Fulham v Newcastle
Fulham ended a run of seven matches without victory by claiming a hard-fought win over struggling Newcastle.
Steve Sidwell put the Cottagers ahead with a deflected shot - their first goal in over five hours of football.
Newcastle levelled when Hatem Ben Arfa beat home keeper Mark Schwarzer with a dipping effort from 25 yards.
But Hugo Rodallega's close-range header ensured the home side claimed a win that moves them three points ahead of United in the Premier League table.
Both these teams have reason to be disappointed with their season so far with Newcastle's injury and suspension-riddled campaign a shadow of their impressive previous one and Fulham's promising start to 2012-13 having tailed off dramatically in recent weeks.
It was no surprise then that this game was a closely-contested affair, with mistakes proving as decisive to the outcome as fluency and skill.
Martin Jol revels in 'vital' Fulham win over Newcastle
Fulham produced the greater amount of the latter and fewer of the former.
Damien Duff clearly had the bit between his teeth and was a regular threat to his ex-club with direct runs and accurate deliveries from either wing, while Dimitar Berbatov was typically intelligent in his movement and touch.
Fulham's key men
- Dimitar Berbatov received 52 passes in tonight's game, 19 more than any other Fulham player.
- Damien Duff produced as many assists for Fulham this evening as he did in 68 Premier League appearances for Newcastle.
The Cottagers did not have it all their own way - particularly during a 20-minute spell either side of the Newcastle goal - but demonstrated an appetite for the cause that will assist their desire to rise up the table.
Newcastle boosted their flagging season with a much-needed victory over Wigan last Monday, but seven days later it is clear they have much more work to do if the corner is to be turned.
It was another disjointed performance from Alan Pardew's side, who too often failed to get their most dangerous attacking players on the ball in areas where they could hurt the home side.
Demba Ba was isolated in attack, fellow striker Papiss Cisse - who scored 13 goals in 14 games for Newcastle last season but has only four in 20 this campaign - was wasted in a role that saw him operate largely on the right while Ben Arfa showed clear glimpses of his talent but is not yet up to speed after missing four games through injury.
They remain without an away win all season and still uncomfortably close to the relegation zone.
Alan Pardew says Newcastle 'can beat anybody' despite Fulham defeat
They were on the back foot from the off and deservedly fell behind when Sidwell's first-time shot from Duff's pass looped up off the knee of Mike Williamson and found the net via the underside of the crossbar.
They should have trailed by more at the break but twice Berbatov was foiled - the first time by a good save from Tim Krul after the striker had run clear of the defence and the second by a defender on the line from a close-range shot.
Newcastle were more of a threat after the break and levelled when Ben Arfa caught Schwarzer out with a shot from 25 yards that looped into the net off the toe of a defender.
However, Fulham battled back and reclaimed the lead when poor marking allowed Rodallega to head home unmarked from Duff's free-kick.
Both sides subsequently hit the woodwork - Fabricio Coloccini curling a shot against the post from range and Mladen Petric striking the corner of the goal-frame from 20 yards - but no further goals came to leave Fulham delighted and Newcastle crestfallen.
Fulham manager Martin Jol: "It was a vital win. If you lose this game you get in a depression and we didn't want that.
"It wasn't easy, although if you look at the chances we had we should have finished it off a lot earlier.
"I was happy that [Dimitar] Berbatov, after talking to him, could fill in that role [behind the striker]. It was vital, he didn't score so that was disappointing, but on the other hand he linked us up and kept the team together - I was very happy with him."
Lineup, Bookings (0) & Substitutions (5)
Fulham
- 01 Schwarzer
- 03 Riise
- 05 Hangeland
- 06 Baird
- 18 Hughes
- 27 Riether
- 07 Sidwell
- 16 Duff
- 31 Kacaniklic (Dejagah - 62' )
- 09 Berbatov
- 20 Rodallega (Petric - 86' )
Substitutes
- 38 Etheridge
- 04 Senderos
- 15 Richardson
- 14 Karagounis
- 19 Diarra
- 10 Petric
- 24 Dejagah
Newcastle United
- 01 Krul
- 02 Coloccini
- 03 Santon
- 05 Simpson
- 06 Williamson
- 08 Anita (Marveaux - 86' )
- 10 Ben Arfa (Sh Ameobi - 70' )
- 18 Gutierrez
- 24 Tiote (Bigirimana - 86' )
- 09 Cisse
- 19 Ba
Substitutes
- 37 Harper
- 14 Perch
- 31 Ferguson
- 34 Tavernier
- 20 Bigirimana
- 22 Marveaux
- 23 Sh Ameobi
Live Text Commentary
Full Time The final whistle goes and the game is over.
