BBC HomeExplore the BBC
This page has been archived and is no longer updated. Find out more about page archiving.

24 September 2014
top of the Pops 2 top of the Pops 2

BBC Homepage
  Video Quiz
  Decades Quiz
  Flick Books
  Fancy Dress
  Show Clips
  Classic Shows
  Top 5s
  School Reports
  Where Are They?
  Show History
  Titles & Themes
  Pan's People
  Ruby Flipper
  Legs & Co
  Contact Us
  BBC Music
  BBC News
  Radio 2
  6 Music

TOTP Online

Contact Us

Walking And Chewing Gum At the Same Time...
Five drummers who got sick of looking at the lead singer's wiggling bum and decided that they could sing!

Phil Collins
Phil Collins was never first choice. Genesis were the Spinal Tap of prog rock, having gone through an impressive four complete drummers before Phil took up the sticks. Having failed to die in a bizarre gardening accident, or explode on stage, he survived until lead singer Peter Gabriel flounced out of the band in a cloud of makeup and chintz. Auditions were held for someone to take the mic but their desperate attempts to avoid the inevitable couldn't stop Phil, and he ended up with the job. A few Genesis albums later he went on to a succesful solo career and became the only person to play at both the UK and the US Live Aid concerts (claims that this is because people at Wembley told him to bog off to America have yet to be substantiated). Not bad for a guy who initially wanted to stay behind the drum kit: "At first I didn't like singing. I didn't think it was a respectable gig, you know. There were steps to do - ostentatious clothes - wiggle your ass a bit. It just wasn't respectable like drumming is."

Don Henley, one of the founder members of the mighty Eagles, was talented to the point of obnoxiousness - he sang, drummed and wrote the songs for one of the most successful supergroups of the '70s. He's dismissive of his skin bashing skills, however, and when Modern Drummer magazine went to interview him he responded: "What does Modern Drummer want with me anyway? I'm no drummer." Indeed, he gave up the sticks and on his last few solo albums he only did duty as a singer songwriter. There's a simple reason for this: "playing the drums hurts my back." Fair enough. This probably explains why there are so few singing drummers around: "I used to have to hold my body in such a position that my spine got out of alignment. Between playing the drums and keeping my mouth in front of the microphone, it really twisted my whole body." Ouch. Nontheless, he realises that the fans like a bit of stick singage every now and then: "I think people enjoy watching me sing and play the drums. It seems to fascinate people. I don't know why."

no 3He married that girl from The Spy Who Loved Me, dontcha knowRINGO STARR: 'IF YOU DON'T KNOW WE'RE NOT TELLING YOU'
Don Henley is full of praise for the first great singing drummer: "I don't care what anybody says about Ringo. I cut my rock 'n' roll teeth listening to him." When Pete Best was dropped by the Beatles for being, well, a bit rubbish really, they recruited Ringo who was, according to Lennon, quite the catch: "Ringo's a damn good drummer. He was always a good drummer. He's not technically good... [but] he was quite simply the heart of the Beatles". This rather begs the question, if he's not technically good what kind of good is he... theoretically good? George Harrison once said that "playing without Ringo is like driving a car on three wheels," and Sir Macca claims that Ringo remains his favourite drummer, even now, when he can work with anyone he chooses. His singing, however, was a little, how shall we put it, raspy... but we all love 'Yellow Submarine' and 'Octopus's Garden'. Anyway, he knew it wasn't his strong suit: "first and foremost I am a drummer... I played drums because I loved them... it was the love of my life." Aw, bless his little heart.

