India v England, third Test, day three as it happened
Alastair Cook is run out for 190 but England extend their lead over India to 193 at stumps on day three of the third Test.
Get involved
To get involved contact us in any of the following ways
- Twitter:Tweet us #bbccricket
As it happened
-
1052:
Ben I think you've nailed it. England are right on top here and barring a disaster of Abu Dhabi proportions there is very little chance of them losing this game. But can they win it and take a 2-1 lead in the series? Join us tomorrow morning at 0330 GMT for chapter four. Goodbye.
-
Ben in Chertsey via text: "I don't know about you lot but I would've snapped your hand off if you'd have offered me a practically 200 run lead with 4 wickets remaining on day three after we lost the toss. Great effort lads!"
-
Geoffrey Boycott, BBC Test Match Special"It was a good days cricket with a nice crowd. England haven't got quite as many runs as I would have liked but if the lead is 200-odd it may tempt India to go for it a bit more. If they are positive, it opens up a channel for England because they may give us a bit more chance of getting them out. There are plenty of runs around but if the odd ball turns you can take wickets. If England bowl like they did in the first innings, they have a very good chance of winning."
-
1045:
Strange goings on out in the middle as the Indian warm-down involves players lying on their front while the physio walks up and down on their backsides. Stay tuned for the Boycott verdict...
-
Dan from Bristol, via text on 81111: "So much negativity today. Shouldn't we be admiring the fact that our side are 200 runs in front against India in India with a destructive bowling line up to come?"
Andy in London, via text on 81111: "Re: Andy in Maidenhead (1032) - take Cook's score out & we've still outscored India. Not doing too badly..."
Tom in Colchester, via text on 81111: "Too many starts, 3 batsmen getting 50 and Patel's 33, but only Cook converting the "daddy hundred" on a nice batting track. That's where England need work."
-
James H on Twitter: "Two words for people clamouring for Prior to bat up the order: Adam Gilchrist."
-
1038:
The body language says it all - while Prior and Swann march off the pitch, Dhoni trudges off, head bowed slowly juggling the match ball from one glove to another. India face a mammoth task to save this match.
-
1036:CLOSE OF PLAY- Eng 509-6 (lead by 193)
India are exhausted after two days in the field and Pujara simply can't muster the energy to throw himself to the ground and stop a Swann cut at point. The result is two more runs to the ever-swelling England score. Swann leaves the last two balls of the over well alone to round off another more than satisfactory day for England.
-
Stu, via text on 81111: "A major difference between the teams: Monty 15 wickets at 20; Swann 15 wickets at 20-odd; Ojha 17 wickets at 20-odd; Ashwin 7 wickets at 77. He's also 0.5 of a run per over more expensive than the others."
-
1032:Eng 507-6
Prior steams to 40 (with 30 runs coming in boundaries) with another meaty cut off Ojha for four. One more to go, England lead by 191.
-
Geoffrey Boycott, BBC Test Match Special"India have had a reasonable day. They couldn't really have expected to bowl England out on this wicket with Cook there and Pietersen still to come."
-
Jason in Belfast, via text on 81111: "What is it with the constant need to criticise a performance ('he needs to get runs') after one bad innings? Consistency is the key - I remember people clamouring for Cook to be dropped when his form hit a bad patch - isn't exactly a bad batsman now is he?"
Andy in Maidenhead, via text on 81111: "County and Lions form counts for nothing at this level. Take Cook's score out and it's not a great batting performance on this wicket."
-
1026:APPEAL - NOT OUT- Eng 503-6
Desperate for a late wicket or two, Dhoni is adopting a scattergun approach to bowling changes and now Sharma is back again in place of Ashwin. Swann laps up the first sight of width and brings up the England 500 with a cut for four. The last ball of the over bangs into Swann's pads but Rod Tucker is having none of it. Two overs left.
-
Gary Hershcovitch on Twitter: "Prior once again proving why he should be batting far higher up. Just imagine his average if he was given partners to play with!"
Gareth Price on Twitter: "I think people forget how each batting position is subtly different, a batsman who excels at 7 may not be a natural 6."
Andrew Hodgson on Twitter: "Bell should have stayed at home with his family. Patel is outscoring him and can bowl."
-
1022:Eng 499-6
Dhoni is rotating his bowlers here and Ojha is back to end Sharma's one-over spell. Clear signs of weariness though as a full toss is given the treatment by Prior, who moves to 36 off 40 balls. The partnership with Swann is worth 46 now - very handy for the England lead, which is now 183.
-
1019:Eng 494-6
Sehwag tumbles forward to claim a low bat-pad catch but Ashwin's very hopeful appeal is dismissed out of hand by Umpire Tucker. I want whatever Matt Prior has been having. Another flick of the wrists and the ball shoots off at a frightening lick over square leg for four.
-
1016:Eng 488-6
Sharma has bowled well today and Dhoni is giving him another dart before stumps. In fact he should have had two wickets but dropped an absolute dolly off his own bowling when Cook had 152. Swann shows him plenty of respect as he blocks out a maiden.
Reintegration latest - KP and Samit spotted chatting merrily in the England dressing-room. Anyone care to insert a punchline?
-
Ali in London, via text on 81111: "Patel's an excellent batsman. That's why he's in the team. Take a look at his county and Lions record."
Fraser, via text on 81111: "I'm sticking up for Patel. Batted well in the warm ups and gives another bowling option, not his fault he wasn't bowled in 1st innings. Bell's the one who needs to get some runs."
Miko, via text on 81111: "Bairstow's fielding is likely to get more wickets than Patel's bowling."
-
1011:Eng 488-6
The spinners are getting through their overs quickly now, with Swann and Prior taking stock and perhaps starting to think about the close.
-
Neil James Mace on Twitter: "Criticism of Patel is a bit unfair, you don't become a Test cricketer by playing limited overs. Early days in his career."
Ralph Brooker on Twitter: "Sorry, but I grind my teeth at talk of promoting Prior. He is in his natural habitat. Tailor-made for the late assault."
-
1006:Eng 482-6 (lead by 166)
Prior pulls off another fine sweep shot, which is too fast for deep square leg and earns him another four. England's number seven has 25 from 28 balls and is taking the lead rapidly towards the 200 mark.
-
More Samit-bashing I'm afraid...
Ollie, via text on 81111: "Why is Patel in the team? He hasn't bowled, he made a useful 33 but nothing more, and he certainly isn't a Collingwood or Jonty Rhodes in the field."
