Galatasaray v Man Utd
Manchester United lost their 100% record in the Champions League this season with defeat at Galatasaray.
Striker Burak Yilmaz scored his fifth goal of the group stage early in the second half when he leapt highest to head in from a right-wing corner.
The home side created the best chances, with Anders Lindegaard saving from Yilmaz and Hamit Altintop, who also saw a shot rattle the United woodwork.
Teenager Nick Powell had United's best chance when his header struck the bar.
With Cluj beating Braga, it was essential for Fatih Terim's side to secure victory over the three-time European champions.
Match facts
- Burak Yilmaz has scored all five of the goals that Galatasaray have netted in the Champions League this season
- At an average age of 24 years and 154 days, this was the third youngest starting line-up that Man Utd have ever selected in a Champions League game
Those two sides have seven points and are both vying for second spot, while United remain on 12 points, having already won the group.
With qualification for the last 16 secured and having left several senior players at home, this encounter gave Sir Alex Ferguson the chance to see if the next generation could cope in an intense atmosphere.
Of particular interest to some United fans would have been the performance of those competing for a spot in central midfield.
Long-serving United pros Ryan Giggs and Michael Carrick looked leggy against Norwich in last weekend's 1-0 defeat, with Ferguson bringing on a 38-year-old - in the form of Paul Scholes - to try to remedy the situation after his side fell behind.
Giggs and Scholes are the burning embers of what remains of the golden midfield that helped the club achieve its successes of the last 20 years.
The two players touted to lead the new generation of midfielders - Tom Cleverley and Powell - started at the Turk Telekom Arena.
Cleverley, 23, has seized his chance this season and produced a steady, if unspectacular performance, in Turkey, but alongside him was a player five years his junior trying to show his manager that he has a long-term future at the club.
Powell, who scored for Crewe in a 2-1 win against Morecambe a year ago yesterday, was excellent on his first Champions League start.
He seemed to forge a good understanding with forward Danny Welbeck, coped well with the physical presence of Brazilian powerhouse Felipe Melo and came closest to scoring for the Red Devils when his header came off the woodwork.
United's other opportunities were merely half-chances, with the starting XI - with an average age of 24 - on the back foot for much of the match against a side fighting for their Champions League future.
Melo was impressive in midfield, although he was lucky not to get punished for some rough early tackles, while Yilmaz and the fantastic winger Nordin Amrabat were a constant threat in the final third of the pitch.
Yilmaz, who has scored all of Galatasaray's goals this campaign, forced a great stop from Lindegaard, although the Turk should have scored when he failed to make a connection with a cross from three yards out.
Turkey international Altintop once again showed his potency from distance, forcing another great save from Lindegaard, before smacking the underside of the bar in the second half with a venomous effort which Lindegaard got a slight touch to.
United coped well with much of what was thrown at them, except for the one moment shortly after the restart when Yilmaz leapt ahead of team-mate Melo to head in the only goal of the match.
Lineup, Bookings (3) & Substitutions (6)
Galatasaray
- 25 Muslera
- 13 Dany Nounkeu
- 26 Kaya Booked
- 27 Eboue
- 04 Altintop
- 08 Inan
- 09 Elmander (Baytar - 63' )
- 10 Felipe Melo
- 11 Riera
- 17 Yilmaz Booked (Bulut - 90' )
- 53 Amrabat (Colak - 81' )
Substitutes
- 86 Ufuk Ceylan
- 03 Cris
- 33 Birinci
- 35 Kurtulus
- 50 Baytar
- 52 Colak
- 19 Bulut
Manchester United
- 13 Lindegaard
- 02 Rafael Booked
- 04 Jones
- 28 Buttner
- 08 Anderson (Young - 74' )
- 16 Carrick
- 23 Cleverley
- 24 Fletcher
- 25 Powell (Macheda - 74' )
- 14 Hernandez
- 19 Welbeck (King - 85' )
Substitutes
- 50 Johnstone
- 31 Wootton
- 36 Vermijl
- 18 Young
- 34 Cole
- 27 Macheda
- 41 King
Live Text Commentary
Full Time The referee blows his whistle to end the game.
90:00 +2:18Federico Macheda is caught offside. Free kick taken by Fernando Muslera.
90:00 +0:54Outswinging corner taken by Ashley Young from the right by-line, free kick awarded for a foul by Joshua King on Dany Nounkeu. Direct free kick taken by Fernando Muslera.
90:00 +0:08 SubstitutionSubstitution Umut Bulut is brought on as a substitute for Burak Yilmaz.
90:00Centre by Joshua King, clearance by Dany Nounkeu.
89:16Javier Hernandez takes a shot. Save by Fernando Muslera.
87:52Dany Nounkeu concedes a free kick for a foul on Federico Macheda. Tom Cleverley takes the direct free kick.
87:32De Carvalho Felipe Melo has an effort at goal. Save by Anders Lindegaard.
85:59The assistant referee flags for offside against Emre Colak. Free kick taken by Anders Lindegaard.
84:10 SubstitutionSubstitution Joshua King on for Danny Welbeck.
80:05 SubstitutionSubstitution (Galatasaray) makes a substitution, with Emre Colak coming on for Nordin Amrabat.
79:30Free kick awarded for a foul by Engin Baytar on Phil Jones. Tom Cleverley restarts play with the free kick.
77:24Hamit Altintop takes a shot from 25 yards.
76:40 BookingBooking Burak Yilmaz goes into the book.
74:20Rafael Da Silva challenges Burak Yilmaz unfairly and gives away a free kick. Selcuk Inan takes the direct free kick.
73:08 SubstitutionSubstitution Nick Powell leaves the field to be replaced by Federico Macheda.
73:08 SubstitutionSubstitution Oliveira Anderson goes off and Ashley Young comes on.
68:27Rafael Da Silva fouled by Nordin Amrabat, the ref awards a free kick. Rafael Da Silva restarts play with the free kick.
67:14Danny Welbeck challenges Semih Kaya unfairly and gives away a free kick. Free kick taken by Semih Kaya.
63:45Foul by Nordin Amrabat on Rafael Da Silva, free kick awarded. Direct free kick taken by Rafael Da Silva.
Substitution Engin Baytar on for Johan Elmander.
62:15Inswinging corner taken left-footed by Oliveira Anderson played to the near post.
62:00Corner taken by Oliveira Anderson played to the near post, De Carvalho Felipe Melo makes a clearance.
61:45Oliveira Anderson takes a inswinging corner to the near post, clearance by De Carvalho Felipe Melo.
60:39Inswinging corner taken from the left by-line by Selcuk Inan, save made by Anders Lindegaard.
60:18Emmanuel Eboue takes a shot. Anders Lindegaard makes a save.
59:10Oliveira Anderson takes a shot. Save by Fernando Muslera.
58:09Javier Hernandez takes a shot.
55:22The ball is sent over by Nordin Amrabat.
54:26Free kick awarded for an unfair challenge on Selcuk Inan by Nick Powell. Free kick taken by Emmanuel Eboue.
53:01Assist by Selcuk Inan.
53:01 Goal scoredGoal - Burak Yilmaz - Galatasa'y 1 - 0 Man Utd Burak Yilmaz finds the net with a headed goal from inside the six-yard box. Galatasaray 1-0 Man Utd.
52:41De Carvalho Felipe Melo takes a shot. Save made by Anders Lindegaard. Outswinging corner taken from the right by-line by Selcuk Inan,
51:13Unfair challenge on Alexander Buttner by Hamit Altintop results in a free kick. Free kick taken by Alexander Buttner.
48:47Shot by Albert Riera. Anders Lindegaard makes a save.
47:46Alexander Buttner produces a cross.
47:25Burak Yilmaz is ruled offside. Indirect free kick taken by Darren Fletcher.
46:17Effort from outside the area by Nick Powell goes wide right of the goal.
45:34Free kick awarded for an unfair challenge on Tom Cleverley by Selcuk Inan. Direct free kick taken by Anders Lindegaard.
45:01The second half kicks off.
45:00 +1:29 Half timeHalf Time The match has reached half-time.
45:00 +0:03The ball is delivered by Albert Riera, Phil Jones manages to make a clearance.
44:15Albert Riera sends in a cross, Michael Carrick manages to make a clearance.
43:32Foul by Oliveira Anderson on Dany Nounkeu, free kick awarded. Dany Nounkeu takes the direct free kick.
42:11Inswinging corner taken right-footed by Tom Cleverley from the left by-line, Nick Powell takes a shot.
40:48The assistant referee flags for offside against Nordin Amrabat. Indirect free kick taken by Anders Lindegaard.
39:17Free kick awarded for an unfair challenge on Tom Cleverley by Nordin Amrabat. Rafael Da Silva takes the free kick.
38:57Corner taken short by Oliveira Anderson.
38:06Effort on goal by Nick Powell from long range goes harmlessly over the bar.
37:51Free kick awarded for an unfair challenge on Phil Jones by Burak Yilmaz. Phil Jones restarts play with the free kick.
36:14Inswinging corner taken right-footed by Tom Cleverley from the left by-line, De Carvalho Felipe Melo makes a clearance.
35:56Corner from the right by-line taken by Oliveira Anderson, save by Fernando Muslera.
34:43Free kick awarded for an unfair challenge on Rafael Da Silva by Selcuk Inan. The free kick is delivered left-footed by Oliveira Anderson from right channel.
