Everton v Manchester United as it happened

Manchester United fall to a 1-0 defeat at Everton with Marouane Fellaini scoring a second-half winner.

20 August 2012 Last updated at 21:35 GMT

Get involved

To get involved contact us in any of the following ways

As it happened

In Summary

  • Result: Everton 1-0 Manchester United
  • Fellaini powers in header on 57 minutes
  • Van Persie makes United debut
Reporting by
  • Tom Rostance, BBC Sport
  1. 2227: 

    Well that's all from us for one night - join us back here on Wednesday night as Chelsea take on Reading. I'll see you there.

  2. 2224: 

    Everton manager David Moyes, speaking to BBC Radio 5 live: "I thought that we played ever so well. We had to dig deep at times, but you saw the pressure we had and the saves David de Gea had to make.

    "Marouane Fellaini is good wherever he plays. I think Manchester United not having all their centre-halves available made it a different game. But he scored from a set play, and you will see a lot of that in the Premier League this season."

  3.  
    Pat Nevin, BBC Radio 5 live

    "Everyone thinks Robin van Persie is an out-and-out centre forward, because he had that great season for Arsenal, but I'm not sure that's his best position.

    "I think he's better as a number 10, off a main striker, and I think that's where he was trying to play when he came on."

  4. 2221: 

    Next up for Everton is a trip to Aston Villa at the weekend. On tonight's evidence they will be a real test for Paul Lambert's side.

  5. 2221: 

    Manchester United have a home game coming up next - against Fulham on Saturday - which could be the perfect time to give Robin van Persie a starting role and get their season up and running.

    Fulham did win 5-0 at the weekend of course, but traditionally they have struggled at Old Trafford.

  6.  
    Pat Nevin, BBC Radio 5 live

    "I think one of the problems David Moyes has had in the past is that he's had players prepared to work in every area of the pitch - except at centre-forward.

    "He's got that sorted out now. You look at Fellaini, at Jelavic - and I think Mirallas is going to be the same - and they've got the workrate there now too."

  7. 2215: 

    David de Gea had a cracking first half in particular. His save to deny Leon Osman was out of the top drawer.

    Let's not forget though that Manchester United have the following players to come into that starting XI:

    Rafael, Phil Jones, Rio Ferdinand, Jonny Evans, Anderson, Dimitar Berbatov, Ryan Giggs, Chris Smalling, Javier Hernandez, Ashley Young, Robin van Persie, Darren Fletcher, Nick Powell and Federico Macheda.

    I don't think they are finished just yet...

  8.  
    GET INVOLVED

    Andrew McCoy on Twitter: "The only United players that can walk off that pitch with their heads held high are Kagawa and De Gea."

  9.  

    Everton defender Phil Jagielka: "We knew it was going to be hard, against a great team such as Manchester United. But the big man put his head in where it hurts and we got the reward.

    "Fellaini is nigh on impossible to mark. In training, we normally pull his hair, but you can't do that in a game!

    "Everyone's a bit tired, but it's nice to send Everton fans home with a win to start the season. It's better than we normally do!"

  10. 2210: 

    The word being banded about to describe Maroune Fellaini's performance tonight is 'unplayable.'

    David Moyes will hope he doesn't get too many offers for the big Belgian before the end of the transfer window.

  11.  

    Everton striker Marouane Fellaini: "It's a great start to the season for us. We started well and we kept going. It was a good performance from us.

    "For the goal, it was a good corner and I just tried to get my head on it. We had a lot of chances in the first half, and I felt that if we kept going, there was a chance we would score."

  12. 2206: 

    The bad news for Manchester United fans is that only twice in Premier League history has any club lost their opening match of the season and gone on to become champions.

    The good news is that both times it was Manchester United - in 1992-93 and 1995-96.

  13. 2202: 

    David Moyes said before kick-off that with all the talk of Robin van Persie people had forgotten about Everton - they certainly haven't after that win.

  14.  
    GET INVOLVED

    From Conor, via text on 81111: "Fergie got it wrong, starting Valencia at right-back was a waste of talent.

    "But hats off to Fellaini, the man was unbeatable in the air and our faux-Barca tactics didn't work. Fergie has to learn that this club does not suit 4-2-3-1. Bring back 4-4-2."

    From Sanja in Herts, via text on 81111: "Fellaini was utterly fantastic. He made the Man Utd defence look like amateurs. Don't think Man Utd have shown title potential tonight."

  15. 2200: 

    Pat Nevin has gone big there - I'm not even sure who the top four will be this season but I'd guess that Spurs and Livepool to name but two will be in the mix.

    Everton were very impressive though.

  16.  
    Pat Nevin, BBC Radio 5 live

    "I think this is the season when if anyone's going to get close to the top four, it's Everton."

  17.  
    Phil McNulty, BBC Sport Chief Football Writer at Goodison Park

    "Everton had Goodison Park rocking at the final whistle and with every justification. David Moyes' side - with Marouane Fellaini close to unplayable - were outstanding. Manchester United were outplayed and even the belated introduction of Robin van Persie made no difference."

  18.  
    Pat Nevin, BBC Radio 5 live

    "Manchester United were the better side in the second half by a long way. But Everton for their first-half display, and for the way they defended in the second half, just about deserved it.

    "Does this mean Everton can start the season the way they normally finish?"

  19.  
    GET INVOLVED

    Henry Winterton on Twitter: "People talk about the power shift in Manchester... What about the power shift in Liverpool?"

  20.  
    GET INVOLVED

    From Chadders in Gloucestershire, via text on 81111: "What a great result for Everton, City and Chelsea fans! And I'm sure Arsenal fans feel an emotion not far from smugness too."

  21. 2156: 

    The only slightly bad news for Everton fans is the sight of Sylvain Distin having to be helped off the field at the end. He made two massive headers in the dying seconds and has obviously done himself some damage in the process. Let's hope that's not too bad an injury.

  22. 2154: 

    Everton chairman Bill Kenwright is absolutely beaming in the directors box. He's seen some opening nights in his time but this must be the best.

    What now for Manchester United? Sir Alex Ferguson will be a concerned man after that. They had so many attacking players on the pitch by the end but barely created a chance.

  23.  
    GET INVOLVED

    From Stobbsy, via text on 81111: "You can have all the stars in the world but nothing beats sheer grit and determination from 11 players. Hats off to Everton."

  24.  
    Pat Nevin, BBC Radio 5 live

    "The effort has been absolutely incredible from Everton."

  25.  
    John Murray, BBC commentator

    "Some of the Everton players drop to the ground in exhaustion. And well they might."

  26. 2152: 

    What a win for Everton, a gutsy, gutsy display to hang on after they took a deserved lead.

  27. 2152: 
    FULL-TIME- Everton 1-0 Manchester United
  28. 2151: 

    It's a good corner as well, but Sylvain Distin makes a brilliant clearing header. Into the final seconds now...

  29. 2150: 

    Phil Jagielka hammers a ball out of play. Anywhere will do now, before Tony Hibbert has to knock it behind for a corner...

  30.  
    Pat Nevin, BBC Radio 5 live

    "It's going to feel like a long four minutes for everyone involved with Everton, but particularly the players. They are exhausted."

  31.  
    John Murray, BBC commentator

    "I think Fellaini might need a sedan chair to get off the field, he's so tired. But he might just have scored the winning goal."

  32. 2150: 
    SUBSTITUTION- John Heitinga on for Marouane Fellaini

    What a performance from Marouane Fellaini. He's battered this Manchester United defence all night.

  33. 2148: 

    It's a debut for Steven Naismith, who gets a warm reception.

    At the other end, Anderson fires a shot wide as we tick over into four minutes of stoppage-time...

  34.  
    Pat Nevin, BBC Radio 5 live

    "I'm a great admirer of Steven Naismith. He may not look the tallest, but don't let him get a free header."

  35. 2148: 
    SUBSTITUTION- Steven Naismith on for Nikica Jelavic
  36. 2147: 

    After endless passes across the area, Anderson gives the ball away for Manchester United, Seamus Coleman is able to bring the ball away and does a fine job for his side.

    He carries it 60 yards up the pitch and then wins a free-kick into the bargain. The crowd cheer that like a goal.

  37.  
    GET INVOLVED

    From Jamie in Leigh-on-Sea, via text on 81111: "Man Utd have missed a trick. Alex Song is like Robin to RVP's Batman. £40m for both would have been a bargain and would guarantee many goals!"

  38. 2145: 

    Nikica Jelavic has to have some treatment for what looks like cramp, that will bring up a bit more stoppage time. There are three minuts of normal time remaining as Ashley Young puts an aimless cross straight at Tim Howard.

  39. 2143: 
    SUBSTITUTION- Anderson on for Tom Cleverley
  40. 2143: 

    More fine defending from Phil Jagielka cuts out a pass intended for Wayne Rooney. It's all hands to the pump now for the hosts.

  41.  
    Pat Nevin, BBC Radio 5 live

    "Everton are getting closer to victory, but they've got the same problem - they're not getting out. We're sitting on the halfway line and we've hardly turned to our left - the end Everton are attacking - in the last 15 or 20 minutes.

    "We've seen a lot of brilliant defending tonight, from Distin particularly in the first half and Jagielka in the second, but Hibbert has done really well too."

  42. 2141: 

    Everton lack an out ball here. They could do with a Louis Saha or Royston Drenthe to hit over the top, Nikica Jelavic looks spent and every time they get it away the ball keeps coming back at them.

  43.  
    GET INVOLVED

    Ian Mitchell on Twitter: "Cannot understand all the love that Kagawa is getting."

  44. 2141: 

    Tony Hibbert had a testimonial a few weeks ago and he gives his faithful something to cheer about with two crunching tackles on Patrice Evra. Seven minutes left...

  45.  
    Pat Nevin, BBC Radio 5 live

    "Osman's worked really hard. He was unfortunate not to score when he hit the bar but he is exhausted. Coleman will get forward but he can also get back and provide cover."

  46. 2138: 
    SUBSTITUTION- Seamus Coleman on for Leon Osman

    David Moyes injects some pace into the side as Seamus Coleman comes on down the right in place of Leon Osman - who was very unlucky not to score.

  47.  
    GET INVOLVED

    From Geoff in London, via text on 81111: "Is it just me or has Nani not improved his crossing since arriving at United however many years ago? Get some lessons from Valencia!"

  48.  
    GET INVOLVED

    Oliver Cook on Twitter: "Distin and Jagielka have been like a brick wall in defence tonight for Everton."

  49. 2137: 

    I thought that Darron Gibson stat sounded too good to be true. He's been a solid addition since he joined though, no doubts about that.

    Here come United, with Robin van Persie teasing a pass across the goalmouth and Tim Howard smothering Shinji Kagawa at the near post. Dangerous times for the hosts. Can they hang on?

  50.  
    GET INVOLVED

    From Phil in Manchester, via text on 81111: "The earlier stat on Gibson (at 2128) is wrong. He lost the FA Cup semi-final against Liverpool."

  51. 2135: 
    SUBSTITUTION- Ashley Young on for Nani
  52. 2134: 

    Robin van Persie drifts out to the left in search of the bal, but his cross in when it comes is poor and Tim Howard easily holds it. Everton are pretty much sitting back all the time now and trying to soak up the pressure. It's a dangerous game against Manchester United.

  53.  
    GET INVOLVED

    From Mikey in Glasgow, via text on 81111: "The Scots know all about Belgium, they're in our World Cup group. (And yes, they're better than us...)"

  54. 2132: 

    Ashley Young and Anderson are warming up now for Manchester United, who have 16 minutes left to salvage something from this game.

  55.  
    GET INVOLVED

    From AD, via text on 81111: "Re: Belgium. Now list the England squad that didn't qualify for Euro 2008. Maybe Belgium are managed by Shteve Van Claren."

  56. 2129: 

    Manchester United definitely look more dangerous now, their movement in midfield is causing trouble for Everton. Robin van Persie is playing right through the middle.

  57.  
    Pat Nevin, BBC Radio 5 live

    "It's difficult to know if Manchester United are playing much better or if it's a case of Everton sitting much deeper because they're tiring. I'm looking at Pienaar and he's exhausted. I'm looking at Osman and he's tiring."

  58. 2128: 

    Great stat that about Darron Gibson - who claims an assist for the Everton goal by the way. It was his corner which Fellaini headed home.

  59.  
    GET INVOLVED

    Rory McCarthy on Twitter: "Darron Gibson has never lost a game playing for Everton. It is worth nothing that now I've said this, I have jinxed Everton."

  60. 2126: 

    Robin van Persie is straight in the action, taking a corner which is cleared away. Manchester United are turning the screw now in typical style.

  61.  
    Pat Nevin, BBC Radio 5 live

    "It's a good time for Van Persie to come on because the spaces are starting to develop."

  62.  
    GET INVOLVED

    From Steve in Ledbury, via text on 81111: "On this evidence, Andy Carroll will be starting for Liverpool when they play Man Utd."

  63. 2126: 
    SUBSTITUTION- Robin van Persie for Danny Welbeck

    Here he is...

  64. 2126: 

    Here's the first real chance for United. Nani's cross from the right is dangerous, Shinji Kagawa is able to dance away from Tim Howard and tee up Tom Cleverley, but his shot is cleared off the line. Close.

  65. 2122: 

    Bit of an office debate breaking out here - why didn't Belgium qualify for the Euros?

    In Fellaini, Mignolet, Courtois, Van Buyten, Kompany, Vertonghen, Hazard, Lukaku, Vermaelen, Dembele, Witsel and Mirallas they must have enough quality.

    Is this the golden generation of Belgians?

  66.  
    Pat Nevin, BBC Radio 5 live

    "Now we'll see the best of Sir Alex Ferguson. He has to change the personnel and the system, and he's the best at doing that."

  67.  
    GET INVOLVED

    Rhys Jones on Twitter: "Really wish I had thought to put Fellaini in my Fantasy Football team. Absolute class tonight."

    Andrew Morris on Twitter: "Forget getting a new left-back in to cover for Evra, we need a new central defender! Carrick was exposed; that's been true all game long."

  68. 2122: 

    Marouane Fellaini causes chaos again, he wins another header in the box but this time it is straight at David de Gea. Robin van Persie is still trotting up and down on the far touchline...

  69.  
    Phil McNulty, BBC Sport Chief Football Writer at Goodison Park

    "Goodison Park is rocking as Everton really put Manchester United on the rack. The goal was thoroughly deserved and the source was predictable. United have not been able to cope with Marouane Fellaini."

  70. 2118: 

    You can't get any more basic than that from Pat Nevin - but he's right. Manchester United have no answer to the big diagonal ball to Marouane Fellaini. But they do possess plenty of quality players going forwards to cause danger in the Everton backline.

  71.  
    Pat Nevin, BBC Radio 5 live

    "The problem Manchester United have is that Everton are bigger than them. Everton have four players who are fantastic in the air and United haven't got as many."

  72.  
    Pat Nevin, BBC Radio 5 live

    "I do not think there's a player in the Premier League who can get close to Marouane Fellaini in the air when he gets a run on it."

  73.  
    GET INVOLVED

    Hugh Moxon on Twitter: "Don't you mean Fellani is unbeatable in the hair?"

  74. 2117: 

    That goal triggered Robin van Persie to leave the bench for the first time all night, he's warming up now as we speak.

    They need Gary Pallister at the minute though. What a performance this has been from Fellaini.

  75. 2115: 
    GOAL- Everton (Marouane Fellaini, 57 mins) 1-0 Man Utd

    If ever a man deserved a goal... This is as basic as it gets, Everton fire in a corner from the right and Marouane Fellaini towers over his marker to thump a header into the bottom corner. Thoroughly deserved.

  76. 2114: 

    Wayne Rooney fires one way over the top after more neat play from Shinji Kagawa, but Everton still look dangerous as well. Surely we are not going to get a 0-0 here?

  77.  
    Pat Nevin, BBC Radio 5 live

    "You can always see how teams are tiring by where they're closing down. In the first half, Everton were closing down 10 yards inside their own half. Now they're closing down 10 yards outside their own penalty area.

    "They are tiring and so there will be gaps. And Manchester United have the players to find them."

  78. 2113: 

    It must be nearly time for Robin van Persie. My shout of 57 minutes looks off the boil to be honest, I've not seen the Dutchman warming up yet.

  79.  
    GET INVOLVED

    David on Twitter: "Everton should be winning. What's the odds on RVP making a dramatic debut for United now?"

  80. 2109: 

    Danger from United now though as Shinji Kagawa feeds Wayne Rooney with a neat pass, the England man looks to play in Tom Cleverley breaking into the area but Tony Hibbert times his challenge perfectly to get it away.

  81.  
    Pat Nevin, BBC Radio 5 live

    "Osman caught it absolutely perfectly. The work by Fellaini made it happen. And well as De Gea has been playing, he couldn't get near it."

  82. 2107: 
    HITS THE WOODWORK

    Unlucky. So unlucky for Everton as they hit the woodwork again.

    Once more it's Marouane Fellaini winning a header, he nods it down for Leon Osman who thumps a shot against the crossbar.

    Fellaini is unbeatable in the air.

  83.  
    Pat Nevin, BBC Radio 5 live

    "Wayne Rooney's been a little out of sorts tonight... so far, I might add. But we noticed that with England during the summer, when he didn't really take the Euros by the scruff of the neck."

  84.  
    GET INVOLVED

    Mark Jackson on Twitter: "RE: Bill in Hereford at 2054. It's because of all those top quality players in Hereford - it's hard to get excited about a new Man Utd player."

  85. 2103: 

    No changes for either side at the break by the way. Robin van Perise's wait goes on.

  86. 2103: 
    KICK-OFF- Everton 0-0 Man Utd

    The second half is go...

  87.  
    GET INVOLVED

    M. Dalmar on Twitter: "United being bullied by the big Belgian. Everton need to capitalise on these chances before Fergie sends on the big guns."

  88.  
    GET INVOLVED

    Robin Davies on Twitter: "I can't remember Fellaini losing an aerial challenge he has gone for tonight. Class display by the lad so far."

  89.  
    GET INVOLVED

    From Ed in Bournemouth, via text on 81111: "Re: Sam @2046. On this evidence who are the six better teams than Everton?"

  90.  
    GET INVOLVED

    Aled Jenkins on Twitter: "Fellaini and Pienaar looking strong and causing problems for United but I think there's more to come from the boys in red."

    Gareth Butler on Twitter: "Kagawa has looked classy, but surely Valencia is wasted at right-back?"

    Gareth Soye on Twitter: "Kagawa did exactly what he was bought for; played some fantastic through balls."

  91. 2056: 

    Here are two entirely contradictory statistics for you to mull over a half-time brew:

    Manchester United have won only one of their last 10 Premier League away matches that have been goalless at half time.

    But, United have gone on to win on three of the five occasions in Premier League history they have been drawing 0-0 at half at Goodison Park (losing twice).

    What does that tell us? Nothing probably.

  92.  
    GET INVOLVED

    From Ethan, via text on 81111: "Most likely Everton will continue to dominate into second half and yet still United will probably end up winning the game. Just typical United."

  93. 2054: 

    See?

    It's a tough crowd in Hereford.

  94.  
    GET INVOLVED

    From Bill in Hereford, via text on 81111: "After all the pre-match build up about Kagawa, I forgot he was on the pitch. Invisible so far."

  95. 2053: 

    I thought Shinji Kagawa looked fairly lively when he got on the ball - which wasn't that often.

    The reaction from you lot seems a bit mixed though.

  96.  
    Pat Nevin, BBC Radio 5 live

    "It was a thoroughly enjoyable first half. There's a problem for Manchester United with balls into the box. I've a feeling Everton might bring on Steven Naismith to add a bit of creativity down the flanks, and United could be undone there.

    "But United have Robin van Persie to come on. And as Everton tire, we might see spaces open up - and see a bit more of Shinji Kagawa."

  97. 2049: 

    What time is RVP time then?

    I'm going to say 57 minutes in...

  98.  
    GET INVOLVED

    Brendan Bennett on Twitter: "Good solid first half from De Gea. Nothing flash, just a confident solid performance. Proving all the doubters wrong."

  99.  
    GET INVOLVED

    From GB in Northants, via text on 81111: "Have Man United signed the the twin brother of David de Gea? Composed shot stopper."

  100.  
    Phil McNulty, BBC Sport Chief Football Writer at Goodison Park

    "Manchester United keeper David de Gea is distinguishing himself with some fine save to keep his side on terms. Everton shading an entertaining game but United showing a threat as well, with the power of Robin van Persie to add."

  101. 2048: 
    HALF-TIME- Everton 0-0 Man Utd
  102. 2047: 

    Manchester United have been on the rack for 10 minutes here but they almost sneak a goal right at the end of the half as Wayne Rooney gets in on an inviting cross but he mistimes his jump and can't get a proper header away.

  103.  

    From Chris in Southampton, via text on 81111: "If it hadn't been for De Gea, Everton might've already had this game won! Massive improvement from last season."

  104. 2046: 

    Oh and another belter of a save from David de Gea!

    Leighton Baines curls in a free-kick, Stuart Pearce style, it's flying in to the top corner until De Gea gets up to turn it over the top. Inspired.

  105.  
    GET INVOLVED

    From Sam, via text on 81111: "Fellaini is definitely putting himself in the shop window. Could surely do a job for a top six club. Is Mr Wenger watching?"

  106.  
    GET INVOLVED

    Matt Harding on Twitter: "David de Gea looks unbeatable tonight. Good job..."

  107. 2043: 

    David de Gea has had a cracking half here - he's arguably kept his side in it.

  108.  
    Pat Nevin, BBC Radio 5 live

    "How did De Gea get his hand on that? I don't think there's ever been any question about his shot-stopping. That was a very good save. I think Everton are just shading this half."

  109. 2041: 

    What a save!

    Again it's Marouane Fellaini winning a big header at the back stick, Leon Osman swivels and drives in a crunching half-volley which David de Gea turns over the bar. Fine save from the youngster.

  110.  
    GET INVOLVED

    Jacob Lockey on Twitter: "United's new shirt belongs on the top of a table..."

    Bob Moston on Twitter: "Do Everton think it's February? They're not meant to be this good in August!"

  111. 2038: 

    Fantastic play from Manchester United.

    Shinji Kagawa and Wayne Rooney move the ball delightfully across the penalty area and Kagawa then releases Danny Welbeck with a peach of a pass. The England man goes to ground as he gets his shot away, he wants a penalty but I don't think there was much contact from Phil Jagielka.

    Much better from the visitors though.

  112.  
    GET INVOLVED

    Charlie Adams on Twitter: "Everton breaking up our play excellently, like Bilbao did last season, pressing our midfield into mistakes."

  113.  
    GET INVOLVED

    From Matt in York, via text on 81111: "RVP must think he never left Arsenal - loads of cute possession, no cutting edge and very vulnerable at the back!"

  114. 2036: 

    Marouane Fellaini is winning header after header up there for Everton at the minute. For a makeshift centre-forward he's superb.

  115. 2035: 

    Leon Osman and Leighton Baines combine neatly on the left of the area but the cross is hacked away. This is a good spell from Everton.

  116.  
    GET INVOLVED

    From Steve in Bristol, via text on 81111: "Re: Andy in Kirkham: Good at tackling or nay, Scholes is still the best player on the park. Still running the show in his 19th season at the highest level. Not too shabby."

  117. 2033: 

    So close for Everton!

    Brilliant target-man play from Marouane Fellaini as he kills a ball beautifully on his chest and spreads it wide. He can't quite get on the end of the cross but when the ball is recycled out to Steven Pienaar on the edge of the box the South African curls in a shot which is heading for the corner until David de Gea gets the end of a finger on to it and turns it away. Fine save.

  118.  

    Sophie Gayter on Twitter: "How has Osman not had an England call up? One of Everton's most consistent performers. Can score and set up loads of goals."

  119. 2028: 

    Manchester United win a free-kick in a dangerous area - what used to be 'Beckham range' - and Wayne Rooney sees his bending effort tipped away by Tim Howard. The pendulum seems to have swung back toward the visitors at the moment.

  120.  
    Pat Nevin, BBC Radio 5 live

    "I think United's shirts are quite classy."

  121.  
    GET INVOLVED

    Adam Kirkham on Twitter: "How long has Scholes been playing football now? By now someone should've sat him down and said: 'Paul, this is how you tackle.'"

  122.  
    Pat Nevin, BBC Radio 5 live

    "There have been a couple of moments where United have got the ball down and played it. And if you're going to get the better of Everton, you've got to take the sting out of them.

    "Man United can do that - tire out the Dogs of War, if you like, and then the spaces will open up."

  123. 2024: 

    Another Everton corner creates some danger, and David de Gea has to back-track quickly to tip over a Steven Pienaar header. Marouane Fellaini then thrashes one over the bar when Pienaar was well placed in space.

    A goal is coming here...

  124. 2024: 

    Paul Scholes tracks back diligently to win the ball back for United on the edge of their own area and launch a swift counter-attack, which ends with Nani curling wide from 25 yards.

    Everton then break nicely to play in Nikica Jelavic but the angle is too acute on the left of the area and David de Gea is able to save.

  125.  
    Phil McNulty, BBC Sport Chief Football Writer at Goodison Park

    "The physical presence of Everton's Marouane Fellaini - not for the first time - is unsettling Manchester United but there have also been some neat periods of possessions for Sir Alex Ferguson's side with Paul Scholes and Tom Cleverley seeing plenty of the ball."

  126.  
    GET INVOLVED

    Luke Minors on Twitter: "Don't think Rooney has played particularly well for several months now. He seems to lose the ball almost every time he has it."

  127.  
    GET INVOLVED

    From Simon in Molesley, via text on 81111: "The Man Utd kit harks of a Gingham table-cloth... Pants."

  128. 2021: 

    Manchester United stream forward and Danny Welbeck latches on to a Patrice Evra cross, but he can't quite force his shot across goal. Good defending from Everton as we reach the halfway mark of the first half.

  129.  
    Pat Nevin, BBC Radio 5 live

    "Fellaini went right in on the keeper. I told you he was a big old unit and he went right into David de Gea. People might remember Dixie Dean - it was a bit like that."

  130. 2017: 

    It's direct again from Everton - and it's dangerous again.

    Leighton Baines puts in a fine free-kick which David de Gea does really well to come and meet with a punch. He was under all sorts of pressure there and the young Spaniard dealt with that really well.

  131.  
    Pat Nevin, BBC Radio 5 live

    "A few gaps have started to open up in the Manchester United defence. There aren't many gaps in that Everton midfield. David Moyes will be very happy with the way it's going."

  132. 2016: 

    Michael Carrick didn't enjoy being thrown to one side there by Maroune Fellaini but he may have to get used to it.

    It's a pity Duncan Ferguson isn't available...

  133.  
    Pat Nevin, BBC Radio 5 live

    "Fantastic power from Fellaini. He's a huge man. He's got good skills too. He's one of those players I think is going to get better and better the older he gets."

  134. 2015: 
    HITS THE WOODWORK

    Not much finesse about this - but it's mightily effective for Everton.

    Marouane Fellaini chests down a throw-in, bundles over Antonio Valencia and outmuscles Michael Carrick before sprinting into the area and hitting the near post from a tight angle. Magnificent play from Fellaini.

  135. 2012: 
    YELLOW CARD- Paul Scholes

    Paul Scholes has started to stamp his authority on this game, he is dictating the play from midfield in classic style.

    But this is also classic Scholes - a lunge into a sliding challenge nowhere near the ball. Booked.

  136. 2008: 

    Manchester United are looking pretty flexible up top.

    Danny Welbeck is the out-and-out focal point, with Nani on the right and Wayne Rooney and Shinji Kagawa flitting about behind. Kagawa has been very mobile so far, and his first venture into enemy territory sees a cross which just evades Welbeck.

    United starting to take control.

  137.  
    GET INVOLVED

    From Rob in Northwich, via text on 81111: "Agreed, that new United shirt belongs in the early 90s!"

  138. 2005: 

    Bright start from Everton as they force a corner now. Leighton Baines delivers, and Marouane Fellaini almost gets a head on it at the near post. The Merseysiders quite rightly sniff a weakness in the air for United.

    Hit the big man.

  139.  
    Pat Nevin, BBC Radio 5 live pundit

    "Manchester United do not want to be outfought in this game so there are a few challenges going in early on."

  140. 2003: 
    YELLOW CARD- Nani

    Nani is furious when he isn't awarded a corner and seconds later the Manchester United winger scythes through Leighton Baines to earn a very early caution.

  141.  
    GET INVOLVED

    From Dave in Edinburgh. via text on 81111: "All this talk of pressure on RVP, there is more pressure on Jelavic as he's in pretty much everyone's fantasy team, but Moyes has still backed him to perform!"

  142. 2001: 

    Everton win a free-kick in the opening seconds and put it in the mixer to test this makeshift Manchester United defence. Leighton Baines whips it in and Leon Osman is the unlikely man who wins the header - he meets it well but it is a long way wide.

  143.  
    GET INVOLVED

    Ali Kaffaf on Twitter: "Jelavic is going to give Carrick a hard time and Pienaar is going to do the same to Valencia."

  144. 2000: 
    KICK-OFF- Everton v Man Utd

    We are away...

  145.  
    GET INVOLVED

    Keegan Fernandes on Twitter: "United lost the title last season due to a shaky backline. Looking the same right now..."

  146. 1956: 

    I'm going to put this out there - I'm not a fan of this new Manchester United kit.

    Anyway, the tea-towelled boys are coming down the tunnel now alongside their hosts from Everton. Z Cars is on the tannoy - kick-off is imminent...

  147.  
    Pat Nevin, BBC Radio 5 live pundit

    "It's a big problem for Manchester United whenever they come here. They don't get any space in midfield because Everton will chase them down for everything, so it's going to be a tough evening for them.

    "I'm looking forward to seeing Nikica Jelavic. I think there's more to come from him. Everybody's talking about Manchester United, but don't write off Everton."

  148. 1954: 

    Manchester United manager Sir Alex Ferguson: "The defensive situation has been a problem for us in pre-season.

    "It's a concern, but there's nothing else we can do. Michael Carrick has played centre-back a few times, so I don't have any great issues about that."

  149. 1953: 

    Just under 10 minutes to go until kick-off then, and Everton new boy Kevin Mirallas is introduced to the Goodison faithful.

    He will wear the 11 shirt and could prove a canny addition. He was signed too late to feature this evening but he's fit and available to join in soon.

  150. 1948: 

    Manchester United manager Sir Alex Ferguson: "Robin's not played any football. There's a lot of expectation on him, and I think it's better he starts on the bench.

    "He's a great player, and there was always a temptation to start him. But the sensible route tonight is to start him on the bench."

  151. 1945: 

    Sir Alex Ferguson has just said that he has left Javier Hernandez out as he had to get some defensive cover on the bench. He's got too many strikers hasn't he? We've all been there on Football Manager...

  152.  
    GET INVOLVED

    Adam J on Twitter: "Can't see Ashley Young making too many starts this season, unless United have a few injuries."

  153.  
    GET INVOLVED

    Paul Cumming on Twitter: "People talk about Man Utd's attacking prowess down the right, but that could create loads of space for Pienaar down the left."

  154. 1943: 

    A good point that about Javier Hernandez. I was just thinking how strong Manchester United's bench looked and there are still the likes of the Mexican and Ryan Giggs to come in - plus Chris Smalling and Phil Jones. Darren Fletcher, Jonny Evans, Nick Powell...