Ramesh, via text on 81111: "Can someone explain what Samit Patel's role in the team is? It isn't bowler because he didn't get a bowl in the 1st innings. It isn't batsman because he isn't good at it. Shouldn't Bairstow be playing instead of Patel?"
-
1003:Eng 478-6
Swann fancies this you know. A little shuffle down the track, then a swing of the bat and the ball sails over mid-off for four. Ojha responds with a beauty as the ball grips and rips past Swann's edge and is taken by first slip! Swann won't mind that, he'll be thinking about India's second innings.
-
Andrew, via text on 81111: "Assuming we are not going to declare I think getting bowled out this evening is the best chance of England getting a victory. Then we can bowl at a tired Indian side for the last few overs today and pick up a couple of wickets."
-
1001:Eng 474-6
More Prior power as he middles a reverse sweep for four. "If you'd hit a regulation sweep with that power you'd be thrilled," enthuses Dravid as he signs off his TMS stint.
-
Dr Winston on Twitter: "England haven't really collapsed but against this attack on this pitch 550 should've been minimum a few hours ago."
Harvey Austin on Twitter: "Patel is not a good enough batsman or bowler. Bit part players should not be in test cricket."
Jack Mendel on Twitter: "Prior clearly should be at 6 not 7 if Patel plays. He is the best keeper-batsmen in the world and runs out of partners."
-
0958:Eng 468-6
Finn is padded up on the England balcony so it looks like he's been preferred to Anderson for the number nine slot. Out in the middle Swann gets off the mark in slightly fortunate fashion with a slash over gully for four.
-
Jonathan Agnew, BBC Test Match Special"Every now and again as an international cricketer you get a real chance to make your mark and I feel Samit Patel missed his."
-
0950:Eng 464-6
What do we make of that Samit knock? Bearing in mind he may not bat or bowl again in this match, has he done enough to keep his place? Encouraging signs but as Dravid put it - "nothing significant".
More sloppy stuff from Dhoni as he's wrong-footed by Sharma's bounce and gives away four byes. That's 13 byes conceded in the England innings now. Swann's the new man but he's kept at the non-striker's end as Prior takes command. He is denied four by a brilliant stop at point, but heaves a short ball over midwicket for a quite incredible six.
-
Rahul Dravid, BBC Test Match Special"That was not really short enough to cut and Sehwag caught it at the second attempt. Unlucky for Samit Patel because that so easily could have gone straight to ground. He'll be disappointed to have got a start but not to convert it into anything significant."
-
WICKET- Patel c Sehwag b Ojha 33 (Eng 453-6)
I definitely put the mockers on the India fielders. Gambhir fumbles on the fence to gift Patel a four and take him to his highest Test score of 33. Samit doesn't add to his score though as a top-edged cut is taken at the second attempt by Sehwag at first slip.
-
0942:Eng 445-5
I know I said we'd closed the Tradesman's chat but that one from Darren was such a peach that, a bit like Marcus Trescothick to a ball pitched up outside off stump, I couldn't resist a nibble.
Dhoni moves almost his entire field to the leg side as Zaheer bowls to Patel. Zaheer tries to tempt Patel with a short ball but he mistimes the pull shot and only bottom edges it to square leg.
-
Darren via text: "Kallis in the Tradesman XI as he is the Jacques of all the trades."
-
Sam Earnshaw on Twitter: "When was the last time Bell put in a decent innings? I think give Bairstow a proper go."
-
0938:Eng 437-5
Off we go then for the final hour of play. India have been a whole lot hungrier in the field today, epitomised by a Gambhir chase and return deny Prior a boundary. Almost immediately, Sharma undermines my claim, by showing very little desire to break stride and prevent Prior picking up four over midwicket.
-
Vic Marks, BBC Test Match Special"England have a long tail that you would not expect to last very long. A lot hinges on this partnership, and especially Samit Patel, and then whether Swann, who hasn't made many runs recently, can contribute to get the lead way over 150 so they can really put the pressure on India. They certainly want to be around the 500 mark today. There were moments when 600 looked possible, but it's still a handy position, just not quite as dominant as they hoped. "
-
Jerry in Colombo, TMS inbox: "Can you take a 12th Man for the Tradesman's XI? I'd suggest Kevin Pietersen. No one has been Plumber."
-
Oli Denne on Twitter: "Technically a former umpire but I've always thought David Lloyd looks like the human version of Grandpa Abe from the Simpsons."
-
0929:Eng 433-5
Super Samit. He leans into a drive and helps himself to four more. Then a nudge into space to keep the strike and move his score to 21.
-
From Liam in Southend-on-Sea, via text on 81111: "Dickie Bird is the spitting image of Roy Cropper from Corrie."
-
0924:Eng 428-5
The sweep shot is well and truly back in vogue among the England players at the moment. Prior picks up a single then Patel gets a bit lucky with a top edge that lands safely in a gap. Swann, Anderson, Finn and Panesar to come for England.
-
From Ben in York, via text on 81111: "Bad time for Bell to be out of form with Bairstow and Root pushing for a place. Seems to be in two minds about what type of batsmen he is. A class player but the form will only come by knowing his own game."
-
0919:Eng 423-5
Zaheer Khan gives Matt Prior a warm welcome with a quick blast of chin music. Then Prior gets off the quacker with a single.
This feels like a really important innings for Samit Patel, who has looked good for his 12 runs so far. He has a highest Test score of 29 and you could even say he is playing for his place. Should he fail, the selectors may feel it's a good time to give Morgan or Bairstow another chance in the last Test, with the New Zealand tour in mind.
-
Vic Marks, BBC Test Match Special"He was trying to repeat the shot before but that was a straight and quicker ball and he missed it. Pietersen was desperate to give the impression he was outside the line. Ashwin's celebrations are muted because he has bowled so many overs without reward but Pietersen is always a big wicket, he was threatening to run amok and began the final session with three fours in a row."
-
0915:Eng 420-5
Ashwin looks a very relieved man to have finally taken a wicket in his 46th over. He wasn't exactly pulling up any trees in Mumbai either. Now then, can the England's lower middle order takes this lead towards the 200 mark or are India going to get themselves right back in the game?
Matty Prior blocks out the rest of Ashwin's over.