34:21Foul by Dany Nounkeu on Javier Hernandez, free kick awarded. Rafael Da Silva takes the direct free kick.
33:43Hamit Altintop takes a shot. Save by Anders Lindegaard.
31:43Foul by Oliveira Anderson on Albert Riera, free kick awarded. Free kick crossed right-footed by Selcuk Inan from left wing.
30:48Free kick awarded for a foul by Nick Powell on Burak Yilmaz. De Carvalho Felipe Melo takes the direct free kick.
28:30Foul by De Carvalho Felipe Melo on Tom Cleverley, free kick awarded. Oliveira Anderson takes the direct free kick.
27:55De Carvalho Felipe Melo fouled by Nick Powell, the ref awards a free kick. De Carvalho Felipe Melo takes the free kick.
24:17Nordin Amrabat takes a shot.
19:53Centre by Selcuk Inan, Close range header by Burak Yilmaz goes over the bar.
19:53 BookingBooking Rafael Da Silva is given a yellow card.
19:51Rafael Da Silva concedes a free kick for a foul on Nordin Amrabat.
18:36De Carvalho Felipe Melo fouled by Oliveira Anderson, the ref awards a free kick. De Carvalho Felipe Melo restarts play with the free kick.
17:45Nordin Amrabat has an effort at goal from just inside the box that misses to the left of the goal. Corner taken by Selcuk Inan from the left by-line.
17:33Hamit Altintop sends in a cross.
16:14Hamit Altintop challenges Javier Hernandez unfairly and gives away a free kick. Free kick taken by Oliveira Anderson.
15:02Alexander Buttner gives away a free kick for an unfair challenge on Hamit Altintop. Fernando Muslera takes the direct free kick.
12:40Nordin Amrabat is flagged offside by the assistant referee. Anders Lindegaard restarts play with the free kick.
10:55Free kick awarded for an unfair challenge on Alexander Buttner by De Carvalho Felipe Melo. Alexander Buttner takes the free kick.
8:54Shot from outside the area by Nordin Amrabat misses to the left of the target.
7:45Free kick taken by Phil Jones.
7:45 BookingBooking Semih Kaya is booked.
7:44Semih Kaya concedes a free kick for a foul on Alexander Buttner.
4:54Free kick awarded for an unfair challenge on Hamit Altintop by Alexander Buttner. Dany Nounkeu restarts play with the free kick.
4:15Burak Yilmaz produces a drilled right-footed shot from 30 yards. Anders Lindegaard makes a save.
3:40Unfair challenge on Nick Powell by De Carvalho Felipe Melo results in a free kick. Alexander Buttner restarts play with the free kick.
1:44Tom Cleverley takes a shot. Fernando Muslera makes a save.
0:00The ref blows the whistle to begin the match.
Live text and data provided by The Press Association
Comments
Jump to comments paginationAll posts are reactively-moderated and must obey the house rules.
More from Football
Elsewhere on the BBC
-
Winning business
Why trying to become a successful entrepreneur has never been more fashionable
-
~RS~q~RS~v=~RS~z~RS~32~RS~)

Comment number 244.
YAMS22nd November 2012 - 21:03
Lol, what is that referring to?! Drunk already? I'd lay off that home made vodka if I were you.
Still waiting for your plausible explanation why you believe Utd get all the decisions in your posted stats...... If you have the balls.
Link to this (Comment number 244)
Comment number 243.
Chelsea 9 vs MU 1122nd November 2012 - 20:59
http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/0/football/20434132?postid=114421596#comment_114421596
Link to this (Comment number 243)
Comment number 242.
YAMS22nd November 2012 - 20:50
Who are you asking the questions too now?!
Do you have an answer why Utd get all these decisions in your stats?!
What do you think the plausible explanation is?!
Link to this (Comment number 242)
Comment number 241.
Chelsea 9 vs MU 1122nd November 2012 - 20:47
Why is Evans not penalized for his challenges & foul on Shelvey & Torres that got them sent off? Why then did BR/RDM & Graham Poll states otherwise?
Why was Shaun Derry red carded when even Fergie stated it wasn't?
Yes MU's sending off ( 0 MU players sent off with 10 opposition red carded) stats is a PL Joke. Even King Kenny will attest to that ;)
City & Chelsea got 12 players sent off. Go figure
Link to this (Comment number 241)
Comment number 240.
YAMS22nd November 2012 - 20:30
So it's ok for you to ask someone a question on a topic he hasn't even mentioned but not to ask you a question on the very topic you are talking about.....?
I'll repeat your question
What do you think of MU sending off ' 0 & 10' stats ( 0 MU vs 10 opposition players red carded) in contrast to MU's superiors.. Chelsea 5 & 3 or City '7 & 2 over the past 56 weeks?
Do give me a plausible explanation?
Link to this (Comment number 240)
Comments 5 of 244