  155.  
    GET INVOLVED

    From Waleed, via text on 81111: "'No Chicharito? Does this mean the rumours of him going are true?"

  156.  
    GET INVOLVED

    Tony Brown on Twitter: "David Moyes has had one of his best transfer windows. Can see Everton causing problems for United tonight. Prediction: 1-1."

  157.  
    GET INVOLVED

    From Mike Harding, via text on 81111: "Surely we are in for a feast of attacking football tonight. With the side they have, United will have to go forward. Everton will see the United defensive selection as a weakness and must also attack."

    From Max in London, via text on 81111: "Berbatov has made the bench for United as he is the cover for centre-back!"

  158. 1939: 

    There was a glint in David Moyes's eyes when he said that people may have forgotten about Everton here.

    I can guarantee that his players will go out on that pitch cranked up. This could be high-octane stuff.

  159. 1938: 

    Everton manager David Moyes: "Monday night games are all well and good but as as a manager it's a long weekend. We have added one or two to the squad, we are happy with that. People are talking about Van Persie and I think they've forgotten that Everton are involved in this game."

  160.  
    GET INVOLVED

    James Driscoll on Twitter: "Shame that Nick Powell isn't even on the bench for Man United this evening."

  161.  
    GET INVOLVED

    From Ashley in Minehead, via text on 81111: "Looks like attack could be the best form of defence for United tonight - score more than they concede!"

  162. 1934: 

    Paul Scholes starts for Manchester United tonight - he made his debut on 21 September 1994 and I make this the start of his 18th Premier League season.

    He's won it 10 times, and he's not even the most successful midfielder at the club. Extraordinary.

    Ryan Giggs is not involved this evening by the way.

  163.  
    GET INVOLVED

    Adam James Turner on Twitter: "Everton 1-0 United tonight. Pienaar in the last 10. RVP to come on and do nothing."

    Matt Holford on Twitter: "This game could be high scoring with United edging it 3-2."

  164.  
    GET INVOLVED

    Jonny Riley on Twitter: "With only two recognised defenders at the back, United need to go for the jugular. "You score three, we'll score five" style.

  165. 1927: 

    So Dimitar Berbatov does get a place in the matchday squad for Manchester United - and he's joined on the bench by Scott Wootton, a 20-year-old centre-half who spent some time on loan with Nottingham Forest last season.

  166.  
    GET INVOLVED

    Kieran Costello on Twitter: "If Barca lined up like United, we would be raving about them only playing with two defenders and six midfielders - but here it's a crisis!"

  167. 1926: 
    LINE-UPS- Everton v Man Utd (20:00 BST)

    Everton: Howard, Hibbert, Jagielka, Distin, Baines, Osman, Gibson, Neville, Pienaar, Fellaini, Jelavic. Subs: Mucha, Heitinga, Naismith, Gueye, Barkley, Coleman, Anichebe.

    Man Utd: De Gea, Valencia, Carrick, Vidic, Evra, Nani, Cleverley, Scholes, Kagawa, Rooney, Welbeck. Subs: Lindegaard, Da Silva, Anderson, Berbatov, Young, van Persie, Wootton.

    Referee: Andre Marriner (W Midlands)

  168.  
    GET INVOLVED

    Dan from Sutton, via text on 81111: "Valencia and Carrick in defence is not a concern. They have played there last season and performed well. Valencia and Kagawa running down the wing sets alarm bells ringing for all Everton fans!"

  169. 1925: 

    I'm looking forward to having a first good look at Shinji Kagawa tonight. Again - quite where all these attacking players are going to fit in is somewhat of a mystery to me but we shall find out very shortly.

  170.  
    John Murray, BBC commentator

    "Shinji Kagawa has been a title winner in Germany for the last two seasons. He's a creative spirit, and it's been said that's what Manchester United need. Will he be up to it? We will find out."

  171.  
    GET INVOLVED

    Alex Butler on Twitter: "Fergie has done the right thing with RVP. He needs to earn his place on that team sheet."

  172.  
    GET INVOLVED

    Pete Sharland on Twitter: "Valencia at right-back will give United a lot going forward down that right side. Baines could have his work cut out tonight."

  173. 1921: 

    Robin van Persie is out on the pitch warming up with his new Manchester United team-mates - it all looks a bit odd seeing him in that tracksuit doesn't it?

    What a signing for United he could be though.

  174.  
    GET INVOLVED

    From Josh, via text on 81111: "The lack of regular defenders for United is more worrying for me. Fergie should have more defensive concerns than where Van Persie will fit in."

  175. 1917:  
    Phil McNulty, BBC Sport Chief Football Writer at Goodison ParkEverton v Man Utd (20:00 BST)

    "Manchester United's £24m new boy Robin van Persie starts on the bench after his move from Arsenal as Sir Alex Ferguson pairs Wayne Rooney and Danny Welbeck in attack. Not many natural defenders in United's line-up but at least captain Nemanja Vidic returns in central defence.

    "Everton manager David Moyes plays one summer signing Steven Pienaar but another, Steven Naismaith, is one of the substitutes."

  176. 1916: 

    No arguments on that score James.

    Nemanja Vidic is a class act, but he could be busy tonight as he is partnered at centre-half by Michael Carrick, with Antonio Valencia at right-back.

  177.  
    GET INVOLVED

    From James Eastleigh, via text on 81111: "Although United have made big and exciting signings this summer, the return of Vidic should not be overlooked - as when fully fit, he has to be one of the best centre-backs in the world."

  178. 1915: 

    Of course it's not all about Manchester United this evening.

    Everton fans will be hoping that their boys can get off to a flying start, but after losing Tim Cahill and Jack Rodwell over the summer David Moyes's side could be a bit light in midfield.

    There have been signings though - Steven Naismith is on the bench after leaving the artists formally known as Rangers, while new Belgian striker Kevin Mirallas is not available to play tonight.

  179.  
    John Murray, BBC Radio 5 live commentator at Goodison Park

    "In the last six seasons, Everton have finished in the top eight. The key for them is to get a decent start to the season. If they can do that, you could say they would be pushing upwards of that."

  180. 1910: 

    So Robin van Persie is left on the bench tonight - which is not a total surprise - but just who will play up front for United this year then?

    Wayne Rooney is a given, surely, just behind Van Persie?

    But what about Danny Welbeck and Javier Hernandez? Dimitar Berbatov is still there - just about.

    And then there are the likes of Ashley Young, Nani, Antonio Valencia, Ryan Giggs and fellow new boy Shinji Kagawa to accommodate.

    Maybe Rooney will play at centre-half...

  181.  
    Phil McNulty, BBC Sport Chief Football Writer at Goodison Park

    "Manchester United start the task of taking the Premier League title back from Manchester City with a testing fixture at Everton.

    "Robin van Persie and Shinji Kagawa will add their talents to Sir Alex Ferguson's squad but Everton manager David Moyes has added attacking quality of his own in the shape of Steven Naismith and the returning Steven Pienaar. Latest signing Kevin Mirallas did not sign in time to play - but Moyes will want Everton to show they are not going to suffer from a familiar slow start this season."

  182. 1907: 
    GET INVOLVED

    So what have you made of the start of the Premier League season so far? We had plenty of goals over the weekend and I fancy a few more this evening.

    How do we see United lining up this season? Should RVP have started? Can Everton spoil Wayne Rooney's return? How much longer can Giggs and Scholes go on? So many questions - so send me your answers.

    As ever you can text in to 81111 (UK only) and have your say on Twitter using the hashtag #bbcfootball. Grand.

  183. 1906: 
    BREAKING TEAM NEWS- Everton v Man Utd (20:00 BST)

    Robin van Persie starts on the bench for Manchester United, who have captain Nemanja Vidic back in defence after his lengthy absence with a knee injury.

  184. 1903: 

    Manchester United scored 89 league goals last season. A lot in anyone's book, but it wasn't enough as Manchester City took the glory thanks to their haul of 93 - and a better defensive record.

    So Sir Alex Ferguson added Robin van Persie to the mix, and must now find a way to shoehorn the Dutchman who scored 30 goals in the top flight last season into his XI.

  185. 1900: 

    Cast your minds back 99 days.

    A time before the Olympics wowed us all into a giddy state of hysteria, a time before the Euros even. It really was just 99 days ago that Manchester United lost the Premier League title to rivals City thanks to that famous late, late goal from Sergio Aguero.

    You can only begin to imagine what went through Sir Alex Ferguson's mind on that evening of 13 May when he digested losing the title on goal difference - but we have seen how determined he is to make sure it doesn't happen again.

    He went out and signed last year's top scorer Robin van Persie - and tonight we will see just how he fits in to the United side at Everton...

Share this story

Related to this story

A goal goes in at our new Live Scores page Live Live Scores

All the latest goals from across the UK & European leagues

Latest Football

  • Venezuela v El Salvador 00:30

View Live Scores All times UK

Fri 24 May 2013 - International Friendlies
  • Qatar v Latvia
Wed 29 May 2013 - International Friendlies
  • Canada v Costa Rica 01:00
  • Ecuador v Germany 19:30
  • England v R. of Ireland 20:00
  • Qatar v Azerbaijan
Thu 30 May 2013 - International Friendlies
  • USA v Belgium 01:00
  • Japan v Bulgaria 11:20
Fri 31 May 2013 - International Friendlies
  • Italy v San Marino 19:45
Sat 1 Jun 2013 - International Friendlies
  • Mexico v Nigeria 02:00
  • Panama v Peru 21:30
Sun 2 Jun 2013 - International Friendlies
  • Brazil v England 00:00
  • R. of Ireland v Georgia 17:30

View all fixtures All times UK

As It Stands Table

Barclays Premier League summary table; it charts each team by position, team name, games played, total goal difference and points
Position Team Played Goal Difference Points

View full table
No movement 1 Man Utd 38 43 89
No movement 2 Man City 38 32 78
No movement 3 Chelsea 38 36 75
No movement 4 Arsenal 38 35 73
No movement 5 Tottenham 38 20 72
No movement 6 Everton 38 15 63
No movement 7 Liverpool 38 28 61
No movement 8 West Brom 38 -4 49
No movement 9 Swansea 38 -4 46
No movement 10 West Ham 38 -8 46
No movement 11 Norwich 38 -17 44
No movement 12 Fulham 38 -10 43
No movement 13 Stoke 38 -11 42
No movement 14 Southampton 38 -11 41
No movement 15 Aston Villa 38 -22 41
No movement 16 Newcastle 38 -23 41
No movement 17 Sunderland 38 -13 39
No movement 18 Wigan 38 -26 36
No movement 19 Reading 38 -30 28
No movement 20 QPR 38 -30 25