-
WICKET- Pietersen lbw b Ashwin 54 (Eng 420-5)
England's lead is 100 now. Make that 104 as KP sweeps firmly for another boundary. Ashwin sends one through a bit lower and quicker, KP plays over the ball and is trapped lbw.
-
From Chris, TMS inbox: "Umpire lookalikes - Simon Taufel and All Black fly half Stephen Donald?"
-
0910:Pietersen fifty- Eng 416-4
A nice little whip to square leg by Kevin Pietersen takes him to 50 off 83 balls. He acknowledges the applause of crowd and team-mates but looks like a man who fancies a fair few more.
-
Jake Waring on Twitter: "Billy Bowden looks a bit like James Cromwell (the farmer in Babe)."
If you say so Jake.
-
0905:Eng 415-4
A ball from Ashwin keeps low but Patel watches it carefully and gets his bat down in time. Another one bounces to waist height and almost takes the inside edge on the way through to the keeper. Monty will be loving that.
-
From Nick in London, TMS inbox: "Umpire lookalikes. Has to be Darryl Hair and Alf Stewart from Home and Away."
-
Geoffrey Boycott, BBC Test Match Special"If England can get a nice lead, but not too huge, it might suck India into thinking they can get knock these runs off and get ahead in the series. That could play into England's hands if India's batsmen start attacking and get out to sloppy shots."
-
0903:Eng 415-4
Sharma strays slightly and is immediately punished by Pietersen who drives him majestically through the covers to move to 49. A slower ball from Sharma has the crowd appealing for a catch, only to realise that a) the ball hit the ground, and b) Sharma dropped it.
-
Tom Rhodes on Twitter: "Steve Bucknor's got both the look and demeanour of Morgan Freeman. Doubt he's got the voice though."
-
Michael Foggin on Twitter: "Just need someone to stick in there with KP and we will have a good lead, Patel needs a good innings."
-
0857:Eng 410-4
Patel is making a great start out there. He works Ashwin to deep square leg for two then cracks one high over midwicket for four.
-
Roy Barkley on Twitter: "Note of caution, Eden Gardens 2001, India hopelessly off the pace yet stage an unbelievable turnaround to beat Australia."
-
0854:Eng 403-4
Sharma to KP, who is watchful, respectful of the man who has just taken the wicket of Bell. Good, straight bowling from Sharma, refusing to give Pietersen any room and completing a maiden over.
-
Steven Kaye on Twitter: "Can't help but feel umpire Dharmasena looks a bit like Tiger Woods."
Good shout Steven, I can see it. Something about the solemn stare. Any other umpire lookie-likeys. I'm sure Rod Tucker reminds me of someone.
-
0848:Eng 403-4
KP tickles off his toes for two then gets one to move to 44. Samit on strike now and that's a sizzler of a square cut for four to take England past the 400 mark. Nicely done my son.
-
James Gulleford on Twitter: "Cue the usual England collapse, silly shot from Bell, could be costly, need a lead of at least 200."
-
0845:Eng 396-4
Samit Patel strides to the crease with England wobbling a touch. Sharma is fired up here and he oversteps to add another run to the England total. Cue the Bell-bashing...
-
Geoffrey Boycott, BBC Test Match Special"Sharma has probably deserved a wicket. He has run in and tried ever so hard on a pitch that isn't great for seamers. It wasn't a great shot, I know it's a defensive field, but they've decided they are going to get on with it and it was a nothing shot."
-
WICKET- Bell c Dhoni b Sharma 5 (Eng 395-4)
Bell gets under way after tea with two runs past point but he doesn't last much longer. A loose drive off Sharma catches the inside edge and Dhoni takes a low catch.
-
0838:APPEAL - NOT OUT- Eng 393-3
Electric start from Pietersen as he splatters the first three balls after tea and cakes for four through the off side. Ojha tightens his field, prompting a couple of forward defences from KP then yells an appeal as the batsman is hit on the front pad. Not for the first time in this innings umpire Dharmasena shakes his head. KP was just outside the line of off stump there.
-
0831:
England lead by 65 runs at the moment with Pietersen just showing signs of coming to the boil with a six and a four before lunch. It's a long shot, but if he gets to 100 before the close, Cook's reign as England's lone record centurion will have lasted precisely one day.
-
0829:
Morning all, here I am, fresh from another encounter with the Singing Chef. And I'm not talking about Alastair Cook, believe me. We reckon this match is going the distance, with England likely to want a lead of at least 200 before the put India in to bat again. They could collapse of course and with Finn in for Broad, England's tail is a bit more labrador than pug today.
-
0817:
On TMS you can hear Jonathan Agnew's visit to the Future Hope charity for Kolkata street children, so tune in to that. I'm off for my third breakfast, with Sam Sheringham returning to talk you through the evening session.
-
Ian Ferris, TMS inbox: Tradesman's XI: 1 Slater, 2 Taylor, 3 Butcher, 4 Cook, 5 Clerk, 6 Painter, 7 Engineer, 8 Sales, 9 Pope, 10 Barber, 11 Miller.
Great work Ian. I think your full XI nicely rounds off our tradesman riff. Next week - the professions.
-
Rahul Dravid, BBC Test Match Special"That was a good session for India, probably the first one this Test match that they can claim to have had some sort of control, but England are still very much on top."
-
The Writer of Wrongs on Twitter: "Is there a case for India refusing to accept the wicket? Doesn't feel very sporting to get a wicket in that way."
-
0810:TEA- Eng 381-3 - 65 ahead
It's Ashwin the offie to take us to tea, with Pietersen building a thirst by sweeping for four. Pietersen walks a single to long on - he'll be 29 not out at the break - with Bell covering up to have a brew on three. England lead by 65 and are setting themselves for an assault on India's tired attack.
-
Adam Edwards on Twitter: "Alastair Cook. Great batsman, total scaredycat."
-
0808:Eng 376-3
Let's get Cliff in as our expert summariser. As though he was hearing messages from Seattle, Pietersen gets his dancing shoes on to send Ojha sailing straight for six. Playing for tea? You know nothing, Shemilt.
-
Cliff in Seattle, TMS inbox: "Now wait just a moment here. Bell and Pietersen at the crease and Vic Marks is worried about a "far lower total" following Cook's dismissal? You're kidding me - right? I see the run rate now increasing and a T-20 run-fest finish to the day."
