Wycombe extended their unbeaten league run to five games as Dean Morgan pounced to deny York a first win since the opening day of the season.
Wycombe keeper Matt Ingram saved from Wes Fletcher before York took the lead.
David McGurk lost Kortney Hause at the back post from a Ryan Brobbel free-kick to head home the opener for York,
The lead lasted six minutes as Morgan reacted quickest to Matt McClure's shot cannoning back off a post for a simple tap-in to earn a draw.
VIEW FROM THE DRESSING ROOM
Wycombe manager Gareth Ainsworth told BBC Three Counties Radio:
"I think that it's not a point gained, but it's our unbeaten run continued.
"York came with a plan today, they've got a very experienced manager. They came for a point, they got a point and they're going away the happier team today.
"When teams come here and they shut up shop we're going to have to find ways of breaking them down. It's up to me and the coaching staff to work out ways of doing that.
"Great to see Dean Morgan on the score sheet again. It's five now for him and he's well on target for what he wants to do."
York City manager Nigel Worthington told BBC Radio York:
"It was a very very good display, but we haven't got our just rewards I don't think.
"I think we controlled a lot of the game and created a lot. Taking into account the goal we conceded, I think there was resilience there in the back four and middle two.
"We've stopped the rot, so we have to go and try and build on that next week."
Wycombe Wanderers 01 Ingram 02 McCoy 06 Johnson Booked 19 Hause 30 Doherty Booked 08 Lewis 11 Wood Booked 22 Kretzschmar 28 Knott (Bloomfield - 90' ) 07 Morgan Booked (Morias - 86' ) 29 McClure (Kuffour - 77' ) Substitutes 41 Harrison 03 Dunne 05 Stewart 23 Arnold 10 Bloomfield 17 Morias 18 Kuffour York City 24 Ingham 02 Oyebanjo 03 Davies 05 McGurk 06 Parslow 12 Carson Booked (Puri - 90' ) 14 Montrose 27 Brobbell (Chambers - 85' ) 29 Whitehouse 09 Fletcher (Bowman - 56' ) 11 Jarvis Substitutes 01 Kettings 04 Smith 23 Taft 18 Platt 28 Puri 10 Chambers 19 Bowman