BBC HomeExplore the BBC
This page was last updated in February 2009We've left it here for reference.More information

29 May 2012
Accessibility help
Text only
South East Wales

BBC Homepage
»
BBC Vocab: Somali
DAMIN / OFF
» Daarid, furid, daar / Turn on
» Waa maxay Vocab-ereyo? / What is VOCAB?
 

Contact Us

Like this page?
Send it to a friend!

 


Raise the Isca!

Medieval ship being excavated in Newport These are archive messages - to air your views please visit our new Your Say index page.


John O'Sullivan from Newport is convinced the council could have done more for the ship:

"They were adamant that that they didn't want to save the ship. Their inaction demonstrates their commitment to the history of our town. No-one at the council saw the long term benefits to the town - ie tourism."


Andrew Ball from Newport praises everyone who's helped to save the ship:

"An internationally important rare 1465/1466 Newport Ship find must now be carefully and accurately recorded with patience before appearing in the Arts Centre basement. Well supported by the public and saved via Council and Assembly, it should go on to prove a most valuable asset for Newport and Welsh commerce and tourism in general. Let's celebrate 95% of this ship's timbers having been saved. Pity about the stern as valuable steering/speed and naming have now been lost. Looking forward to eventual display - future archaeological excavation report should prove interesting. Good work done by archaeologists/Friends of Newport Ship and general public alike in its saviour."


Eleri from Wrexham thinks that the ship should have been fully excavated:

"As an arcaheologist myself, I am disgusted that it hasn't. Arcaheological guidelines state that we should try and leave remains in situ for future generations, but in this case, the guidelines are wrong...local councillors are not preserving the local heritage due to costs. The amount may seem huge but can easily be re-compsensed when opened and on show to the paying public."


Rebecca Gilchrist in Newport thinks more care should have been taken:

"There should have been an initial survey done before building work began. You cannot expect NOT to find archaeological wood in an area which is famous for the preservative properties of its river silt, especially when you look at historical maps of the area which show this part of the river to have inlets used extensively for boat building/breaking.

"I'm very disappointed with the lack of enthusiasm and interest shown nationally. It is unfair to expect Newport Council to foot the bulk of the conservation bill. Yes, the cost may top £20m in the long run, but when you consider the billions misdirected or wasted in this country, it's barely a drop in the ocean in comparison.

"The Newport councillors will not be remembered for saving the Newport Ship, but for being so interested in the Arts Centre that they ignored the wishes of local people to have the ship raised in its entirity. We already had the Dolman Theatre and Newport Art Gallery. Now we want the ship."


Alexi Drove from Vancouver in Canada thinks he has a solution to the funding problem:

"Declare the ship to be a rare and completely ENGLISH medieval ship. I sincerely believe funding would pour into the project from Westminster. Action - The assembly should immediately organise a referendum on whether the remains of the ship should be buried or destroy. After all isn't that what happend to the rest of Welsh history. I am convinced the Swedish people would never have raised the 'Vasa' had there been a Victorian Dock wall in the way."


For previous comments on the Newport ship, click here.

  • See a slideshow of the ship and its new home

    take a look

    What's your view? How and why should the ship be preserved? Join our debate about the fate of the Isca.




  • Newport Life
    More from this section
    More from Your Say
    Message board

    take a look

    animation Have your say
    Add an event
    Add a quiz
    Get the newsletter


    Related links
    Newport Life
    Slideshow - Newport Ship

    Related www links
    Newport Council
    Friends of the Newport Ship
    Newport Ship - campaign website
    Mary Rose

    The BBC is not responsible for the content of external websites

    take a look

    JK Rowling
    Hall of Fame
    Which Harry Potter characters were inspired by JK Rowling's Chepstow schooldays?

    Web Guide
    Get surfing!
    Want to know more about South East Wales? Check out our Web Guide to people, places and activities.

    Singer Amy Wadge
    Enjoy yourself!
    Plan a great night out, check out the music scene or have some fun and games.




    About the BBC | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy