England v South Africa, second Test, day one, Headingley as it happened

South Africa dominate day one of the second Test against England at Headingley, making 262-5 as Alviro Petersen hits a century.

2 August 2012 Last updated at 19:48 GMT

Get involved

To get involved contact us in any of the following ways

Send a comment:

The BBC may edit your comments and not all emails will be published.
Your comments may be published on any BBC media worldwide.

Terms and conditions

As it happened

  1. 1943: 
    Commentary

    Well then, that was quite a day, with the drama beginning right at the toss, which seems a long time ago now. Those late wickets were a boost for England, but South Africa still had the better of the play. I'll be back tomorrow to see if England's fightback continues. Thanks for your company.

  2.   
    BBC Test Match Special's Geoff BoycottContributor

    "I'd have batted first and I also didn't understand why they left Swann out, he's the best spinner in the world. I'm trying to work out why they fielded first, maybe they were worried about Steyn, maybe they felt they needed to take some early wickets to put South Africa under pressure."

  3.   
    BBC Test Match Special's Vic MarksContributor

    "There has been so much talk since the Oval Test about how England are going to get rid of Smith, Amla, Kallis etc. Petersen is the man who has held the innings together despite that little flurry. Those two wickets will cheer England up a bit. Not to get a wicket in the morning was a blow. They've clawed a bit back but I still put South Africa on top."

  4. 1933: 
    CLOSE OF PLAY- SA 262-5

    The shadows are lengthening at Headingley, but England were quick enough into position to ensure that Broad can sneak one more over in today. Twice he goes past the edge of Petersen, who's batted all day remember, and, just for good measure, he makes it three in a row. When the batsman takes a single to point, Broad gives him a tap on the back to acknowledge the knock he has played, a nice touch. Rudolph negotiates the final two balls, and the players head for home.

  5.   
    BBC Test Match Special's Vic MarksContributor

    "It is the sign of a good side to be strong at the end of a long and frustrating day."

  6. 1928: 
    Commentary- SA 261-5

    Jacques Rudolph is that new man, and he gets a nice cheer from the Headingley crowd in a nod to all the runs he scored for Yorkshire. He's greeted by three slips, two gullys and two men catching on the leg side, but he's able to get a single to get off the mark.

  7.   
    BBC Test Match Special's Vic MarksContributor

    "When you put a side in you're banking on getting them out for under 300."

  8.  
    WICKET- Steyn b Finn 0 (SA 259-5)

    That's too good for Steyn. Finn, in the early evening Leeds sunshine, gets one to hold its line that bowls the night-watchman neck and crop. Some late cheer for England, and a tricky period for the man coming in.

  9. 1922: 
    Commentary- SA 259-4

    Steyn has to face the music, shaping up to Broad with three overs of the day remaining. Steyn can't resist driving at a full one and is lucky not to get an edge, and, when Broad strays down the leg side, the night-watchman gets down the other end.

  10. 1919: 
    Commentary- SA 258-4

    South Africa have employed a night-watchman in the shape of Dale Steyn, but he's at the non-striker's end as Petersen drives Finn down the ground for four.

  11.   
    BBC Test Match Special's Vic MarksContributor

    "It's a wicket England were absolutely desperate for. It has not been their day, that lbw kind of epitomised that, but at least they've got De Villiers."

  12.  
    WICKET- De Villiers b Broad 47 (SA 254-4)

    England finally have a breakthrough. De Villiers, dropped two overs ago, looks to play at ball from Broad that just nips back off the seam, but can only suceed in chopping on to his stumps. The new ball has worked, and England finally have some good fortune.

  13.   
    BBC Test Match Special's Michael VaughanContributor

    "That kind of summs up England's day."

  14.   
    BBC Test Match Special's Phil TufnellContributor

    "It looked dead."

  15.  
    NOT OUT

    Agony for England. For all the money in the world Petersen looked stone dead, but the replays show the ball to be going over top.

  16.  
    UMPIRE REVIEW

    It's Finn sharing the new ball with Broad, how often does James Anderson not get his hands on the new ball? It looks like a good decision though, as Finn gets one to jag back at Petersen. Huge appeal....out! England have the breakthrough. Or do they? We've got a review....