-
0805:Eng 369-3
Like a man looking for his keys in the dark, Bell is feeling his way here, ducking one Sharma bumper then hooking another for a single. Sharma, his mullet billowing, then has a word as Pietersen pulls out an extravagant leave. My advice to a bowler whose team has been carted round for 369-3? Shut up.
-
Tarun on Twitter: "Cook's reaction showed he had made some mistake, easy to blame India."
Sunil on Twitter: "One moment of madness should not overshadow the magnificent innings that had just blessed Eden gardens! Well done Cook!"
Christopher Sparke on Twitter: "At the time of his dismissal, Cook had scored over 38% of England's runs in the series (547 out of 1427)."
Ed Salinger on Twitter: "After being on the field for over 90% of the action who can blame Cook's thought process for not being quite at its sharpest."
-
0759:Eng 367-3
A few comparisons are being made between Cook's run out and the situation that saw Ian Bell called back at Trent Bridge in 2011. They're different in that this was Cook's error, whereas Bell, on that occasion, had good reason to think the ball was dead. The aforementioned Bell goes back to take Ojha for a single.
-
Andrew Samson, BBC Test Match Special statistician"Cook has made 547 runs at an average of 136.75 in this series and batted for 26 hours and one minute. He has faced 1,160 balls, hit 65 fours and three sixes.
"That was also the first time Cook has been run out in first-class cricket."
-
0754:Eng 366-3
How often do see a batsman on only 12 faced with a field that is completely slipless? That's what Pietersen has as Ishant Sharma comes into the attack in place of Zaheer. Sharma gets too leggy, allowing Pietersen to work off his hips for four.
-
Josh Withers on Twitter: "Should Dhoni call Cook back there? Seems against the spirit of the game."
-
0749:Eng 361-3
Cook's scoring had slowed right down as he neared a double ton, but the arrival of a new man at the crease will delay England's acceleration further. Bell could do with a score, too. He respects an Ojha maiden. England playing for tea?
-
Phil Keith on Twitter: "What a way to get out!!! Should have let it hit you! Run out on 190! Well batted Alastair Cook."
-
0742:Eng 361-3
Cook was retreating back to his ground as Kohli's throw came in from square leg. He was reaching for his ground, but stopped just before grounding his bat, letting the ball pass under his arm. Only problem was, the ball hit the timbers and the skipper knew straight away that he was a gonner, putting his head in his hands. Credit to the umpires, they checked to see if Cook had grounded his bat at any point, but replays couldn't save him. Zaheer to Pietersen, a maiden.
-
TestCricketFanatic on Twitter: "Tradesmen's XI - Bob Barber"
-
0740:Eng 361-3
My word, what do we make of all that? Plenty to talk about with that Cook dismissal. Before that, Ian Bell is the new man and is off the mark with a single off Ojha.
-
Rob Porter on Twitter: "Should Cook have just stood there and let the ball hit him?! Ridiculous."
-
0740:
Stephan my son, after that textbook explanation of the rules, I've decided you're the man to take over the tiller. Steady hand my friend, keep her out of danger.
-
Vic Marks, BBC Test Match Special"That was a freakish end to a brilliant innings. He let his instinct take over and made sure he got out of the way. He could have got in easily, his bat was hanging over the line. Tremendously frustrating for Cook. It's just possible that England could get a far lower total as a consequence. Suddenly the crowd is alive and there's a new batsman in."
-
Stephan Shemilt, BBC Sport"If Cook had grounded his bat before the throw, then taken 'evasive action' to avoid the ball, he would have been given not out. As it was, the skipper just stopped short of dropping his bat over the crease before allowing the ball to pass by and, by the time the stumps were hit, it was too late."
-
WICKET- Cook run out (Kohli) 190 (Eng 359-3)
KP slapped the ball into the covers and declined to run. Cook was taking evasive action to avoid Kohli's throw but was out of his ground as the ball struck his timbers. The umpires took advice from the TV official before deciding the England skipper had to go.
-
UMPIRE REVIEW
Now then, drama. Has Cook been run out for 190 at the non-striker's end???
-
greatwhiteegg on Twitter: "Trademen's XI, if there's a dispute there will have to be a Boycott."
-
0728:Eng 357-2
Ojha gets one all wrong and this time Dhoni has no chance of stopping it as it trickles down the leg side for four byes. Cook's scoring rate has almost slowed to a halt here. He does this sometimes when he approaches the big landmarks. I still remember his look of utter devastation when he was out for 294 at Edgbaston last year.
-
From Dexter in London, via text on 81111: "Tradesmen's XI: Mark Taylor & Michael Slater to open."
-
0725:Eng 353-2
Another corker of a shot from KP, bludgeoning Yuvraj down the ground to the rope. If he stays in England could be 300 to the good come stumpies.
-
0721:Eng 348-2
The spectators in the Eden Gardens crowd are taunting those of us stuck in freezing Blighty, lapping up ice lollies in the sun. Ojha is teasing the England batsman too, KP totally misreading a quicker ball which shoots through the gate and past Dhoni's left leg for four byes.
-
David M Stewart on Twitter: "Tradesmen's XI: Robert Pearson Carpenter was a noted English cricketer and umpire."
-
0718:Eng 343-2
Yuvi floats one up well outside off stump and KP isn't going to leave this alone. His timing is spot on as he clatters it just in front of square on the off side for a boundary. KP connects again but this time Kohli is alert in the covers and stops the ball in its tracks.
-
Richy on Twitter: "Tradesmen's XI: Bert Ironmonger."
-
From Neil in Letchworth, via text on 81111: "Tradesmens XI: Manager would have to be Duncan Fletcher."
-
0711:DRINKS BREAK- Eng 339-2
Cook settles everyone down by calmly playing back an Ojha maiden. Time for a quick drinks break before the resumption of the Yuvi v KP show.
-
Geoffrey Boycott, BBC Test Match Special"Where's Ian Bell to calm it down! When Pietersen comes in, he can get over-excited and try to over-attack and get himself out. You never quite know with him."
-
Richard Holden on Twitter: "Mark Butcher might make the cut in a Tradesmen's XI."
-
0707:Eng 339-2
Flags are waving and fans are screaming as Dhoni brings on another left-armer in the form of Yuvraj. And the tactic almost pays dividends straight away when KP almost edges onto his stumps. Another ball, another close shave as an inside edge cannons onto his boot. Don't go anywhere.
-
Oliver Doward, BBC Sport in Kolkata"That innings was classic Jonathan Trott. An almost totally uneventful knock, but you look at the board and he's burgled 87."
-
From Pete Allen, via text on 81111: "Tradesmen's XI: Eddie Paynter and Andrew Plummer. Bet there's a Carpenter out there too."
-
0704:Eng 339-2
Another roar as Kevin Pietersen comes out to face the left-arm spin of Pragyan Ojha. How will KP play this one then? Plenty of intent as he pushes his first three balls firmly into the off side then gets off the mark with a cut for one.
-
Geoffrey Boycott, BBC Test Match Special"The odd ball has turned by Ojha at Trott and there he played defensively and got a nick. There's no shame in getting out to a good ball, it was a good length and line and he had to play it. It's irritating because he wanted a hundred but don't beat yourself up about it."
-
WICKET- Trott c Dhoni b Ojha 87 (Eng 338-2)
Trott nicks a ball from Ojha that turns a fraction, Dhoni catches and Eden Gardens erupts. India have a wicket at last.
-
From Piers Morgan, TMS inbox: "Cook and Taylor should definitely be in the Tradesmen's XI and maybe throw a Buttler in there too!"
-
0656:Eng 338-1
Cook sweeps round the corner off the toe end of his bat, then Trott has a bit of a loose swing but manages to clear leg gully and pick up two runs.
-
From Dave in Hitchin, via text on 81111: "Tradesman's XI: Brickie Ponting?"
-
0653:Eng 334-1 (Lead by 18)
Back to basics for the England duo after that brief flirtation with recklessness. Ashwin is milked for a couple before Cook takes a single off Ojha.
-
Tom Byrne on Twitter: "Tradesman's XI: Farokh Engineer."
-
0648:Eng 332-1
Two more to the Cooker, then a risk. A big one... Cook wants a single but Trott sends him back. Gambhir's throw lets India down and Dhoni has to flip the ball at the stumps out of the back of his hand. By the time he does, Cook's dive has saved his bacon. Phew mockers fears abated, for now.
-
Geoffrey Boycott, BBC Test Match Special"England are accumulating runs quite easily and I suspect they will carry on towards tea like this. If they are going to make a spurt it will be after tea and if Pietersen hasn't had a knock by then they should probably stand him down and put Bell in. It would be good to get Bell into the action because he's been away and it's not good for the mind if you've just been sat there waiting to get in."
-
Tom in London via text: "Master chef - what a delicious way to start the day, rolling pastry a long long way."
-
0644:Eng 329-1
Cook's not giving up on this race you know. Here he his dancing down the track to plant Pragyan Ojha into the stands. I'm sure he wouldn't have done that before he was made one-day captain. I genuinely think the limited-overs game has done wonders for Cook's repertoire. He's on 183 now, Trott 83 - neck and neck.
-
0640:APPEAL - NOT OUT- Eng 320-1
Big appeal from Ohja as Trott is rapped on the pad. Not out says the ump, missing leg suggests the replay.
-
Oliver Jones on Twitter: "There once was Jonny Trott who when the ball hit the slot hit it for 4 the crowd wanted more but then the next ball was a dot."
-
Nasrey Odum on Twitter: "Sachin Tendulkar should call it a day. I hate seeing England win Test matches. India need young lads."
-
0637:Eng 319-1- England in the lead
Trott unfurls an immaculate reverse sweep to motor into the eighties and put England into the lead. Then he slaps to long leg for another two. He's the firm favourite to reach the landmark now. Nari Contractor, what a great name. Anyone care to suggest other members of a tradesmen's XI?
-
0634:Eng 313-1
Trott nurdles round the corner for a two to reach 77. Cook has 173. Who's your money on? Trott to get to his ton or Cook to his double first? Or is that a horrible dose of mockers?
-
Simon Mann, BBC Test Match Special"It's not been a riveting day so far but it's been a very professional England performance. Trott wants to make the most of his opportunity here, having struggled in the previous Tests."
-
0630:Eng 310-1
Hope for India in the form of a thick edge from Trott, but the ball keeps low and absolutely races away to the boundary. More cheers and jeers from the Barmies as Sharma fumbles in the field. He's more like Titus Bramble than Zlatan Ibrahimovic at the moment.
-
RichieJK on Twitter: "If England win this series and then the Ashes next year, that has to be the best start to England captaincy ever right?"
-
0627:Ind 304-1
Trott plays out another Ojha maiden. He is doing a very good job of hogging the strike at the moment, with Cook only facing five balls in the first six overs after lunch.
-
Robin in Chesterfield via text: "Who have India got left to bring out and do the end of day interview? - the groundsman?"
-
0624:Eng 304-1
Another little slice of luck for Cook, who hasn't been quite as fluent today. He flashes a big drive at Ashwin, getting a thick outside edge that runs to third man for four. England grind past 300.
-
Oliver Doward, BBC Sport in Kolkata"Ted Dexter was regaling tales to those in earshot over lunch, unfurling a series of stylish imaginary cover drives as he talked - the magic is still there! Lord Ted is the oldest surviving England captain to have led the side in India and is at Eden Gardens as a guest of honour along with opposing skipper from the 1961/62 series, Nari Contractor."
-
0622:Eng 298-1
Ojha rattles through another over quicker than you could say Ravichandran. It's a maiden. Re Cook, what about a Chef's Special?
-
John in Huddersfield via text: "Just up with my 2-year-old cricket mad son who is playing pretend cricket. Think it's the only way India would get a wicket today!"
-
0619:Eng 298-1
I'm quite proud of my "MasterChef" term for a big Cook hundred. Any other suggestions? Or other cricketers who nicknames could work in similar ways? The usual steady start post-lunch from these two, with just a single to Trott off Ashwin's first offering.
-
0616:Eng 297-1
Trott gets the scoreboard moving after tea with a tickled single off Ojha. Cook and Trotters have now combined for 132 runs this series. I'm starting to get that Brisbane feeling.
-
0611:
Marmite old friend, how I've missed you. Sorry, miles away with my breakfast. The Indian fielders are intertwined in their third huddle of the day with Dhoni offering more words of wisdom. In case you are just joining us, the news is that England have taken their first innings score to 296-1. Captain Cook is still there on 167 after surviving the mother of all dropped catches by Ishant Sharma. Trott has 66. Let's play.
-
BBC Sport's Alistair Watkins
The two greatest wicket-takers in Test cricket - Muttiah Muralitharan and Shane Warne - will face each other when the second season of Australia's Big Bash gets under way later today.
Warne will lead a Melbourne Stars side who are favourites to win the T20 competition, and has David Hussey, Lasith Malinga and England's Luke Wright in his team, while Muralitharan is the star name in the Melbourne Renegades line-up.
Wright made the highest score of the Big Bash League in 2011-12, hitting 117 off 60 balls - including nine sixes - against the Hobart Hurricanes.
BBC Radio 5 live sports extra will have live commentary on selected matches later in the tournament, starting next Wednesday with Perth Scorchers against Warne's Melbourne Stars.
-
0540:
Time for a quick pause chez nous. Why not give your live text reading eyes a little rest chez vous? We'll catch you in good time for the restart at 0610 GMT, while Test Match Special have a feature on Joe Root followed by a report on New Zealand's captaincy crisis.
-
Vic Marks, BBC Test Match Special"It's been a sedate old morning, 80 runs from 32 overs. Cook has been the junior partner, which is unusual, and he's played and missed more times this morning than he did all yesterday. I think India bowled OK and we have seen the ball turn a little more in the last 45 minutes or so, but the situation for them is not good. It's rosy for England."
-
0534:LUNCH INTERVAL- Eng 296-1
This really is a batting masterclass from Chef, a Masterchef if you will. This time he's on the back foot, playing against the spin but with total control to punch Ashwin past midwicket for two more. A single each before Cook leaves a wide one that bounces sharply and is taken by Dhoni at shoulder height.
Thus ends another great session for England who will lunch with gusto on this fine Kolkata morn. They are just 20 runs behind India's first innings total, and still have nine wickets in hand.
-
0526:Eng 291-1
An instant riposte to Greg as Yuvraj pulls off a fine piece of fielding. He darts along the rope and stops the ball with one hand to keep Trott to two runs.
-
Greg Fuller on Twitter: "India have 10 Montys in the field today. Luckily none bowling."
-
From Michael in London, via text on 81111: "Don't worry Sharma, it cannot be any worse than my only serious over of bowling, taking 12 balls to finish it and actually bring applauded at the painful end. Needless to say I got nowhere near the school team again."
-
0523:
New Zealand Cricket boss David White on Ross Taylor's decision to take a break from cricket after a dispute about the captaincy: "He thought about it long and hard and he said that he would like a break to spend time with his family and we've agreed to that and we respect it.
"It's not ideal and we would be a stronger team with Ross Taylor in it."
-
Charlotte Berry on Twitter: "I'm running out of good excuses for producing little work in the past 3 days. Apparently 'because the cricket's on' is not an excuse."
-
0523:Eng 288-1
Wow, stat gold from Andrew there. Is Cook superhuman? Half man, half Brad-man? Discuss. Ojha is on for Sharma and there is definitely a bit more turn in this pitch, which is another good sign for England.
-
Andrew Samson, BBC Test Match Special statistician"We're approaching 60 hours of play in the series, Alastair Cook has been on the pitch for 90% of that time."
-
0520:Eng 287-1
The Barmy Army are now serenading Sharma with the Mitchell Johnson song. "He's bowls to the left..." and all that jazz. Ashwin's been by far the best of the India bowlers this morning and he vary nearly accounts for Cook as the England batsman almost sweeps onto his stumps.
-
Shravan Bhat on Twitter: "For all the talk of the pitch, India have got all the basics wrong. Silly run outs, drop catches and not bowling to a field."
-
0515:APPEAL - NOT OUT- Eng 287-1
Back to spin, in the form of Ashwin. Still no sign of Yuvraj with just the four bowlers used by Dhoni so far. Good ball from Ashwin, turned past Cook's outside edge. Then some more sharp turn and an appeal as Trott is rapped on the pads. Rod Tucker says no, probably because Trott was well forward, but a good shout all the same.
-
TrickieDickie in Hollywood, TMS inbox: "That was the cunning plan! Drop him on 156, then watch in awe as he cruises to a triple century, while focusing on mopping up the tail at the other end, leaving a target of around 750 to scratch out a draw and go into the decider level at 1-1. Genius."
-
Vic Marks, BBC Test Match Special"The only blot on the horizon for England is that the pitch is perhaps behaving too well, but there's still time for that to change. That's why they want to bat all day and maybe into tomorrow. They are on course to be around about 300 at lunch, 500 at the close. If they get there, they would give it some humpty tomorrow morning because, as it stands, it will take a lot to bowl a side out. If it goes well I think they will accelerate this afternoon and evening."
-
0509:Eng 282-1
No rest for Sharma as he's asked to bowl another over. I'm surprised he hasn't contrived a reason to temporarily vacate the field. England work him for three singles and the waiting game continues for India.
-
Oliver Doward, BBC Sport"Poor Ishant Sharma. Within moments of grassing the simplest of chances off his own bowling, Barmy Army trumpeter Billy Cooper blares out the traditional circus clown theme!"
-
From Bertie in Cambridge, TMS inbox: "I sympathise with Sam's cabbie [0344]. First time I watched cricket, this is what I saw: 11 men standing around, not doing very much, dressed in white. And then two men walk out with clubs, dressed for a nuclear war."
-
Adam Mountford, BBC Test Match SpecialOn Twitter: "During lunch interval on TMS (0530) we profile England's rising star Joe Root and get the latest on turmoil in New Zealand."
-
0503:Eng 279-1
The TV directors are not being kind to poor old Ishant Sharma after that dropped catch. After every ball, they are zooming in on him as if searching for an explanation for his aberration. Cook's happy for another life, slashing to deep point for another single to move to 157 of the best.
-
Rahul Dravid, BBC Test Match Special"It's been slow and steady for England, consolidation. There's an air on inevitability about this for India, who are aware they are going to have to bat very well in the second innings."
-
0459:Eng 278-1
Just noticing a thicker than average covering of facial hair on Trott's lower visage. Makes him look a whole lot scarier, almost wolf-like. He's in the the zone now, driving Sharma for another boundary to reach 60 not out.
-
0456:
Some news from New Zealand where Ross Taylor has been replaced by Brendon McCullum as New Zealand captain in all three forms of the game. The move comes after speculation that McCullum would take over from Taylor as ODI and T20 captain only. Taylor has now opted to take a break from the game and will miss the Black Caps' tour of South Africa.
-
0455:Eng 274-1
I've going to stick my neck out and say that is the worst drop I have ever seen. But we move on. Single to Trott off Zaheer.
