The maturity the 21-year-old displayed in guiding his side around the park, bringing control to England's game as well as nailing four vital kicks in difficult conditions, had the BBC's pundits purring.
"He is the iceman, there is an edge about him," said former England and Lions centre Jeremy Guscott. "It is not cockiness but confidence. He likes to get amongst it. He is a bit more in-your-face than Jonny Wilkinson, who was more measured, but the end result is about the same."
Wales fly-half legend Jonathan Davies, while admiring Farrell's "phenomenal" goal-kicking, also praised his use of the boot in other areas. "His variety of kicking in open play was very good. Everything he did allowed England to be competitive for the ball and keep the pressure on Ireland."
Scotland coach Scott Johnson called Laidlaw "a wonderful technician - his mind works in a different place to others".
But former Scotland scrum-half Andy Nicol admitted: "I was really impressed with Youngs. The control and variety to his game was very good, and he almost created a try for Manu Tuilagi.
"It is very rare you see scrum-halves play the full game these days. It is testament to how much control England had at half-back. Youngs really put down a marker for the Lions. He is in the box seat now."
If Youngs took a big step forward in a position without a stand-out candidate, the competition at full-back gets tastier by the week.
"He is just an out-and-out paceman and opportunist," said Chris Paterson, whose old full-back position Hogg looks set to occupy for some time.
His chances of wearing Lions red though are by no means certain. Leigh Halfpenny earned another man-of-the-match gong after a faultless kicking display and some incisive attacking interventions in
Wales' 16-6 win over France in Paris.
On another day, England's Alex Goode might have taken the individual honours after a display of tremendous composure under pressure in difficult conditions in Dublin, overshadowing another strong Lions contender, Rob Kearney.
"Goode made one error when he went up for a high ball but, apart from that, he took every single ball, every single kick, and it was a 9/10 performance," noted Guscott.
As it was, England captain Chris Robshaw won the award in Dublin after another tireless display of tackling, carrying, taking kick-offs and generally making all the right calls.
Gatland appeared to offer hope to the flanker this week when he said Robshaw
"has reinvented himself"
in terms of his work at the breakdown.
But the debate over Robshaw's Lions suitability appears to be less about his form, than the specific requirements the tourists will need to stifle the threat of Australia's master breakdown bandit David Pocock.
"The question is whether he [Robshaw] can nullify Pocock,"said Guscott. "If Gatland feels Justin Tipuric or Sam Warburton is more suited to that job, then he won't pick him."
Tipuric certainly justified the calls for his promotion to the Welsh starting line-up with a strong outing in Paris, where he was Wales' joint-top tackler and their leading line-out target.
Highlights: France 6-16 Wales
Team-mate George North also underlined his status as a Lions Test wing-in-waiting with a superb 12th try for his country, expertly taking the chance offered up by Dan Biggar's perfectly-judged chip.
"You can't under-estimate how good that was," said former England and Lions coach Sir Clive Woodward, observing the game for the BBC. "It was an awesome finish which showed incredible awareness, and that is why he is the Lions Test winger for me."
While North confirmed his match-winning ability, other players with Lions ambitions will not look back on this weekend with such fondness.
Jamie Heaslip, the Lions number eight in South Africa, had a day to forget in Dublin.
The Ireland captain dropped two routine high balls with "poor technique" - according to former Ireland flanker Phillip Matthews - as well as conceding two penalties for ruck offences.
Six Nations 2013 : Highlights: Ireland 6-12 England
Prop Cian Healy's loss of discipline in such an intense encounter, with emotions running high, will also not have escaped Gatland's notice. A potential ban for the ugly-looking stamp on Dan Cole's ankle, and a swinging arm in another incident, were not the best advert for a would-be Test Lion, even if his scrummaging ability caused Cole problems at times.
"Healy should know better," Guscott added. "He is a multi-capped international and he just let frustration get the better of him."
While Joe Marler impressed on England's loose-head, another prop to re-state his case this weekend was Scotland tight-head Euan Murray. Any player who can dilute the threat of Italy's scrum and still find the energy to jointly top the tackle count with 15 must be worth consideration.
This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.