the past. Changes as large as 5-10°C over periods as short as a decade; fast for Climate Change where we usually think in terms of centuries or millennia. These data also show that the ocean circulation is implicated in many of these rapid changes."

He said of the film "It telescopes events, such as the shutdown of the North Atlantic circulation, into a few days (it would take years to happen in reality) and amplifies the impact of the events (we are not headed for another Ice Age). The ocean circulation might slow down in the future and this might lead to somewhat cooler temperatures (by a few degrees) in the UK and NW Europe, but not to the disaster depicted in the film."

The future

...some climate models indicate that the Gulf Stream could slow by 20-25% by 2100.
Dr Jenkins said that some climate models indicate that the Gulf Stream could slow by 20-25% by 2100. However, when considered against the backdrop of Global Warming caused by the Greenhouse Effect, the UK would still see overall warming. In a simulation of a total shut down of the Gulf Stream, a fall in temperatures was only seen in a small area around the North Atlantic in the UK and north west Europe, while the rest of the world experiences warming.

Dr Srokosz said "Present day observations suggest that changes are occurring in the North Atlantic circulation... however existing observations are not adequate to answer the question of whether the THC is slowing down."

"Rapid climate change is a low probability but high impact event, so we need to improve our knowledge of the processes involved and narrow the uncertainties on the prediction of potential future rapid climate change." Which is what RAPID aims to do.





About the BBC | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy