Scotland v Macedonia
Highlights - Scotland 1-1 Macedonia
Scotland's chances of qualifying for World Cup 2014 hang by a thread after just two matches following a second home draw in four days.
Macedonia's early goal by Nikolce Noveski should have been chalked off for offside, but they were good value for the lead.
Kenny Miller levelled before the break having been set up by Jamie Mackie.
Both sides had chances to win, with Macedonia hitting the post and forcing Allan McGregor into several good saves.
Arguments may be made about there still being plenty of points to play for.
But, on the evidence of the games so far, Scotland will not be going to Brazil in two years' time.
Miller and Morrison celebrate after Scotland's equaliser at Hampden Park
The home side did fashion the first chance of the match, but Gary Caldwell's left-foot drive was never in danger of threatening Martin Bogatinov's goal.
Conversely, Ivan Trichkovski's drilled shot from 10 yards just a few moments later had McGregor scrambling to turn it wide.
Macedonia took confidence from that and, when Trichkovski fired the ball across goal and Noveski, who was a yard offside, directed it past McGregor from six yards to give Macedonia an 11th-minute lead.
Scotland were rattled and, unlike their more technically adept opponents, were unable to string more than a couple of passes together.
Agim Ibraimi came within inches of inflicting further grief on the home side, as his shot on the turn flew close.
McGregor again bailed his side out as they were caught on the counter-attack and, although there was a whiff of offside, Ibraimi was allowed to shoot, only for McGregor to block superbly.
Shaun Maloney and Mackie tried their best to drag the Scots up by their bootlaces, with both players busy and energetic.
A Maloney corner was headed just wide by Andy Webster on the half-hour mark before Bogatinov was forced to punch away a powerful free kick by the Wigan player.
As half-time approached, Scotland at last began to build some momentum, with James Forrest also springing to life.
It was James Morrison who managed to squeeze a ball past Vanche Shikov through to Mackie, who showed supreme selflessness to square for Miller to tap into the empty net.
Interview - Scotland manager Craig Levein
The Scots began to display a vigour that had been absent previously and Paul Dixon tested Bogatinov with a low drive from long range at the start of the second half.
Scotland were certainly more of an attacking threat by this stage, but Macedonia still looked the likelier side to score and Ferhan Hasani hammered a shot off McGregor's left-hand post from just outside the box.
Charlie Adam replaced Miller and then the Hampden crowd got the substitution for which they had been clamouring as Jordan Rhodes came on for Morrison and the pair almost combined to immediate effect.
However, the striker's flashing header at the near post from Adam's cross found only the side-netting.
McGregor continued to show his worth as he rushed out to deny Mirko Ivanovski, who had been played in by a deft pass from the left boot of the majestic Goran Pandev.
By the closing 15 minutes, Macedonia were content to take a point and Bogatinov was largely untroubled as they managed that relatively comfortably, much to the chagrin of the home support.
Lineup, Bookings (6) & Substitutions (6)
Scotland
- 01 McGregor
- 02 Hutton
- 03 Dixon
- 04 Berra
- 05 Caldwell
- 08 Webster
- 07 Morrison (Rhodes - 66' )
- 16 Maloney
- 17 Forrest
- 09 Miller (Adam - 58' Booked )
- 15 Mackie (Naismith - 77' )
Substitutes
- 12 Marshall
- 21 Samson
- 13 G Hanley
- 22 Foster
- 06 Adam
- 18 Cowie
- 19 Dorrans
- 23 M Phillips
- 10 Snodgrass
- 11 Naismith
- 14 Rhodes
- 20 McCormack
FYR Macedonia
- 01 Bogatinov
- 02 Georgievski
- 03 Popov
- 04 Noveski
- 06 Sikov
- 16 Gligorov Booked (Shumulikoski - 70' Booked )
- 18 Demiri
- 07 Trickovski (Hasani - 37' Booked )
- 10 Pandev Booked
- 19 Ibraimi Booked (Tasevski - 89' )
- 21 Ivanovski
Substitutes
- 12 Pacovski
- 22 Naumovski
- 05 Grncarov
- 14 Lazevski
- 15 Mojsov
- 08 Shumulikoski
- 17 Tasevski
- 20 Georgiev
- 09 Ristic
- 11 Hasani
Live Text Commentary
Full Time The referee blows for the end of the match.
90:00 +2:51The offside flag is raised against Mirko Ivanovski. Free kick taken by Allan McGregor.
90:00 +1:33Corner taken by Charlie Adam from the right by-line, save by Martin Bogatinov.
88:28 SubstitutionSubstitution (FYR Macedonia) makes a substitution, with Darko Tasevski coming on for Agim Ibraimi.
87:49Goran Pandev takes a shot. Save by Allan McGregor.
86:42Unfair challenge on Daniel Georgievski by Paul Dixon results in a free kick. Martin Bogatinov takes the free kick.
84:49Alan Hutton produces a cross.
83:18Free kick awarded for an unfair challenge on Agim Ibraimi by Charlie Adam. Agim Ibraimi restarts play with the free kick.
81:45Corner taken by Shaun Maloney.
80:55Unfair challenge on Martin Bogatinov by Jordan Rhodes results in a free kick. Free kick taken by Martin Bogatinov.
80:23Inswinging corner taken by Charlie Adam, save by Martin Bogatinov.
79:40Alan Hutton fouled by Ferhan Hasani, the ref awards a free kick. Direct free kick taken by Alan Hutton.
77:19Direct free kick taken by Charlie Adam.
77:19 BookingBooking Velice Sumulikoski shown a yellow card.
77:16Velice Sumulikoski concedes a free kick for a foul on James Forrest.
76:32 SubstitutionSubstitution Steven Naismith joins the action as a substitute, replacing Jamie Mackie.
76:14Centre by James Forrest.
75:19Inswinging corner taken right-footed by Ferhan Hasani from the left by-line, Goran Popov takes a shot. Comfortable save by Allan McGregor.
72:27Vance Sikov challenges Jordan Rhodes unfairly and gives away a free kick. Direct free kick taken by Gary Caldwell.
71:39Mirko Ivanovski takes a shot. Save made by Allan McGregor. Inswinging corner taken left-footed by Agim Ibraimi from the right by-line.
The offside flag is raised against Mirko Ivanovski. Andy Webster takes the free kick.
69:24 SubstitutionSubstitution Nikola Gligorov goes off and Velice Sumulikoski comes on.
67:32Charlie Adam crosses the ball, Header from close range by Jordan Rhodes misses to the right of the goal.
67:17Goran Popov gives away a free kick for an unfair challenge on Charlie Adam. Gary Caldwell restarts play with the free kick.
65:59The ball is crossed by Paul Dixon.
65:17 SubstitutionSubstitution James Morrison goes off and Jordan Rhodes comes on.
62:13A cross is delivered by Mirko Ivanovski, clearance by Christophe Berra.
59:15Unfair challenge on Goran Pandev by Charlie Adam results in a free kick. Agim Ibraimi takes the free kick.
59:15 BookingBooking Charlie Adam receives a yellow card for unsporting behaviour.
58:44Effort on goal by Goran Pandev from just outside the area goes harmlessly over the target.
57:26Direct free kick taken by Allan McGregor.
57:26 SubstitutionSubstitution Kenny Miller goes off and Charlie Adam comes on.
57:26The offside flag is raised against Ferhan Hasani.
57:07Ferhan Hasani takes a shot.
56:20Corner taken by Agim Ibraimi, Paul Dixon manages to make a clearance.
53:29Paul Dixon gives away a free kick for an unfair challenge on Agim Ibraimi. Agim Ibraimi restarts play with the free kick.
52:28Inswinging corner taken from the left by-line by Shaun Maloney, Nikolce Noveski manages to make a clearance.
51:31The free kick is swung in right-footed by Shaun Maloney, Nikolce Noveski makes a clearance.
51:31 BookingBooking Booking for Goran Pandev for dissent.
51:17 BookingBooking Booking for Nikola Gligorov.
51:02Nikola Gligorov is penalised for a handball.
49:07A cross is delivered by Jamie Mackie, clearance by Ferhan Hasani.
48:19Agim Ibraimi takes a shot. Save made by Allan McGregor.
47:25Paul Dixon takes a shot. Martin Bogatinov makes a comfortable save.
45:59James Forrest sends in a cross, Martin Bogatinov manages to make a clearance.
45:01The second half begins.
45:00 +2:58 Half timeHalf Time The referee blows for half time.
45:00 +2:46Goran Pandev sends in a cross, clearance by Andy Webster.
45:00 +1:56The ball is swung over by Jamie Mackie, save by Martin Bogatinov.
45:00 +0:24The ball is sent over by Alan Hutton, Goran Popov makes a clearance.
44:11Kenny Miller crosses the ball.
42:40Assist on the goal came from Jamie Mackie.
42:40 Goal scoredGoal - Kenny Miller - Scotland 1 - 1 Macedonia Goal scored by Kenny Miller from close range to the bottom left corner of the goal. Scotland 1-1 FYR Macedonia.
41:49A cross is delivered by James Morrison.
40:02Free kick crossed left-footed by Paul Dixon from right wing.
40:02 BookingBooking The referee shows Ferhan Hasani a yellow card.
39:50Ferhan Hasani gives away a free kick for an unfair challenge on Alan Hutton.
38:31Goran Pandev fouled by Gary Caldwell, the ref awards a free kick. Free kick taken by Vance Sikov.
34:46Christophe Berra takes the free kick.
34:46 SubstitutionSubstitution Ivan Trickovski goes off and Ferhan Hasani comes on.
34:46The assistant referee signals for offside against Mirko Ivanovski.
33:23The official flags Kenny Miller offside. Martin Bogatinov restarts play with the free kick.
31:58Muhamed Demiri concedes a free kick for a foul on Shaun Maloney. The free kick is swung in right-footed by Shaun Maloney, Martin Bogatinov makes a save.
31:32Nikolce Noveski gives away a free kick for an unfair challenge on Kenny Miller. Gary Caldwell restarts play with the free kick.
30:28Corner taken right-footed by Shaun Maloney from the left by-line, Headed effort from inside the area by Andy Webster misses to the right of the target.
29:42Agim Ibraimi takes a shot. Save by Allan McGregor.
28:47Mirko Ivanovski gives away a free kick for an unfair challenge on Alan Hutton. Alan Hutton takes the direct free kick.
21:46 BookingBooking The referee cautions Agim Ibraimi for unsporting behaviour.
20:14Inswinging corner taken left-footed by Muhamed Demiri played to the near post.
19:15Paul Dixon gives away a free kick for an unfair challenge on Agim Ibraimi. Free kick crossed left-footed by Agim Ibraimi from right wing, Paul Dixon makes a clearance.
18:47Kenny Miller gives away a free kick for an unfair challenge on Vance Sikov. Free kick taken by Vance Sikov.
18:15Effort from the edge of the area by Agim Ibraimi goes wide of the left-hand post.
16:24Effort from outside the penalty area by Agim Ibraimi goes wide left of the target.
13:36Foul by Jamie Mackie on Daniel Georgievski, free kick awarded. Direct free kick taken by Daniel Georgievski.
12:06Vance Sikov concedes a free kick for a foul on Kenny Miller. Shaun Maloney restarts play with the free kick.
10:08Assist on the goal came from Ivan Trickovski.
10:08 Goal scoredGoal - Nikolce Noveski - Scotland 0 - 1 Macedonia A goal is scored by Nikolce Noveski from inside the six-yard box to the bottom left corner of the goal. Scotland 0-1 FYR Macedonia.
9:42Corner crossed in by Ivan Trickovski,
6:19Corner taken by Ivan Trickovski.
6:05Ivan Trickovski takes a shot. Alan Hutton gets a block in.
4:48Shot by Gary Caldwell from just outside the area goes over the net.
3:58Unfair challenge on Kenny Miller by Vance Sikov results in a free kick. Gary Caldwell takes the direct free kick.
3:11The offside flag is raised against Mirko Ivanovski. Free kick taken by Allan McGregor.
2:24Gary Caldwell gives away a free kick for an unfair challenge on Goran Pandev. Direct free kick taken by Daniel Georgievski.
0:38Unfair challenge on Andy Webster by Mirko Ivanovski results in a free kick. Direct free kick taken by Allan McGregor.
0:00The referee gets the game started.
Live text and data provided by The Press Association
Comments
Jump to comments paginationAll posts are reactively-moderated and must obey the house rules.
More from Football
Elsewhere on the BBC
-
Watch video Super-charged sport
BBC Travel has a go at an unusual activity which once held the world record for fastest ball speed
-
~RS~q~RS~v=~RS~z~RS~59~RS~)

Comment number 198.
Labis13th September 2012 - 20:19
You lack historic knowledge.
The correct name for this country is "Former Yugoslavic Republic Of Macedonia".
Macedonia is a Greek province.
This country has never been officially recognised as "Macedonia".
Link to this (Comment number 198)
Comment number 197.
OwenHM13th September 2012 - 17:53
http://riffingaboutfootball.wordpress.com/2012/09/13/craig-levein-must-acknowledge-scotlands-sour-start-to-survive/
Interesting article on Levein's approach to the Scottish situation. Well worth a read.
Link to this (Comment number 197)
Comment number 196.
David Ware13th September 2012 - 17:21
Scotland should have easily won this game, against a team ranked 97th best in the world, they should have scored two or three goals against them. I do accept the fact that the goal was at least a yard offside, but Scotland still have to score a couple of goals a game if they are to progress out of this group, which is probably the toughest. I won't be surprised if Rhodes starts the next game
Link to this (Comment number 196)
Comment number 195.
ricky12th September 2012 - 17:21
Levein take note. you spoke highly about the young kid who came on last saturday with 10 mins to go. a future class striker for us he said. but i thinks he's not got the experience yet.!! What a comment from someone like levein..[he's banging goals for his club.] Give the kid a place up front next match Craig.How did you become an iternational manager with your experience.!!
Link to this (Comment number 195)
Comment number 194.
Disaster for Scotland12th September 2012 - 17:12
"Since Scotland seems to be reasonably successful at U-21 level"
Unfortunately, they would be no match for a senior side. My theory is that raw talent will get you so far, but after this, you need to be coached properly. I believe that 21 is the ceiling for raw talent, and that's why we fail to transfer our results from under-21's to the full side - the players don't develop any further.
Link to this (Comment number 194)
Comments 5 of 198