R&A chief says male-only golf clubs do not need to change
R&A chief executive Peter Dawson accepts Augusta's decision to allow women members might be "enlightened" and says his job running golf would be much easier if the issue of single-sex clubs didn't exist.
He has also suggested that the landscape surrounding this controversial issue may be much-changed within "10 or 15 years".
But the boss of golf's oldest governing body insisted any move to mixed memberships at men-only clubs would have to come from within those organisations.
Speaking to BBC Sport, Dawson suggested that the Royal and Ancient Golf Club of St Andrews - and other exclusively male clubs which stage the Open - feel no need to change policy.
The comments came in a wide-ranging interview that touched on several of the sport's hottest topics.
Dawson voiced disapproval at the way the PGA of America is fighting the proposed ban on anchored putting methods, questioned how drugs controversies are handled and revealed a significant breakthrough for the staging of golf at the 2016 Olympics.
But the man who has been in charge at St Andrews for the last 14 years was first keen to confront the single-sex membership issue.
This year's Open will be staged at Muirfield, home of the men-only Honourable Company of Edinburgh Golfers. Royal Troon and Royal St George's are the other Open venues provided by all-male clubs.
Dawson estimates that only 1% of the 3,000 golf clubs in the UK are single-sex organisations. He said: "50% are men only and 50% are women only. That's a fact that's not often reported."
Even though Augusta has admitted Condoleezza Rice and Darla Moore as their first female members, Dawson points out that it remains much easier for women to play at Muirfield as a visitor than to play the ultra-exclusive course that stages the Masters every year.
A less comfortable fact is that of the men-only clubs in the UK, several wield huge influence. There are those that have the high profile of staging the Open, and in the case of the Royal and Ancient there is the added role of governing the game.
Does this not hinder golf as it tries to attract more players and escape its elitist image?
"I truly think that is a myth," Dawson said. "I think many people out there think that the R&A run the golf courses in St Andrews and that no women can play.
"That's absolutely not the case. The courses here, and there are seven of them in the town, are entirely public, run by the St Andrews Links Trust and around these courses there are five private clubs that share the public courses with visitors."
But Dawson's admission that there could be a notion that women aren't welcome at St Andrews does highlight a perception problem.
Leading government figures like Sports Minister Hugh Robertson have described the men-only status of the Royal and Ancient as "increasingly anachronistic".
The issue has disappeared at a stroke for the Augusta National, so why doesn't Dawson encourage members of his own club to follow suit? "I don't deny my job would be made a lot easier if this issue didn't exist, that's self-evident.
"But one might choose to respect the wishes of members of these clubs, which are virtually unanimous in a place like St Andrews, that the status quo works extremely well for them."
Dawson accepts there is growing pressure on high-profile single-sex clubs like the Royal and Ancient to change their ways. "We are very aware of what people say. This issue is really quite small, although quite high profile," he said.
"I think if we have this interview 10 or 15 years from now, we might be talking about quite a different scene. But that's for others to determine."
So within a decade and a half, women might be admitted to clubs like the Royal and Ancient, Muirfield, St George's and Troon? "Well, I think it's possible but I do very strongly believe it is a matter for them to determine.
"I think these pressures quite often misrepresent the facts, but there is no doubt the pressures are there and they are part of the market which will determine what happens here."
Dawson has taken due note of Augusta's move to admit women. "Was it enlightened?" he said. "I suppose you could say that, yes. I wouldn't want to in anyway criticise what Augusta do, they run their own affairs."
Relations between the R&A and another leading organisation, the PGA of America, are less cordial.
The body that organises the US Ryder Cup effort and represents the country's club pros has been most vocal in opposing the proposed ban on anchored putting methods.
President Ted Bishop described the Masters victory of the broomhandle-wielding Adam Scott as "probably as painful as swallowing a handful of nails for USGA and R&A officials."
In response, Dawson said: "Some of the comment has been inflammatory and it's perhaps put rule-making onto the negotiating table. We've seen a campaign rather than comment.
"I don't want to inflame the situation, but I have been surprised and indeed disappointed and Ted knows my views about that."
Dawson is also watching closely the situation surrounding the Vijay Singh drugs controversy. No decision has been revealed despite the Fijian admitting taking a banned substance contained in deer antler spray.
The process has been shrouded in secrecy and the R&A boss believes there should be more transparency in such cases. "This is a PGA Tour matter and I understand that it is being dealt with under their procedure at an appeal stage," he said.
"A determination will be made, I think, quite soon. I can't deny that a little more openness about these things should be encouraged," added Dawson, who helped lead the introduction of drug testing to the game.
The picture appears somewhat clearer regarding the construction of the Olympic golf course in Rio for the 2016 Games. Paperwork problems have prevented the start of building work and the project is a long way behind schedule.
"Just last weekend I'm delighted to say all the permits have been signed by the city of Rio. We do feel there is scope now to get back on track," Dawson revealed.
"It has been a worry for us and we must now make sure the construction process remains on schedule and if it does we will be fine."
And if it doesn't? "The implications are pretty severe because there isn't another golf course that we inspected that would be right for Olympic golf in the city of Rio, but I'm increasingly confident we won't need to have a Plan B."
Dawson reiterated that it is almost certain that 72-hole strokeplay will be used for the men's and women's tournaments at the Olympics.
Both sexes will be represented in Rio but not, for the time being at least, in some of the clubhouses of the game's most iconic venues.
CommentsJump to comments pagination
Comment number 47.Ozibrit
27th April 2013 - 0:48
Comment number 46.sharrison01
26th April 2013 - 9:16
Comment number 45.smacbean
25th April 2013 - 14:33
Comment number 44.RobRugby
25th April 2013 - 13:12
Comment number 43.Nick
25th April 2013 - 12:50
Comment number 42.Abdi
25th April 2013 - 9:12
Comment number 41.Tommy boy
25th April 2013 - 9:02
Comment number 40.RobRugby
25th April 2013 - 8:43
Comment number 39.randallandhopkirk
24th April 2013 - 21:58
Comment number 38.Lord Lucan
24th April 2013 - 21:39
Comment number 37.Thistledhub
24th April 2013 - 20:38
Comment number 36.John Petrie
24th April 2013 - 18:57
Comment number 35.flooch
24th April 2013 - 18:52
Comment number 34.TheRealJimmy
24th April 2013 - 18:42
Comment number 33.flooch
24th April 2013 - 18:40
Comment number 32.Bazc1975
24th April 2013 - 18:29
Comment number 31.abertawejacktoo
24th April 2013 - 18:07
Comment number 30.The Belly Putter
24th April 2013 - 17:41
Comment number 29.randallandhopkirk
24th April 2013 - 17:24
Comment number 28.TheRealJimmy
24th April 2013 - 16:09