  17.   
    BBC Test Match Special's Michael VaughanContributor

    "Two slips in place, surely get another one in, I can't believe the plan is to bowl short, get it full!"

  18. 1904: 
    DROPPED CATCH- SA 246-3

    It will Stuart Broad will the new nut from the Football Stand End, and he gets the first ball to shoot through along the ground, beating everyone for four byes. Then, when ABDV tries to leave he can't draw his bat away in time, sending the ball towards Anderson at slip. Jimmy shells the one-handed chance. It's tough, but England need to take them. To add insult to injury, the next ball is edged through third man for four.

  19. 1900: 
    Commentary- SA 238-3

    Last over before the new ball, this time it's Finn to Petersen, but the Middlesex man continues with the short stuff. He gets no joy, but at least England can now get their hands on a new cherry.

  20. 1855: 
    Commentary- SA 238-3

    There's only two overs left until the new ball, so you sense this must be Trott's last one. He's driven for a couple by De Villiers, and that must be his lot. Have a rest Trotty.

  21. 1852: 
    Commentary- SA 234-3

    We do have a change, it's Steven Finn from the Kirkstall Lane End, around the wicket. The tall pacer drops his first ball short, and De Villiers hooks hard for four, endangering the health of Ian Bell at a shortish leg gully. This short bowling is a ploy to De Villiers, another bumper is hooked for four, but a final brainrattler climbs sharply and is well played by ABDV.

  22. 1846: 
    Commentary- SA 225-3

    Just a couple from that Trott over, Petersen punching through the covers for a single, then ABDV kicking a leg bye. I sense we could be having a change....

  23.   
    BBC Test Match Special's Michael VaughanContributor

    "The crowd are probably wanting South Africa to score more quickly but they're 1-0 up they're trying to bat once and get a big total and if you do that at Headingley you don't lose the game."

  24. 1843: 
    Commentary- SA 223-3

    Wowzers, that is a lovely shot from De Villiers, who is almost on one knee as he laces Bresnan square through the off side for four. Big Tim's reply is a bumper, but England are looking short of ideas here.

  25.   
    BBC Sport's Mark MitchenerContributor

    "Over in Jamaica, New Zealand have recovered from a shaky start as they look to square the Test series against New Zealand. The Kiwis lost opener BJ Watling for two and Brendon McCullum for a duck, but Martin Guptill and captain Ross Taylor have steadied the ship, adding 63 so far for the third wicket.

    "Meanwhile, 14 wickets fell today at Chester-le-Street where play will resume tomorrow with Australia A on 56-0, chasing 224 to beat Durham."

  26.  
    SMS

    From Cuan, London: "Trott's got as much chance of picking up a wicket as I have of buying a pair of tickets for the 100m final off this Locog website!"

  27. 1840: 
    Commentary- SA 218-3

    Still Trott, who can't draw a stroke from De Villers, a maiden. The crowd are just starting to tail away now, but there's a group down to my right enterntaining themselves with a very long beer snake.

  28. 1836: 
    Commentary- SA 218-3

    The slightest hint of a lapse in Alviro Petersen's concentration draws an inside edge, but there's no luck for England and Bresnan, as the ball runs away for four to fine leg.

  29. 1832: 
    Commentary- SA 213-3

    There really isn't much going on for England at the moment, especially as this South Africa pair are very watchful in defence. Home side can't wait for the new ball.

  30. 1830: 
    Commentary- SA 212-3

    Still Bresnan, who finds a little shape towards Petersen, but he strays too far towards the South Africa opener's pads and is worked to fine leg for four.

  31. 1826: 
    Commentary- SA 208-3

    The trumpeter playing the theme from Only Fools And Horses welcomes Jonathan Trott to the attack as England look to hurry through some overs before the new ball. A minor success for Trott, he gets ABDV to play and miss outside off stump.

  32.   
    BBC Test Match Special's Phil TufnellContributor

    "It's the old adage, what's the best way to take 20 wickets and that's got to be with five bowlers in my opinion."

  33. 1822: 
    Commentary- SA 206-3

    That Petersen ton came in the last over before a drinks break. Bresnan continues afterwards, getting a hint of swing in to De Villiers, who dabs for a single, then when Bresnan drops short, Petersen hooks perfectly for four. Poor from Big Tim that, he should have learnt that you get no joy dropping short on this pitch.

  34.  
    SMS

    Em, via text on 81111: "Re the rest of my text (1703): "Belting it down"? "Hard"? "Heavy"? Utter nonsense. Many's the time I've been in British rain that makes this feel like a dripping tap. Hope this one gets through."

  35. 1815: 
    CENTURY- 100 FOR ALVIRO PETERSEN

    Broad drops short and Petersen hooks hard in front of square leg for four, taking him to his fourth Test hundred. He's also the fourth South African to post a ton in this series. The man who dropped him earlier on, Alastair Cook, has his hands on his knees at short cover, his head bowed.

  36.  
    SMS

    From Andrew from Dorset: "Whatever happens in this game, Taylor has to be given six games to prove that he can play at this level. For the record I think he can."

  37. 1811: 
    Commentary- SA 197-3

    Petersen breaks the shackles somewhat by pushing Bresnan for a couple through the covers, then a single dropped on the leg side takes the opener to 96.

  38.  
    Commentary

    From Fred Bloggs, TMS inbox: "Having heard the MCC/ICC/umpire view on ‘distracting’ could not a batsman now complain that Dale Steyn's hair is a distraction as he bowls so can he be dead-balled from now on please? I remember the furore in Australia when Dean Jones complained that Curtly Ambrose's wristband was distracting."

  39.  
    Twitter

    From joeblackers15: "Ryan Sidebottom and Carles Puyol have a distinctive similarity."

  40. 1809: 
    Commentary- SA 194-3

    It certainly can't be said that England's bowling isn't accurate here, it's just that South Africa are patient enough to absorb the pressure the home side are applying. Broad is on the money to ABDV, a maiden. Only one run in four overs.

  41.  
    Commentary

    From Mike G, Ferndown, TMS inbox: "Regarding the saga of the bails falling off, It occurs to me that; should the bowler complete his run with the bail on the ground and the batsman hit a run and a fielder returns the ball with the intention of hitting the stumps at the end where the ‘bail’ remains on the ground, how then, if the ball hit the stumps could the batsman be declared ‘out’?"

    We suspect the entire "Finn's bails" saga will feature heavily when John Holder joins TMS during Friday's lunch interval for the ever-popular "Ask the Umpire" slot. Email your questions to tms@bbc.co.uk (marking it "Ask the Umpire") or tweet producer Adam Mountford @tmsproducer

  42. 1804: 
    Commentary- SA 194-3

    If you're not sat in the Western Terrace, apologies for my frequent references, but the window of my commentary box rather cuts off a lot of the ground, leaving the Western as one of my main sources of entertainment. This time, a man wearing what looks to be only his underpants is up and singing as Petersen plays back a maiden from Bresnan.

  43.  
    Commentary

    From John, TMS inbox: "Re: dead balls - It appears to me that there are three aspects to this. Firstly, Finn needs to sort out his delivery stride so he isn't disturbing the stumps. Secondly, the umpires are entitled to call 'dead ball' if they believe breaking the stumps is off putting for the batsmen. Thirdly, by subsequently hitting two 'dead balls' for four, the SA batsmen themselves showed they weren't distracted."

  44. 1800: 
    Commentary- SA 194-3

    More big-batted defence from ABDV, this time to deny the best efforts of Stuart Broad. When the skies are even relatively clear, England look a spinner short of an attack.

  45.  
    Commentary

    From Dr Jim Provan, TMS inbox: "Obvious lookalike - Bumble Lloyd and Count von Count from Sesame Street!"

  46. 1757: 
    Commentary- SA193-3

    You have to say that we have entered another one of those phases where you can't see England getting a wicket. There's excitement on the Western Terrace, as Steven Finn is cheered for signing autographs. Bresnan can find no way past De Villiers. It's a maiden, but that bat looks as wide as a door.

  47.  
    Contributor

    More from the MCC statement on Finn: "A precedent may have been set but it remains to be seen whether dead ball will be called on each occasion that this happens for the remainder of the match. Unlike some other Laws, there is no specified warning procedure for this situation. MCC's Laws sub-comittee will discuss the matter at its next meeting and will work closely with ICC on issuing guidance to umpires.