Karen Carpenter, one of the most expressive pop vocalists of all time, began her musical career as a drummer. She fell into music by accident, choosing to join the school band as a means of getting out of gym class, and then picking the drums because they seemed the softest option. She never looked back: "luckily, drumming came naturally, I started right off playin', and time signatures came naturally... I don't know how, I mean, it felt so comfortable when I picked up a pair of sticks!." Her brother, who formed the other half of The Carpenters, agreed: "boy, could she play 'em!" Richard and Karen were the best selling American artists of the '70s and she came under a lot of pressure to get out from behind the drum kit. Eventually she compromised - she drummed for the up-tempo numbers and came to the front for the ballads. The final word goes to drumming legend Buddy Rich, who once told Karen: "do you know that you’re one of my favourite drummers?" High praise indeed!

no 5Hey, Hey it's a Monkee!MICKEY DOLENZ: 'THE MONKEES'
The original manufactured band, The Monkees were recruited to fill set roles in a TV show designed to launch the band. According to Dolenz: "I was hired as an actor to play the role of a drummer. I had to learn to play drums." It wasn't long until the Monkees were one of the biggest bands in the world, but how many of the songs actually feature them playing their instruments is hotly debated - for their early recordings they mostly dubbed vocals onto tracks laid down by session band Candy Store Prophets. Their debut hit 'Last Train To Clarkesville' featured Mickey on lead vocals, as did 'I'm A Believer'. Drumming and singing aside Mickey has made two truly great contributions to world culture: he wrote the Monkees classic UK No 2 hit 'Randy Scouse Git' (we're not making that up, honest); he also, all hail him, co-created the TV show Metal Mickey, and for that he should be praised as a god among men.

  The Gardener's Delight  
  Mary, Mary quite contrary, how does your Top 5 grow ....  
  Fatboy Jims & Lardy Ladies  
  The singers who took their sex, drugs & rock 'n' roll with a slice of cake...  
  Britpop Busters  
  Five facts about the legendary Britpoppers...  
  Filmed In Technovision  
  Enter the world of experimental telly according to the Pet Shop Boys
  Punk Pretenders?  
  Perfectly Punked? Nah, at heart they were all a bunch of old softies...  
  Front Bottom!  
  We name and shame the bands named after a lady's privates...
  Bring Your Gran  
  Golden oldies who joined forces with youthful pop people...  
  2003's Demented Predictions  
  TOTP2's bonkers ball-gazer predicts this year's pop ups and downs...  
  The Erasure Story  
  Trip through the history of the UK'S top synth duo...
  Rubbish Xmas Songs  
  What not to play at your Christmas party...  
  Bag Of Bones  
  Legends that should have eaten their greens. Bring out the lard...  
  Banned by the BBC  
  The songs that were just too hot to handle ...  
  Fortune Smiles Upon Them  
  Be they works of genius, accident or stealing, these songs are lucky to be alive.  
  Elton John  
  Drugs, Diana, dirty deeds. It's a wonder that he's still standing...  
  Inxs-ive Lifestyles  
  We examine Australia's biggest export since Fosters...  
  Poodle Rockers  
  Gravity-defying perms and spandex trousers, they're the Poodle Rockers...
  Welcome to the house of factual fun...  
  Status Quo  
  We take a trip down memory lane with the mighty Quo...  
  Pop Activists  
  Top pop people who fight for the rights...  
  Singing Drummers  
  Drummers who got sick of looking at the lead singer's wiggling bum.  
  Rolling Stones  
  Headline-grabbing moments from Britain's lippiest band.  
  David Bowie  
  Follow Dave's top 5 looks through the years - including the mullet action!  
  Hot Chocolate  
  Indulge yourself in the pleasure that is Errol and the gang  
  "Secret" Drug Songs  
  "It was inspired by this crazy picture my son painted." Yeah, right...  
  Abba-nother Go  
  You were going to call it what? 5 working titles from the Super Swedes...  
  In & Out Of Bed With Madonna  
  Collaborations for the Queen of Pop that didn't end at 5.30...  
  Songs that gave a whole new meaning to 'Born To Hand Jive'...  
  For those that glam-rocked, we all salute you...  
  A trip through the lambchop elite's glory story...  
  '80s Revival Hell  
  Alas, some pop icons just wouldn't let that decade go.  

About the BBC | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy