Premier League
Crystal Palace1West Ham0

Crystal Palace 1-0 West Ham United

New Crystal Palace manager Tony Pulis earned his first win as a rare Marouane Chamakh goal helped beat West Ham.

After the Hammers had early control with Mohamed Diame heading over, Chamakh headed in his first goal since August from Barry Bannan's cross.

Media playback is not supported on this device

Pulis praises 'unbelievable' effort

Palace could have extended their lead as Jussi Jaaskelainen made two saves to deny Jason Puncheon and Cameron Jerome.

But Pulis's side defended stoutly and the three points helped them move off the bottom of the Premier League.

The Eagles are still three points behind fourth from bottom Cardiff, yet the manner in which they held onto their lead will give Pulis hope as he bids to maintain his record of never having been relegated in 21 years of football management.

For West Ham, a disappointing evening ended in controversy as Ravel Morrison appeared to shove Palace defender Joel Ward in the face after the final whistle, earning the Hammers 20-year-old a booking.

He will miss West Ham's next game at Liverpool after collecting five yellow cards this season.

The fact he did not receive a red card may be considered fortunate, but there was nothing lucky about Palace's second victory in three games, which was hard-fought, if not exactly pretty.

Chamakh, who criticised West Ham boss Sam Allardyce after playing only three games while on loan at Upton Park last season, scored his second goal of the season.

And his header came against the run of play in a first half in which West Ham had started to take control.

Palace were playing their first home game since Pulis took charge and began brightly as Jason Puncheon tested Jaaskelainen with a stinging shot.

But with Morrison back in the Hammers line-up, the visitors were better in possession than their opponents.

That led to a glut of opportunities around the half-hour mark as Kevin Nolan miscued a volley from Mark Noble's free-kick and Diame headed over from Stewart Downing's cross.

Media playback is not supported on this device

Allardyce 'frustrated and angry' at loss

Carlton Cole, who replaced Modibo Maiga in attack after scoring in the 3-0 victory over Fulham on Saturday, also created another chance for Downing, which he mis-controlled.

The Hammers have only scored three of their 12 goals this season in the first half, and they went behind in a manner which would have infuriated Allardyce, who spoke proudly about his side's defensive record before the game.

Barry Bannan's poor corner was cleared back to the Scot, and he had time to pick out the unmarked Chamakh, who glanced his header into the goal from five yards out.

Whatever Pulis said at half-time, his players came out in the second half like a team transformed.

They had three great chances to score in the space of two minutes as Jaaskelainen tipped Puncheon's shot around the post, watched Kigasho Dikgacoi head over from the resulting corner and then blocked Jerome's effort when the striker was clean through.

That period had the home supporters bouncing and they were mocking their West Ham counterparts soon after as Downing was denied a goal as the referee's assistant saw Joey O'Brien foul Chamakh after they challenged for a cross at the back post.

With Joe Cole and Maiga introduced, the visitors pressed for an equaliser with Downing's free-kick saved well by Julian Speroni.

But Palace came closest to scoring the next goal as Dikgacoi had a shot saved before substitute Jimmy Kebe fired over with the goal gaping.

West Ham manager Sam Allardyce:

"I haven't got the words for it [the goal] when everybody has a marker and the ball comes in from the corner, you still have your marker, you don't lose your marker but we did and being in the middle of the goal with a free header they're not going to miss.

"That's the most disappointing thing for me today because that's lost us the game effectively.

"On such a crucial game we should not have let that slip. A point at the end of the day wouldn't have been a bad result.

"It's all our fault today."


Crystal Palace

  • 1Speroni
  • 2Ward
  • 21Moxey
  • 15Jedinak
  • 19Gabbidon
  • 27DelaneyBooked at 30mins
  • 13PuncheonSubstituted forKébéat 66'minutes
  • 8Dikgacoi
  • 30Jerome
  • 29ChamakhSubstituted forWilliamsat 85'minutes
  • 46BannanSubstituted forO'Keefeat 82'minutes


  • 3Mariappa
  • 9Phillips
  • 12O'Keefe
  • 16Gayle
  • 20Williams
  • 28Kébé
  • 34Price

West Ham

  • 22Jääskeläinen
  • 17O'Brien
  • 8RatSubstituted forMcCartneyat 78'minutes
  • 4NolanSubstituted forColeat 58'minutes
  • 19Collins
  • 5TomkinsBooked at 67mins
  • 23Downing
  • 16Noble
  • 24ColeSubstituted forMaigaat 58'minutes
  • 15MorrisonBooked at 90mins
  • 21Diamé


  • 3McCartney
  • 7Jarvis
  • 10Collison
  • 11Maiga
  • 13Adrián
  • 20Demel
  • 26Cole
Lee Mason

Match Stats

Home TeamCrystal PalaceAway TeamWest Ham
Shots on Target

Live Text

Match ends, Crystal Palace 1, West Ham United 0.


Ravel Morrison (West Ham United) is shown the yellow card.

Full Time

Second Half ends, Crystal Palace 1, West Ham United 0.
Attempt missed. Jimmy Kébé (Crystal Palace) right footed shot from the centre of the box is just a bit too high.
Offside, West Ham United. Ravel Morrison tries a through ball, but George McCartney is caught offside.
Offside, West Ham United. Mark Noble tries a through ball, but James Collins is caught offside.
James Tomkins (West Ham United) wins a free kick on the left wing.
Foul by Cameron Jerome (Crystal Palace).
Attempt missed. James Collins (West Ham United) header from the centre of the box is high and wide to the left. Assisted by Stewart Downing with a cross following a corner.
Corner, West Ham United. Conceded by Jimmy Kébé.
James Collins (West Ham United) wins a free kick in the attacking half.
Foul by Cameron Jerome (Crystal Palace).


Substitution, Crystal Palace. Jonathan Williams replaces Marouane Chamakh.
Foul by George McCartney (West Ham United).
Jimmy Kébé (Crystal Palace) wins a free kick on the right wing.
Offside, West Ham United. Ravel Morrison tries a through ball, but Stewart Downing is caught offside.


Substitution, Crystal Palace. Stuart O'Keefe replaces Barry Bannan.
Hand ball by Marouane Chamakh (Crystal Palace).
Foul by Mohamed Diamé (West Ham United).
Marouane Chamakh (Crystal Palace) wins a free kick in the attacking half.

As It Stood

3Man City138142525
8Man Utd13643522
11Aston Villa13445-116
12West Brom13364-115
15West Ham14347-313
19Crystal Palace143110-1410
View full Premier League table

Top Stories

Get Inspired Activity Finder

Run by the BBC and partners

Find ways to get active near you:

For more ideas, information and inspiration, visit