    What the umpires feel is distracting to the batsman is entirely subjective, but Davis was within his rights to signal dead ball if he was sure that Smith was indeed distracted."

  48. 1753: 
    Commentary- SA 193-3

    The last of England's quartet of pace bowlers to bowl after the delay, Stuart Broad, is recalled to the attack at the Football Stand End. He has only two men on the leg side, with one of the seven on the off posted at short cover. Broad keeps a good off-stump line and, when De Villiers stretches to drive, the ball falls short of Alastair Cook at that short cover position.

  49.  
    Commentary

    From Helena in Cambridge, TMS inbox: "Could you find out if the Main Balcony has a roof, please? I am packing for my trip to Headingley on Saturday and I need to know how much wet weather gear to pack! Thanks - Public Service Broadcasting at its best!"

  50.  
    Contributor

    MCC statement regarding Steven Finn incident: "Jeff Crowe, the match referee, confirmed to MCC that Finn had broken the wicket at least three times prior to this specific incident. Both batsmen complained that it was a distraction and Finn was told to move over. The umpires decided that if it happened again they would call dead ball. It did and so Davis calledit under 23.4 (b) (vi)."

  51. 1747: 
    Commentary- SA 193-3

    Tim Bresnan replaces Anderson here at the Kirkstall Lane End. In these brighter conditions, he can expect less help than the assistance knocking around before the rain break. He will get even less help if he continues to bang in it half-way down, Petersen gobbling up the chance to cut for four.

  52.   
    BBC Test Match Special's Vic MarksContributor

    "In a funny sort of way he's got less to think about, Andrew Strauss, he's got his four fast bowlers so it's just a question of rotating them, they all do their various shifts."

  53. 1743: 
    Commentary- SA 188-3

    You have to say that AB de Villiers has more than a bit of a look of German F1 driver Sebastian Vettel. Cricketing lookalikes on a postcard, or better yet, on Twitter using the hashtag #bbcricket, email tms@bbc.co.uk or text 81111. Finn is looking less threatening here and, as if to prove my point, ABDV effortlessly drives through the covers for four.

  54. 1739: 
    Commentary- SA 180-3

    The trumpeter strikes up with a blast of 'Yellow Submarine' as De Villiers drives Anderson down the ground for a single. From the last ball of the over, Petersen edges, but it falls short of Alastair Cook at second slip.

  55. 1735: 
    Commentary- SA 178-3

    What a shot this is, the sort us mere mortals can only dream of being able to play. Finn is just a fraction short, but De Villiers hops on to the back foot, playing a square drive with one knee in the air. Four of the best. If I tried to play a shot like that I'd fall on my stumps.

  56.   
    BBC Test Match Special's Vic MarksContributor

    "I think I'd want a forward short-leg in for De Villiers. I'm pining for Swann now, if only for my own personal entertainment, although England will be pining for him if they get one more because there is a little phase of left-handers after this."

  57. 1731: 
    Commentary- SA 172-3

    It certainly is brightening up now, allowing me to gaze into the distance and see some rolling fields. That's proper Yorkshire. Anderson is bowling a good spell here, searching for that big wicket of Petersen. The Lancashire man is getting some shape into the right-hander, but Petersen is solid in defence.

  58. 1727: 
    Commentary- SA 172-3

    Finn overpitches to ABDV, a full toss that is played down the ground for a couple. The lanky Middlesex man is not doing that again though, sending down a trio of shorter balls that do not trouble De Villiers.

  59.  
    SMS

    From John: "[Re: 1705] We haven't gone anywhere. The entire west stand went to the pub, but we're back now!"

  60. 1723: 
    Commentary- SA 169-3

    The BBC had requested to speak with the umpires at the close of play about the Finn/Smith/Davis dead ball incident, but that request has been declined. We are, however, expecting a statement from the ICC and MCC shortly. Anderson is full to De Villiers, who is happy to play back a maiden.

  61. 1719: 
    Commentary- 169-3

    Petersen is hurried here, a brainrattler of a bouncer from Finn is top-edged for four over the head over the slips, bouncing just once on the way to the fence. Finn says nothing, but stands with his hands on his hips and thrusts his tounge into his cheek, as if he's trying to hide a ping pong ball in his mouth.

