Two Tests in, the dominant plotline of England's series in India could not be more clear.
This is a contest defined almost entirely by the two teams' relative successes in playing spin.
it was England's batsmen sent spiralling, losing seven wickets for 71 in their pivotal first innings. In Mumbai,
India lost all but one of their 20 wickets
to Monty Panesar and Graeme Swann.
Playing top-flight spin on turning pitches, as those struggling batsmen can testify, remains one of the great challenges in the game. So how to succeed where so many have failed?
Graham Thorpe's record against the turning ball is better than any England batsman of the last 20 years. In the winter of 2001-02, when England won series in both Pakistan and Sri Lanka, he hit 553 runs at an average of 61.44, including two centuries; in Tests overall, his average on the subcontinent was identical to his record on more familiar surfaces.
Now the England and Wales Cricket Board's national lead batting coach, Thorpe has responsibility for schooling the new generation of players.
This is what he tells them.
Use your feet
Thorpe's key tutors in his own development were former Essex and England skipper Keith Fletcher, on his early 'A' tours, and then senior team coach Duncan Fletcher.
The second Fletcher expanded on the preferred theory of his namesake. The magic word? 'Press'.
England's recent record in India
India 1-2 England
India 3-0 England
India 1-0 England
India 1-1 England
India 1-0 England
Thorpe explains: "Think of that as a very powerful front-foot movement that allows you to move towards the pitch of the ball if it's full, or, if it's just short of a length, to get very deep in your crease by pushing back off your front foot and playing as late as you can.
"There is a difference between a press, which is a movement that leads to something else, and a plant - a big old heavy step with the front foot that leaves you stuck.
"You should have momentum going over your front leg, so that there is a little tension in your front thigh. That bend in the front leg allows you to push back quickly if the ball is short enough.
"The way it looks can vary between players. Graham Gooch used to be slightly more upright than me; I like to crouch a little. But his front foot would have been doing something very similar to mine.
"He was effective off front and back foot, and he was also able to sweep."
Use your brain
That's the first part of the theory. Putting it into practice requires a second set of skills.
"It all sounds very easy, but in the heat of the battle people have to make decisions," says Thorpe. "And that brings in game-plans, concentration, real clarity in your method and a balance of aggression.
"Some players naturally like to be more aggressive in their play. But if you have five fielders around the bat, you have to work out how you can possibly move some of them. Just by showing intent, a captain might start moving some of those players back. You have to work out the risk-reward side of it.
"You need real belief in your method. You can see that when players first go in - if they have their footwork and real belief, you can see a calmness about them."
Select your shot
The best players in the world are self-evidently capable against almost any attack. Jacques Kallis, for example, averages 63 on subcontinent pitches, Ricky Ponting 62 and Hashim Amla 84.
"People say England are not great, and there is truth in that. Two people got hundreds in the second Test but most of the others got out cheaply. I think India got lulled into thinking England were poor in Ahmedabad. They thought, 'the more it turns the quicker we'll beat them'. But the worse a pitch, the more it seams or spins, and that levels the sides up"
"If they do play a big shot, you can clearly see the method in what they're trying to do and the reasons behind it," says Thorpe.
"Pre-meditated isn't good, because it reduces you to one shot. What I used to say to myself was, if the ball goes into that area, I might sweep it. If he throws this one up, I might try to hit him over the top. But if he didn't get it into that area, I was able to bail out and play another shot because of the position I'd moved my feet into.
"I restricted myself on certain shots. You knew that the probability of risk would be too great against certain bowlers.
"You also need different tempos during the day's play. You could have an initial period where you might have to get rid of a few fielders from around the bat - a risk that, once dealt with, you could settle into a period of play where you didn't have to take as many risks.
"Work out where your boundary areas are going to be, and work out what your tick-over shots are going to be."
Pressurise the bowler
Great players of spin, like West Indian Brian Lara and Sri Lankan Mahela Jayawardene, would never let an opposition bowler settle. They might only take singles at times, or the occasional two, but the initiative is never ceded.
"You have to be active and busy, and show intent," advises Thorpe.
"Intent is not just charging out of your crease. It can be body language at the point of the bowler's release; you can pretend to come down the pitch, to put some pressure on them.
"Mike Gatting used to do it very well - he would duck his shoulder in his stance, as if he were coming down the track, and when the bowler would then drop it a little short he could step back and put it away.
"Be confident in your ability. Be calm in defence; have clarity about your acting strokes.
"You have to practise watching spinners a great deal. You can often pick up little clues from how the ball may rotate. You may pick it out of the hand; if not, you might guess from the trajectory of the ball. You might be able to work it out from the way it is moving through the air."
Understand the pitch
In Ahmedabad the turn was slow and low; in Mumbai, sharp from the start. Subcontinent pitches will spin more than English pitches, but it isn't a simple equation.
"The difference in how the pitch will play in first and second innings can require you to have two different ways of playing," says Thorpe.
"On the first day, when the track is shiny, the ball might skid on. Then you want to be hitting more down the ground; you wouldn't want to be hitting a sweep shot on day one, or if you were, you might play a fine sweep as a lower-risk shot, if you were confident in playing it.
"Second innings, when the turn is sharper, it might be much harder to hit the ball down the ground. Then you need to be good at moving your feet to get to the pitch, or you then have the sweep - but you need to practise it really well for it to work."
Push yourself relentlessly
Thorpe spent the first part of the winter at the national academy in Loughborough before travelling to India with the performance programme.
To simulate turning pitches on the indoor surface at home, he would create rough in the nets using pimpled rubber discs and cut-up chunks of carpet.
He has even glued elastic bands onto cricket balls to create over-exaggerated turn and bounce ("it makes it crystal clear to the player that he can't just plop his feet and hands halfway forward") and studied the technique of Olympic fencers to see how another predominantly sideways sport produces such quick foot movement.
"We will use anything that might have relevance to a cricket shot," he explains.
"You make the work more challenging by adding in more and more. Make a player aware of what they can and can't get away with.
"I might insist on target practice - one area on off-side, one on leg-side, mid-on, mid-off, and they're only allowed to hit those areas. No hitting over the top, no sweeping - purely for a practice drill, purely for footwork.
"A player has to work out for himself the danger and rewards for what he's doing. You're on your own out there - no coach can stand next to you out in the middle.
"Watch the very best players and see what they do. If you take 2% here and 2% there, that can make a huge difference. You can never stand still."