-
Jonathan Agnew, BBC Test Match Special"It's cruel to even describe how easy that was, the sort of soft underarm lob of a tennis ball you'd toss to your granny in the garden."
-
0451:DROPPED CATCH- Eng 269-1
Sharma pitches one a bit full and Cook punches him down the ground for four. Then - horror of horrors for India - Sharma drops an absolute dolly of a return catch from Cook. The ball is simply lobbed back to him but the ball hits the back of his hands and bounces down. Cook looks embarrassed still to be there. So wasteful from India.
-
From Ben in Alberta, TMS inbox: "That huddle was a cunning stunt designed to fool Cook into thinking India actually have a plan…"
-
0443:Eng 269-1
Just looking at a table on TV which tells me that Cook now has the fourth highest amount of runs by any visiting batsman in Asia. Top of the tree? Jacques Kallis since you ask. More sign of uneven bounce as a Zaheer ball scoots past Cook's blade at ankle height. England's pacemen will be licking their lips at the sight of that.
-
Dan Palmer on Twitter: "India don't look interested at all. Completely different side to the one that smashed us a few years back, England cruising."
-
0440:Eng 267-1
What do we reckon Dhoni said to his troops in that there huddle? "Keep calm and carry on?" "Anybody got a cunning plan?" "Is there a trap door in this stadium?" It's not the most auspicious of restarts for the hosts as Ashwin very nearly allows to a Trott drive to slide through him at mid-off. A little bit of extra bounce for Sharma surprises Cook, who takes his hand off the bat after gloving the ball down in front of him.
-
Jonathan Agnew, BBC Test Match Special"This is quite rare, India are having a second huddle of the day, as if Dhoni is saying 'what are we going to do about this?'"
-
Harriet in New York, TMS inbox: "Following the live text on Thursday evening from New York, studiously ignoring all comparisons to baseball and joining the aesthetic appreciation of my fellow lady cricket fans. Can England prove Boycott right by batting all day and in turn my claims that baseball players would be stumped trying to play all day in the Indian sun? Yes please. Fingers crossed it'll be good news when I wake up."
-
Geoffrey Boycott, BBC Test Match Special"If you're an Indian supporter it must be quite disheartening so early in the morning. The spinners caused no problems and the new ball has gone off the bat quicker. I can't give any genuine hope for India as to how they are going to get wickets."
-
0431:Trott fifty- Eng 266-1
Trott is building to a canter out there. He's enjoying the extra pace on the new ball and he storms to his 13th Test fifty with two boundaries in a row off Zaheer. The first is a half-volley, flicked off his pads, the second clipped off the hips and as ever at the ground, the outfield does the rest. This partnership is now worth 101 - plenty for India to ponder as the players pause for a drink.
-
David Wilson on Twitter: "Start of day three is mirroring my own. In the office an hour now and I've only just gotten off the mark with my first work email."
-
0424:Eng 254-1
Ishant Sharma makes a bright start with a ball that whistles past Trott's off stump at a decent rate. Then a bit of width and Trott finds the boundary rop with a square drive.
-
Philip Sparrow on Twitter: "Cook will be considered a true great when he captains England to two Ashes victories in one year."
-
0421:Cook reaches 150- Eng 250-1
Zaheer Khan is back for his 19th over and he's yet to take a wicket. He won't get one with balls like that earlier. It's much too straight to Cook, who clobbers him through midwicket to bring up the big 150. Zaheer tries a slower ball but only succeeds in delivering a looping full toss, which Cook just pushes back to the bowler.
Still no sign of a bead of sweat on the England skipper's brow. Can anyone else out there play sport without perspiring. Quite a skill that.
-
Nick Wall on Twitter: "Which batsman would you rather have to bat for your life - Geoff Boycott or Ali Cook?!"
-
0414:Eng 246-1
Ashwin's carrom ball is more like a carrot ball for Jonathan Trott as he gobbles up a four through the covers. Yum yum.
-
From Anon, via text on 81111: "Cook averaged 42.78 before the 2010 Ashes series. Since then his average is 70.63. We have a demi-Bradman as captain!"
-
0413:Eng 239-1
Cook nudges a single round the corner to reach 146 not out. He has made 150 six times in Test matches and twice converted them into doubles. His highest score? 294 big ones against India at Edgbaston last year.
-
From Dibs in Bebington, via text on 81111: "Cook is in the company of greats on all of the lists so surely that makes him a great (plus he smashed the Aussies in the last Ashes)."
-
0409:Eng 238-1
Boycott storms into the TMS commentary box, clumsily trips over a water bottle and repeats his assertion that England are going to bat all day. A thick outside edge gets Trott two to third man. Plenty more chat about Cook's claims to greatness....
-
From Lucy in Oxford, via text on 81111: "I am with Anna [0359] - great cricket and beautiful pairing in all senses!"
-
0406:Eng 235-1
Trott unveils a whole new sets of blocks and leaves before pushing the last ball of Ojha's over through the covers for two.
-
Andrew Samson, BBC Test Match Special statistician"Cook has just gone past 500 runs in the series, only the third Englishman to score 500 in a series in India. The others are Ken Barrington and Mike Gatting."
-
0403:Eng 233-1
At last, a boundary, and it's a peach as Cook drives through the covers where Tendulkar quickly gives up the chase on this rapid outfield. Then a beauty from Ojha spins sharply past Cook's outside edge.
-
0400:Eng 227-1
Cook steals a single and the strike with a push to mid-on. The new ball is due but with his spinners offering good control Dhoni's not going to take it yet.
-
From Nigel, TMS inbox: "In meeting all day in Bangalore today, no mention of the cricket this morning from my Indian colleagues!"
-
0359:Eng 226-1
Steady on Anna, it's a bit early for that kind of chat, isn't it? We have a veritable avalanche of runs in Ashwin's latest, as Trott sweeps for two, then repeats the shot two ball later to reach 27 from 102 balls.
-
Anna (not only admiring the team aesthetically but also able to understand the rules of the game) in Woking, via text on 81111: "For all the ladies awake at this unworldly hour - has there ever been an opening pair more easy on the eye than Cook & Compton?"
-
0356:Eng 221-1
Ojha is brought into the attack in place of Zaheer but the result is the same - a maiden, with Trott smothering any spin, of which there was very little. I really hope my cabbie isn't watching this or he'll be put off cricket for life!