90:00 +3:56The ball is crossed by Fabricio Coloccini, save made by Mark Schwarzer.
90:00 +3:03Foul by Sylvain Marveaux on Damien Duff, free kick awarded. Free kick taken by Damien Duff.
90:00 +1:52Ashkan Dejagah challenges Jonas Gutierrez unfairly and gives away a free kick. Sylvain Marveaux crosses the ball in from the free kick, Steve Sidwell makes a clearance.
90:00 +1:05The ball is crossed by Jonas Gutierrez, save by Mark Schwarzer.
89:27Centre by Jonas Gutierrez, Demba Ba has a headed effort at goal from deep inside the area missing to the right of the target.
88:46The ball is crossed by Danny Simpson, Steve Sidwell manages to make a clearance.
88:14Mladen Petric has an effort at goal from outside the box hitting the post.
87:34Demba Ba takes a shot. Aaron Hughes gets a block in.
86:52Dimitar Berbatov takes a shot. Comfortable save by Tim Krul.
85:01Sascha Riether takes the free kick.
85:01 SubstitutionSubstitution Gael Bigirimana comes on in place of Cheick Tiote.
85:01 SubstitutionSubstitution Sylvain Marveaux on for Vurnon Anita.
85:01 SubstitutionSubstitution Mladen Petric replaces Hugo Rodallega.
85:01Foul by Fabricio Coloccini on Steve Sidwell, free kick awarded.
84:17Davide Santon delivers the ball, save made by Mark Schwarzer.
83:12Jonas Gutierrez takes a shot. Save by Mark Schwarzer.
82:21Demba Ba takes a shot. Mark Schwarzer makes a comfortable save.
81:26Shola Ameobi takes a shot. Mark Schwarzer makes a comfortable save.
79:36The ball is swung over by Davide Santon, clearance by Brede Hangeland.
Free kick awarded for a foul by Steve Sidwell on Jonas Gutierrez. Strike on goal comes in from Davide Santon from the free kick.
76:53Ashkan Dejagah challenges Jonas Gutierrez unfairly and gives away a free kick. Free kick taken by Vurnon Anita. The ball is sent over by Danny Simpson, Aaron Hughes makes a clearance.
74:50Foul by Shola Ameobi on Steve Sidwell, free kick awarded. Aaron Hughes restarts play with the free kick.
74:24Shot on goal by Steve Sidwell from just inside the area clears the crossbar.
74:10Damien Duff delivers the ball.
73:02A cross is delivered by Davide Santon, clearance by Brede Hangeland.
71:49Free kick awarded for a foul by Shola Ameobi on Sascha Riether. Direct free kick taken by Aaron Hughes.
71:23Hugo Rodallega takes a shot. Tim Krul makes a comfortable save.
70:40Effort from the edge of the penalty area by Fabricio Coloccini hits the post. Vurnon Anita has an effort at goal from just outside the area which goes wide of the left-hand post.
69:36Cheick Tiote restarts play with the free kick.
69:36 SubstitutionSubstitution Hatem Ben Arfa leaves the field to be replaced by Shola Ameobi.
69:36Steve Sidwell challenges Demba Ba unfairly and gives away a free kick.
69:09Dimitar Berbatov challenges Tim Krul unfairly and gives away a free kick. Tim Krul restarts play with the free kick.
68:54A cross is delivered by Damien Duff, Jonas Gutierrez manages to make a clearance.
68:25Danny Simpson delivers the ball.
66:46The assistant referee flags for offside against Papiss Cisse. Indirect free kick taken by Mark Schwarzer.
65:17A cross is delivered by Danny Simpson.
64:59Chris Baird challenges Cheick Tiote unfairly and gives away a free kick. Direct free kick taken by Cheick Tiote.
62:52The assist for the goal came from Damien Duff.
62:52 Goal scoredGoal - Hugo Rodallega - Fulham 2 - 1 Newcastle Hugo Rodallega finds the net with a headed goal from deep inside the penalty area. Fulham 2-1 Newcastle.
62:09Foul by Cheick Tiote on Ashkan Dejagah, free kick awarded. A cross is delivered by Damien Duff,
61:23 SubstitutionSubstitution Ashkan Dejagah replaces Alex Kacaniklic.
61:23Steve Sidwell takes a shot. Save made by Tim Krul.
60:23Shot from just outside the box by Alex Kacaniklic goes over the crossbar.
57:36Demba Ba takes a shot. Mark Schwarzer makes a comfortable save.
56:13Corner taken right-footed by Vurnon Anita, save by Mark Schwarzer.
55:27Danny Simpson sends in a cross.
53:21Assist by Vurnon Anita.
53:21 Goal scoredGoal - Hatem Ben Arfa - Fulham 1 - 1 Newcastle Goal scored by Hatem Ben Arfa from outside the penalty area to the top left corner of the goal. Fulham 1-1 Newcastle.
52:16A cross is delivered by Hatem Ben Arfa. Centre by Danny Simpson, blocked by Alex Kacaniklic. Danny Simpson produces a cross, Brede Hangeland makes a clearance.
52:01The ball is delivered by Danny Simpson, Brede Hangeland makes a clearance.
51:16The ball is swung over by Jonas Gutierrez, blocked by John Arne Riise.
50:14Dimitar Berbatov produces a right-footed shot from close range which goes wide of the right-hand upright.
48:51The ball is crossed by Alex Kacaniklic, Danny Simpson gets a block in. Corner taken by Chris Baird from the left by-line, Davide Santon manages to make a clearance.
46:52Vurnon Anita takes a shot from just outside the penalty area clears the crossbar.
46:20Free kick awarded for an unfair challenge on Jonas Gutierrez by Hugo Rodallega. Fabricio Coloccini takes the free kick.
45:01The referee gets the second half started.
43:10Jonas Gutierrez produces a drilled right-footed shot from 25 yards. Brede Hangeland gets a block in. Corner taken by Hatem Ben Arfa from the right by-line played to the near post, save made by Mark Schwarzer. Vurnon Anita takes a shot. Save made by Mark Schwarzer.
45:00 +1:22 Half timeHalf Time The ref blows to end the first period.
44:17Inswinging corner taken left-footed by Hatem Ben Arfa, Demba Ba takes a shot. Clearance by Sascha Riether.
43:10Jonas Gutierrez takes a shot. Brede Hangeland gets a block in. Hatem Ben Arfa takes the inswinging corner, save made by Mark Schwarzer. Vurnon Anita takes a shot. Save by Mark Schwarzer.
41:10Foul by Steve Sidwell on Cheick Tiote, free kick awarded. Free kick taken by Tim Krul.
39:21Centre by Danny Simpson, Brede Hangeland makes a clearance. Free kick awarded for a foul by Danny Simpson on Alex Kacaniklic. Chris Baird restarts play with the free kick.
38:12Effort on goal by John Arne Riise from long range goes harmlessly over the bar.
37:13Alex Kacaniklic crosses the ball, Tim Krul makes a comfortable save.
36:33Free kick awarded for a foul by Hatem Ben Arfa on Hugo Rodallega. Chris Baird restarts play with the free kick.
36:02Danny Simpson sends in a cross.
34:44Dimitar Berbatov gives away a free kick for an unfair challenge on Fabricio Coloccini. Tim Krul restarts play with the free kick.
33:50Handball by Steve Sidwell. Direct free kick taken by Demba Ba.
33:04Hugo Rodallega fouled by Mike Williamson, the ref awards a free kick. Free kick taken by Chris Baird.
31:32The ball is sent over by Davide Santon, Shot from deep inside the area by Hatem Ben Arfa clears the bar.
30:36Outswinging corner taken from the right by-line by Vurnon Anita, Fabricio Coloccini takes a shot. Sascha Riether manages to make a clearance.
29:24Free kick awarded for an unfair challenge on Aaron Hughes by Papiss Cisse. Free kick taken by Mark Schwarzer.
29:01The ball is delivered by Sascha Riether, Tim Krul makes a save. Dimitar Berbatov takes a shot. Mike Williamson manages to make a clearance.
26:40Jonas Gutierrez sends in a cross.
24:52Outswinging corner taken left-footed by Damien Duff, clearance by Fabricio Coloccini. Corner taken by Damien Duff, Demba Ba makes a clearance.
24:05Davide Santon takes a shot. Comfortable save by Mark Schwarzer.
23:52Jonas Gutierrez sends in a cross, Aaron Hughes makes a clearance.
23:00The ball is delivered by Papiss Cisse, Brede Hangeland manages to make a clearance.
22:25Free kick awarded for an unfair challenge on John Arne Riise by Danny Simpson. John Arne Riise restarts play with the free kick.
21:19Free kick awarded for a foul by Danny Simpson on Alex Kacaniklic. Direct free kick taken by John Arne Riise.
20:25Steve Sidwell challenges Jonas Gutierrez unfairly and gives away a free kick. Vurnon Anita takes the direct free kick.
19:48Dimitar Berbatov has a drilled shot. Save made by Tim Krul.
18:12The assist for the goal came from Damien Duff.
18:12 Goal scoredGoal - Steve Sidwell - Fulham 1 - 0 Newcastle Steve Sidwell gets on the score sheet with a goal from just inside the penalty area high into the middle of the goal. Fulham 1-0 Newcastle.
17:25A cross is delivered by Damien Duff, Hugo Rodallega produces a right-footed shot from inside the area that clears the bar.
15:20Shot from outside the area by Chris Baird misses to the left of the target.
14:40A cross is delivered by Papiss Cisse, Mark Schwarzer makes a comfortable save.
14:08Effort from outside the penalty area by Vurnon Anita goes wide left of the target.
13:32Corner taken by Chris Baird, Davide Santon manages to make a clearance.
13:21A cross is delivered by Alex Kacaniklic, blocked by Danny Simpson.
13:02Sascha Riether sends in a cross, Fabricio Coloccini makes a clearance.
12:02Dimitar Berbatov challenges Jonas Gutierrez unfairly and gives away a free kick. Free kick taken by Tim Krul.
10:35Vurnon Anita fouled by Alex Kacaniklic, the ref awards a free kick. Fabricio Coloccini takes the free kick.
10:14Centre by Damien Duff, Davide Santon gets a block in.
8:54Jonas Gutierrez takes a shot. Blocked by Chris Baird. The ball is swung over by Danny Simpson, save by Mark Schwarzer.
7:43The ball is crossed by Sascha Riether, comfortable save by Tim Krul.
5:56A cross is delivered by Sascha Riether, Fabricio Coloccini makes a clearance.
4:54Damien Duff sends in a cross, blocked by Jonas Gutierrez. Inswinging corner taken right-footed by Damien Duff, Chris Baird takes a shot. Clearance made by Cheick Tiote.
4:01The ball is delivered by Danny Simpson, clearance by Aaron Hughes.
2:50Centre by Danny Simpson, Mike Williamson has a headed effort at goal from just inside the area that misses to the right of the target.
2:13Foul by Dimitar Berbatov on Hatem Ben Arfa, free kick awarded. Vurnon Anita takes the free kick.
0:54Effort from the edge of the area by Alex Kacaniklic goes wide of the right-hand post.
0:16Damien Duff crosses the ball.
0:00The game kicks-off.
Live text and data provided by The Press Association
Comments
Jump to comments paginationAll posts are reactively-moderated and must obey the house rules.
More from Football
Elsewhere on the BBC
-
Watch video Art in the shadow of Hitler
Why Hitler’s propaganda war against modernism dominated German art
-
~RS~q~RS~v=~RS~z~RS~37~RS~)

Comment number 98.
TheOracleofDelphi11th December 2012 - 21:16
@86 I was there. You shaded the first half - although report fails to mention Fulham clearing off the line twice in 1st half. 2 or 3 up by half time? A tad myopic! 2nd half Newcastle created lots of chances - see stats, hit the woodwork twice and rightfully we feel aggrieved to get nothing from game - Fulham had some counterattacks 2nd half, but created little. You got the luck and the 3pts.
Link to this (Comment number 98)
Comment number 97.
Chelsea111th December 2012 - 20:10
When all is said and done Mr Pardew is safe, unfortunately the same can't be said about Newcastle.
Link to this (Comment number 97)
Comment number 96.
Paul220711th December 2012 - 16:21
Pardew seems lost this season with his tactics for the mass majority of last season he got them spot on but this year he just doesn't seem to have a set plan constant changing of positions during a match it's odd to see! Worst was taking Ben Arfa off last night after he scored and started to look a real threat although fantastic as a fulham it was to see it was a baffling decision!
Link to this (Comment number 96)
Comment number 95.
Edmondo11th December 2012 - 15:55
The realisation has to be we play 4-3-3, last season we played our best football in that formation. The reason we are not playing that formation is because Ba complains at being played on the wing instead of in the middle. Whilst I have no doubt about his scoring ability, for Newcastle to benefit he either has to accept playing on the wing or be sold and have Papiss back in the middle....
Link to this (Comment number 95)
Comment number 94.
Complete and utter horse11th December 2012 - 15:38
"First there was one striker but now we have two", have I hit a nerve? ;)
Where are you from, Surrey?
Link to this (Comment number 94)
Comments 5 of 98