India v England: Pragyan Ojha leaves tourists facing defeat
|
First Test, day three, Ahmedabad |
|
India 521-8 dec v England 191 & 111-0 |
England are facing defeat in the first Test against India after another inept attempt at dealing with spin.
Replying to India's 521-8, the tourists were shot out for 191 in Ahmedabad as left-armer Pragyan Ojha took 5-45.
Matt Prior showed some fight with 48, but England's pitiful effort was epitomised by Kevin Pietersen and Ian Bell falling to successive Ojha balls.
The tourists at least fared better following on, reaching 111-0, but are 219 short of making India bat again.
Test Match Special analysis
"England are still in a huge hole and the odds against them saving this match are very long, but they'll be a bit more cheerful tonight. They've shown it's possible to score runs out there if you keep your head. Earlier today, we thought it might finish on the third day - now we're not sure if it will finish on the fourth."
Openers Alastair Cook and Nick Compton mixed defence with endeavour in batting through an elongated evening session, but the damage done in the first innings leaves England staring at a seventh loss in 12 Tests this year.
Just as in the 3-0 Test series defeat by Pakistan and the World Twenty20 in Sri Lanka, England looked baffled by high-quality slow bowling, caught between shotless defence and reckless attack.
The dismissals of Pietersen and Bell were England versus spin in microcosm. First, Pietersen's open face was beaten by a ripping delivery that took out his middle stump then, inexplicably, Bell charged his first ball and was caught at deep mid-off.
Ravichandran Ashwin finished with 3-80 as India's probing spinners made a mockery of England's decision to field only one specialist slow bowler in Graeme Swann.
But the threat posed by seam bowlers Umesh Yadav and Zaheer Khan should also worry Cook's men, as both looked more dangerous than England's pace trio of James Anderson, Stuart Broad and Tim Bresnan.
The skiddy Yadav extracted life from the slow pitch, while Zaheer found the reverse swing that eluded England. Yadav trapped Samit Patel lbw, with Zaheer doing the same to Broad, although both looked to be going down the leg side.
Bell's subcontintental struggles
In six Tests away from home in 2012, Ian Bell has scored just 134 runs at an average of 13.40:
0 & 4 v Pakistan, Dubai
29 & 3 v Pakistan, Abu Dhabi
5 & 10 v Pakistan, Dubai
52 & 13 v Sri Lanka, Galle
18 & DNB v Sri Lanka, Colombo
0 v India, Ahmedabad
On both occasions Prior was the man watching on from the other end, and it was he, along with Cook, who looked the best equipped of England's batsmen to deal with spin on a turning wicket in Ahmedabad.
The wicketkeeper offered one chance to deep square leg when he pulled a full toss to Zaheer, but after that looked comfortable driving, cutting and sweeping.
He shared stands of 47 with Bresnan and 43 with the aggressive Broad, before being bowled trying to drive Ojha to become the last wicket to fall.
Cook and Compton, following Prior's example, then batted 38 overs to have India retreating for the first time in the match.
Cook, who looked accomplised in the first innings before edging a drive off Ashwin to slip, was again adept at judging length.
He survived a strong lbw shout from Ojha, but regularly cut through the off side on his way to an unbeaten 74.
Debutant Compton was more circumspect than his captain, showing all the application and determination evident during his prolific season for Somerset in poking and nudging his way to 33.
Despite the fightback, England's horrific first-innings effort means that, after only three days, defeat seems inevitable.
Comments
Jump to comments paginationAll posts are reactively-moderated and must obey the house rules.
More from Cricket
Elsewhere on the BBC
-
Working Lives Ecuador
The BBC's Michelle Fleury meets five very different people who live and work in Quito
-
~RS~q~RS~v=~RS~z~RS~22~RS~)

Comment number 115.
Davey Bones18th November 2012 - 10:48
All those vociferous calls to bring back Pietersen and the continual slagging off of whoever was playing in his place must be embarrassing those posters now. One decent innings from Pietersen and we would have saved this match easily but he let us down again.
Link to this (Comment number 115)
Comment number 114.
Bill Walker18th November 2012 - 10:23
Much as it pains me to say it, the Boycott method of occupying the crease seems to be the best bet out here. Straight bat defence, no flashing blades or charging down the pitch, and wait for the occasional bad ball. It makes for extremely boring cricket, but when you're under fire, stay in the bunker.
Link to this (Comment number 114)
Comment number 113.
sirGreenmantle18th November 2012 - 10:21
Good to have KP back. Left arm spinners get a go and he gets horribly out. It's like he's never been away.
Not much comfort for England though, plumping against most advice for a high maintenance No' 4 of very little brain. Some thought he couldn't get worse than when averaging 11 against Pakistan in the UAE. Watch on. What is the point? Get Bairstow in.
Link to this (Comment number 113)
Comment number 112.
ambuya18th November 2012 - 10:04
Does England have, and if not why not, a national training centre like the FA does, where pitches can be prepared which exactly match those of the next tour country? Do they have bowling machines which exactly mimic in style and variation, the bowlers of the next tour country? Do they have psychiatrists....
Link to this (Comment number 112)
Comment number 111.
DrCajetanCoelho18th November 2012 - 9:18
Cook has shown that he possesses the right ingredients to handle the Indian challenge. In Prior England has a proven stalwart who knows his doctrine for the number seven slot. Matt did well in the first innings shepherding the lower order batters against some hostile bowling from India's Pragyan and Ashwin. Hearty congratulations to centurion Alastair Cook. Wonderful batting.
Dr. Cajetan Coelho
Link to this (Comment number 111)
Comments 5 of 115