Aston Villa v Norwich
Michael Turner's header earned Norwich City a point and denied 10-man Aston Villa victory in manager Paul Lambert's first meeting with his old club.
Lambert, who left City in acrimonious circumstances in the summer, saw his side take a first-half lead through Christian Benteke's cool finish.
But the game turned seven minutes after the break when Villa's Joe Bennett was sent off for a second booking.
And, after sustained pressure, Turner's header earned a deserved draw.
Relentless second-half Norwich domination had threatened to overwhelm a Villa side who had taken the lead against the run of play.
Villa's home troubles
Villa have only won two of their last 17 home matches since beating Norwich in last season's corresponding fixture nearly a year ago
And Lambert will be relieved to earn a draw, even though it means Villa's start to the season is the club's poorest to a campaign for 43 years and leaves them hovering just above the Premier League relegation zone.
Although the vast majority of the pre-match build-up had concentrated on Lambert's Carrow Road exit, he had insisted this was "just another game".
The Scot and Norwich are both suing each other for breach of contract and the matter is to be decided by a Premier League managers' tribunal.
But the apathy with which the Norwich fans greeted Lambert suggested their main feeling was of respect and gratitude to a man who had won them two promotions and masterminded such an impressive first season back in the top flight.
And with just one win apiece from a combined total of 16 league games, and both sides struggling, neither team could afford to be distracted.
Heavy defeats against Liverpool and Chelsea had left Canaries fans preparing for a miserable season, but last Saturday's fine 1-0 win over Arsenal seemed to have renewed their belief and an unchanged side looked busy, confident and dangerous in the opening stages.
Villa effort impresses Lambert
Grant Holt, the matchwinner against the Gunners, led the line impressively and he and the busy Wes Hoolahan posed constant problems for a reshuffled and injury-ravaged Villa defence.
Hoolahan should have put the visitors ahead when sent through by Holt's clever pass, but keeper Brad Guzan came out quickly to make a decent block with his feet.
Villa appeared nervous, struggling to retain possession, and their edginess was beginning to transmit itself to the home support.
But they took the lead with their first meaningful attack on 27 minutes after a mix-up involving both Norwich centre-backs.
Sebastien Bassong and Turner allowed Benteke too much space and the striker, who was preferred to Darren Bent up front, sent keeper John Ruddy the wrong way with a calmly slotted finish after good work by Joe Bennett.
Lambert's side finally settled and briefly threatened to build on their lead. Benteke had a header comfortably saved after the interval, but when Joe Bennett was dismissed after picking up a second caution for blocking Elliott Bennett, Norwich seized complete control.
The excellent Hoolahan went close on a couple of occasions, Holt was denied by Guzan when through one on one, and only some inspired Villa defending - particularly from Ron Vlaar - kept the visitors at bay.
Analysis
"A lively second half made up for a generally lacklustre first. It ended honours even but Norwich had the chances to win it. Villa defended so stoutly and Paul Lambert will be relieved to get a point, but Norwich will feel they should have gone on to win."
But finally the pressure told and Hoolahan was inevitably involved in the equaliser, finding the head of Turner with a delightful right-wing cross following a quickly taken short corner.
More Norwich chances followed but Guzan made several decent saves, defenders blocked a series of long-range efforts and Villa were able to hold on.
Aston Villa manager Paul Lambert:
"I think the sending off changed a lot. That changed the game.
"At first thought I thought it was a sending off, because when you commit a foul and you go to do something, then you put yourself in a position where you can get the red.
"But, looking at it again, I think Elliott, too, has had hold of Joe. It was a bit of an even contest and I think the two of them were at it.
"I haven't had the chance to talk to the ref [Phil Dowd] about it yet. I've only just watched a tape of it. But I thought the team were brilliant with the way they defended strongly after that.
"Will Villa will be okay? I have great belief we'll be totally fine."
Norwich City manager Chris Hughton:
"I think it was two points that got away. When you are 1-0 down, you are delighted to get back in the game.
Norwich the better side - Hughton
"If it's 0-0 and you have the pressure we had at the end, you are more disappointed.
"You can look at the game apart from possession, balance of play and amount of ball in the final third, as one of three clearcut chances.
"They had one and Benteke put it away. We had two with Wes Hoolahan and Grant Holt and we didn't but I thought having gone down 1-0, we came out second half with a good attitude and forced the issue.
"I think I would have been confident enough we would have got back in the game even with 11 men."
Lineup, Bookings (3) & Substitutions (6)
Aston Villa
- 22 Guzan
- 04 Vlaar
- 27 Bennett Dismissed after an earlier booking
- 34 Lowton
- 08 El Ahmadi
- 12 Albrighton
- 16 Delph
- 31 Herd Booked
- 11 Agbonlahor (Lichaj - 54' )
- 14 Holman (Weimann - 76' )
- 20 Benteke (Bent - 69' )
Substitutes
- 01 Given
- 30 Lichaj
- 07 Ireland
- 15 Westwood
- 25 Bannan
- 09 Bent
- 26 Weimann
Norwich City
- 01 Ruddy
- 02 R Martin (R Bennett - 46' )
- 05 Bassong
- 06 Turner
- 18 Garrido
- 04 Johnson (Morison - 70' )
- 12 Pilkington
- 14 Hoolahan
- 17 E Bennett (Snodgrass - 64' )
- 27 Tettey
- 09 Holt
Substitutes
- 13 Rudd
- 20 Barnett
- 24 R Bennett
- 08 Howson
- 07 Snodgrass
- 10 Jackson
- 16 Morison
Live Text Commentary
Full Time The referee brings the game to a close.
90:00 +4:25Close range shot by Robert Snodgrass clears the bar.
90:00 +1:47The ball is delivered by Steve Morison, Effort on goal by Ryan Bennett from inside the area goes harmlessly over the bar.
90:00 +1:39Foul by Matthew Lowton on Wesley Hoolahan, free kick awarded. Direct free kick taken by Wesley Hoolahan.
87:27Foul by Fabian Delph on Wesley Hoolahan, free kick awarded. Robert Snodgrass produces a strike on goal direct from the free kick.
86:53Corner taken by Robert Snodgrass from the right by-line, clearance made by Eric Lichaj.
86:42Centre by Andreas Weimann, Michael Turner manages to make a clearance.
85:33Corner taken by Anthony Pilkington.
84:19The referee blows for offside against Steve Morison. Bradley Guzan takes the indirect free kick.
83:56Centre by Robert Snodgrass, save by Bradley Guzan.
81:29The ball is delivered by Steve Morison.
79:30Robert Snodgrass challenges Eric Lichaj unfairly and gives away a free kick. Direct free kick taken by Fabian Delph.
78:03The assist for the goal came from Wesley Hoolahan.
78:03 Goal scoredGoal - Michael Turner - A Villa 1 - 1 Norwich Michael Turner finds the back of the net with a headed goal from inside the six-yard box. Aston Villa 1-1 Norwich.
77:59Short corner taken by Robert Snodgrass from the right by-line, The ball is swung over by Wesley Hoolahan,
77:49Robert Snodgrass takes a shot. Blocked by Ron Vlaar.
77:31The ball is delivered by Anthony Pilkington, Ron Vlaar makes a clearance.
77:02Centre by Robert Snodgrass, clearance by Ron Vlaar.
76:45Unfair challenge on Wesley Hoolahan by Fabian Delph results in a free kick. Wesley Hoolahan takes the direct free kick.
76:19Grant Holt takes a shot. Save made by Bradley Guzan.
Substitution Andreas Weimann replaces Brett Holman.
74:47Centre by Javier Garrido.
74:08Karim El Ahmadi gives away a free kick for an unfair challenge on Wesley Hoolahan. Wesley Hoolahan takes the direct free kick.
72:10The ball is swung over by Anthony Pilkington, save by Bradley Guzan.
70:45Inswinging corner taken from the left by-line by Anthony Pilkington, Robert Snodgrass takes a shot. Matthew Lowton gets a block in. The ball is swung over by Robert Snodgrass, Ron Vlaar manages to make a clearance.
71:48Corner taken right-footed by Anthony Pilkington.
71:25A cross is delivered by Anthony Pilkington, blocked by Marc Albrighton.
70:45Inswinging corner taken from the left by-line by Anthony Pilkington, Robert Snodgrass takes a shot. Marc Albrighton gets a block in. Robert Snodgrass produces a cross, Ron Vlaar makes a clearance.
70:31Javier Garrido sends in a cross, clearance by Chris Herd.
69:56The ball is delivered by Grant Holt, clearance made by Matthew Lowton.
69:13 SubstitutionSubstitution Bradley Johnson goes off and Steve Morison comes on.
68:52 SubstitutionSubstitution Darren Bent is brought on as a substitute for Christian Benteke.
68:18Centre by Bradley Johnson.
68:18The ball is sent over by Bradley Johnson.
67:35Robert Snodgrass crosses the ball, clearance by Ron Vlaar.
65:32Free kick awarded for a foul by Robert Snodgrass on Fabian Delph. Bradley Guzan restarts play with the free kick.
63:09Corner taken by Anthony Pilkington from the left by-line played to the near post, clearance by Christian Benteke. Robert Snodgrass takes a shot. Blocked by Ron Vlaar. Bradley Johnson has an effort at goal from outside the box which goes wide right of the goal.
63:09 SubstitutionSubstitution Robert Snodgrass comes on in place of Elliott Bennett.
63:09Wesley Hoolahan takes a shot. Save by Bradley Guzan.
62:21Direct free kick taken by Sebastien Bassong.
62:21 BookingBooking Chris Herd is shown a yellow card for unsporting behaviour.
62:11Unfair challenge on Grant Holt by Chris Herd results in a free kick.
58:24Javier Garrido sends in a cross, comfortable save by Bradley Guzan.
58:00Christian Benteke is caught offside. John Ruddy takes the indirect free kick.
57:01Elliott Bennett sends in a cross. The assistant referee signals for offside against Grant Holt. Bradley Guzan takes the indirect free kick.
56:44The ball is crossed by Ryan Bennett, clearance made by Ron Vlaar.
54:18Free kick awarded for an unfair challenge on Chris Herd by Grant Holt. Bradley Guzan restarts play with the free kick.
53:43 SubstitutionSubstitution Eric Lichaj replaces Gabriel Agbonlahor.
53:04The ball is sent over by Elliott Bennett, save made by Bradley Guzan.
51:38Free kick crossed left-footed by Anthony Pilkington from right wing, save by Bradley Guzan.
51:38 DismissalDismissal The referee sends off Joe Bennett for second bookable offence.
51:29Elliott Bennett fouled by Joe Bennett, the ref awards a free kick.
49:41The ball is swung over by Matthew Lowton, Ryan Bennett makes a clearance. Free kick awarded for an unfair challenge on Alexander Tettey by Christian Benteke. John Ruddy restarts play with the free kick.
48:36Free kick awarded for an unfair challenge on Grant Holt by Ron Vlaar. The free kick is swung in left-footed by Anthony Pilkington, clearance made by Christian Benteke.
47:03Joe Bennett produces a cross, clearance made by Sebastien Bassong. Corner taken by Marc Albrighton, save made by John Ruddy.
45:37The ball is crossed by Marc Albrighton, Christian Benteke takes a shot. Save by John Ruddy.
45:01The referee blows his whistle to start the second half.
45:01 SubstitutionSubstitution Ryan Bennett joins the action as a substitute, replacing Russell Martin.
45:00 +1:09 Half timeHalf Time The referee blows for half time.
44:04Bradley Johnson concedes a free kick for a foul on Fabian Delph. Joe Bennett crosses the ball, Christian Benteke takes a shot. Comfortable save by John Ruddy.
42:38Foul by Michael Turner on Gabriel Agbonlahor, free kick awarded. Fabian Delph restarts play with the free kick.
39:50Grant Holt has an effort at goal from outside the area which goes wide right of the goal.
39:13Short corner worked by Anthony Pilkington.
38:46Anthony Pilkington sends in a cross, clearance by Brett Holman.
38:16Javier Garrido crosses the ball, clearance by Ron Vlaar.
37:43Inswinging corner taken right-footed by Marc Albrighton from the left by-line to the near post, save by John Ruddy.
37:31Christian Benteke takes a shot. Blocked by Michael Turner.
36:21Fabian Delph fouled by Alexander Tettey, the ref awards a free kick. Free kick crossed left-footed by Fabian Delph.
35:23The referee blows for offside against Wesley Hoolahan. Ron Vlaar restarts play with the free kick.
33:18The referee blows for offside against Anthony Pilkington. Indirect free kick taken by Chris Herd.
32:40The ball is crossed by Javier Garrido, clearance by Fabian Delph. Gabriel Agbonlahor produces a cross.
26:01The assist for the goal came from Brett Holman.
29:12Marc Albrighton challenges Bradley Johnson unfairly and gives away a free kick. Free kick crossed left-footed by Anthony Pilkington.
28:22Free kick crossed left-footed by Anthony Pilkington, save by Bradley Guzan.
28:22 BookingBooking Joe Bennett receives a yellow card for unsporting behaviour.
28:18Free kick awarded for an unfair challenge on Elliott Bennett by Joe Bennett.
27:29The official flags Elliott Bennett offside. Bradley Guzan takes the indirect free kick.
26:01Joe Bennett provided the assist for the goal.
26:01 Goal scoredGoal - Christian Benteke - A Villa 1 - 0 Norwich Christian Benteke finds the back of the net with a goal from deep inside the penalty box to the bottom right corner of the goal. Aston Villa 1-0 Norwich.
24:49Karim El Ahmadi has an effort at goal from outside the box which goes wide right of the goal.
24:12The ball is sent over by Russell Martin.
22:16The assistant referee flags for offside against Sebastien Bassong. Bradley Guzan takes the free kick.
22:16Sebastien Bassong is flagged offside by the assistant referee. Bradley Guzan restarts play with the free kick.
21:29Inswinging corner taken left-footed by Anthony Pilkington from the right by-line to the near post, clearance made by Fabian Delph.
21:12Wesley Hoolahan takes a shot. Save by Bradley Guzan.
20:39Christian Benteke is ruled offside. John Ruddy takes the indirect free kick.
19:25Centre by Matthew Lowton.
17:37Foul by Anthony Pilkington on Christian Benteke, free kick awarded. Marc Albrighton delivers the ball from the free kick right-footed from right channel, Grant Holt makes a clearance.
13:51Elliott Bennett takes a shot and went wide of the left-hand upright.
12:26Alexander Tettey takes a shot.
10:50Anthony Pilkington fouled by Fabian Delph, the ref awards a free kick. John Ruddy takes the free kick.
9:44Wesley Hoolahan is ruled offside. Chris Herd takes the indirect free kick.
7:30Foul by Chris Herd on Wesley Hoolahan, free kick awarded. Bradley Johnson crosses the ball from the free kick left-footed from left channel, Joe Bennett manages to make a clearance.
6:58Brett Holman takes a shot. John Ruddy makes a save.
5:16Inswinging corner taken right-footed by Marc Albrighton from the left by-line, Christian Benteke has a headed effort at goal from deep inside the area missing to the right of the goal.
2:46The ball is delivered by Elliott Bennett.
0:00The game gets underway.
Live text and data provided by The Press Association
More from Football
Elsewhere on the BBC
-
Watch video Art in the shadow of Hitler
Why Hitler’s propaganda war against modernism dominated German art
-
~RS~q~RS~~RS~z~RS~42~RS~)