-
Edward Pearce on Twitter: "Cook is the ONLY man in England's top 10 for: top score, highest average & most: runs, runs in a series, 50s, 100s- best ever?"
-
0353:
Ashwin to Cook - maiden. We've had five runs in seven overs so far this morning. Talk to me folks...
-
Alistair Bruce-Ball, BBC Radio 5 liveOn Twitter: "Morning all, we've started in Kolkata, England want to bat, bat & bat some more, strains of Jerusalem drift across ground from England band."
-
0350:Eng 221-1
Cook is gifted his first run of the day by the absence of a mid-on as he pushes down to Zlatan Sharma at long-on.
-
Oliver Doward, BBC Sport"Very sparse crowd this morning after first two days saw the biggest Test crowd at Eden for many a year, clearly not much appetite among the Bengali faithful for a second helping of a Cook run fest."
-
Jonathan in Iqaluit, TMS inbox: "In answer, yes, I think we consider him great after breaking and setting the records he did yesterday. If he retired at the end of this Test surely he would be classified as great?"
-
0348:APPEAL - NOT OUT- Eng 219-1
Cook misses a sweep at Ashwin and there's a huge appeal from the India bowler and close catchers. Umpire Dharmasena says no becuase Cook was outside the line when ball struck pad. He hasn't quite settled yet has the England skip. All this talk of greatness proving a bit of a distraction?
-
George Gardner on Twitter: "I'm sure this has been pointed out before but Ishant Sharma doesn't half look like an Indian Zlatan Ibrahimovic."
-
0344:Eng 219-1
Ashwin to Trott, single to mid-on. On the way in this morning, my cabbie (who knows precious little about cricket) asked me if I expected today to be "entertaining". I did my best to explain that if Trott and Cook bat all day that wouldn't be the first word that springs to mind.
-
Tom Elliott, TMS inbox: "The greatest innings I have seen Cook play was his 235 vs Australia in the 2010 Ashes - I had the privilege of watching first hand with the Barmy Army! He was immense in that innings and totally demoralised the Aussie attack."
-
0338:Eng 218-1
Trott was disappointed not to contribute to England's win in Mumbai and according to Aggers is hell-bent on scoring a big one today. He's biding his time early on, looking out for any sign of swing from Zaheer Khan. Just a single off the over, tucked wide of mid-on.
-
0335:Eng 217-1
Ashwin delivers the first over of the day and the England scoreboard ticks round to 217 with a leg bye off Trott's pads. Cook defends the rest of the over, his bat gun barrel straight, his head still. He quite fancies a double.
-
0327:
Its easy to forget that is wasn't so long ago that Cook was fighting for his place in this England side. Since scoring a century against Pakistan at the Oval in August 2010 to end a run of eight innings without reaching 30, Cook has scored 11 hundreds in 28 Tests at an average of 68.53.
So where would you rank him among England's greatest batsmen? Which was his greatest innings? Is "great" the right word or can we only use that at the end of a player's career? Get in touch via email to tms@bbc.co.uk with For Sam Sheringham as your subject, tweet us to #bbccricket or send a text to 81111 (UK).
-
0323:
There's plenty of reaction to Cookie's capers smeared all over this website. BBC Cricket correspondent Jonathan Agnew refers to him as England's Jacques Kallis in his post-match column, former skipper Michael Vaughan says Cook is well on the way to becoming a great of the game, while Cook's opening partner Nick Compton enjoyed the "best seat in the house" for his captain's "amazing" knock.
-
Vic Marks, BBC Test Match Special"Cook bats the same every time, he's a wonderful run-making machine. All the great batsmen work to a system and his mind is so uncluttered he's never ruffled and goes about his business in his usual way. He was dropped once and had a tiny patch where he played and missed a couple of times and edged that catch to Pujara but otherwise he goes on and on, and he bats more fluently as he gets older. He's got 136 out of 216 and goodness knows how many he will get. I don't think he can ever have been in better form."
-
0318:
England will resume this morning on 216-1 in reply to India's 316 all out, with Cook on 136 not out and Jonathan Trott on 21. If the tourists can bat all day, they will be well on the way to a 2-1 lead with one match to play.
-
0314:
I refer, of course, to Alastair Cook - England cricket captain extraordinaire, possessor of unimaginative nickname and serial smasher of batting records. In the course of yesterday's play, Cook became the first England batsman to score 23 Test centuries, surpassed the legendary Sachin Tendulkar to become the youngest player to 7,000 runs and scored his fifth century in as many Tests as captain. By the end of next week, Cook has a very good chance of becoming the first England skipper to win a series in India since 1985. In any other year he'd be a SPOTY shoo-in.
-
0310:
Is it too late to reopen the shortlist for Sports Personality of the Year? I know a man who goes by the name of Chef would quite like a piece of the action.
Related to this story
Live Scores - India v England
- England beat India by 7 wickets
- India: 316 & 247 (84.4 overs)
- England: 523 & 41-3 (12.1 overs)
- Venue: Kolkata
England 2nd Innings
| View full scorecard | |||
| Cook | st Dhoni | b Ashwin | 1 |
| Compton | not out | 9 | |
| Trott | lbw | b Ojha | 3 |
| Pietersen | c Dhoni | b Ashwin | 0 |
| Bell | not out | 28 | |
| Extras | 0 | ||
| Total | for 3 | 41 | |
Cricket Tweets
What are tweets?-
Desperately sad to learn of death of Rory Morrison (48) A familiar TMS Radio4 voice for many years. Lovely man @Aggerscricket 11 Jun 13
-
When Freddie met Fiery. Catch up with @flintoff11 speaking to Geoff Boycott in the "Ashes Legends" series @bbc5live - http://t.co/09M3w3w7QL @tmsproducer 11 Jun 13
-
Glad Boycott's Uncle Algie got a mention in the Ashes Legends interview. Just surprised his mum didn't, nor her pinny @AlisonMitchell 11 Jun 13
-
The first mention of "uncovered pitches" from Geoffrey @bbc5live. Timed at 3 mins 20 secs. I lose sweepstake. I went for 20 seconds @tmsproducer 11 Jun 13
-
When Freddie met Geoffrey. Starting now Andrew Flintoff in conversation with Geoff Boycott @bbc5live part of "Flintoff's Ashes Legends" @tmsproducer 11 Jun 13
~RS~q~RS~v=~RS~z~RS~41~RS~)