  62. 1715: 
    Commentary- SA 165-3

    It's James Anderson bowling from the Kirkstall Lane End, running in to an accompaniment of "Jimmy, Jimmy, Jimmy, Jimmy Anderson", from the Western Terrace. Petersen takes a single to square leg, then De Villiers covers up in defence.

  63. 1711: 
    Commentary- SA 164-3

    After a single scrambled fine on the leg side, Finn has AB de Villiers groping at a ball that is wide of off stump. Away to my right over Bramley (at least, I think it's Bramley), there are some fluffy white clouds that suggest a hint of sunshine, but it's still a little gloomy in Headingley.

  64. 1707: 
    Commentary

    We can actually go all the way to 1930 tonight, so still lots of cricket to be played. Steven Finn has the ball at the Football Stand End, Alviro Petersen, 76 not out, is on strike.

  65. 1705: 
    Commentary

    The stands might be half-empty, but a big cheer greets England when Andrew Strauss leads his team onto the field. This could be quite a period of play, conditions are still good for bowling.

  66.   
    BBC Test Match Special's Michael VaughanContributor

    "South Africa have still got the same focus but they've just got that little bit of 'let's just make it happen,' it's a more relaxed approach and that's all down to Kirsten."

  67. 1703: 
    Commentary

    Not only is he bowling with a medicine ball, but Steven Finn is now doing press-ups. I'm not sure if any spectators left during that rain break, but I'd say the ground is about half-full at the moment. Kevin Pietersen appears, wearing shades. Unnecessary.

  68.  
    BBC Sport's Jamie Lillywhite at HeadingleyContributor

    "Steven Finn is the only England player on the field at present, he has just been sending a few deliveries down with a ball the size of a miniature football. Scientists have probably devised a reason for this, but I am not sure the late, great Fred Trueman of this parish would approve."

  69.  
    SMS

    Em, North Stand, via text on 81111: "*text missing* tap. Stephan, as a British person I expect a better attitude to rain from you."

    Really keen to know what that missing text is. What have I done wrong???

  70.  
    BBC Sport's Jamie Lillywhite at HeadingleyContributor

    "England bowling coach David Saker has a very distinctive gait, and he takes a solo stroll out to the centre to assess the conditions. He will no doubt feel a little lighter on the shoulders after those three wickets." 

  71. 1654: 
    Commentary

    We're awaiting confirmation, but we think play can go on until 1900 tonight. With the light the way it is, I'd pretty surprised if we make it that far, though.

  72. 1647: 
    Commentary

    And the news is this. We will resume at 1710 BST, with only three overs lost from the day. That means there's 35 overs left in the day.

  73. 1646: 
    Commentary

    The umpires have inspected and, down below me, they are now reporting back to Andy Flower with the verdict. We should have some news very soon....

  74. 1643: 
    Commentary

    Andy Flower is out on the ground too. He rubs his hand on the grass like a proud gardener checking the health of his lawn.

  75. 1642: 
    Commentary

    Umpires Steve Davis and Rod Tucker are on their way for an inspection, followed by a man carrying a stick and some white paint.

  76. 1641: 
    Commentary

    We now have something of a mopping-up operation under way. A blotter is moving up and down the edge of the square and all the sheets have been removed. All that remains is the white wheelie covers that protect the wicket.

  77. 1635: 
    Commentary

    Good news. The rain has relented and the covers are coming off, so it looks like we could be getting more cricket again soon. It's still quite grey around Headingley though, so we may not get through to the close without further disruption.

  78.   
    BBC Sport's Mark MitchenerContributor

    "Over in Jamaica, West Indies have won the toss and elected to field in the second Test against New Zealand. The Kiwis, who trail 1-0 in the two-Test series, are without former skipper Daniel Vettori and batsman Daniel Flynn because of injury, while slightly surprisingly, veteran seamer (and walking wicket) Chris Martin has been left out. West Indies bring in paceman Tino Best for the injured Ravi Rampaul."

  79. 1605: 
    Commentary

    I'm afraid I have no good news to bring you, it's raining hard, and it looks like it will be for some time. I'm going to pop off and do a sunshine dance - I have literally no idea what you're going to do without me.

  80. 1601: 
    Commentary

    From Josh, TMS inbox: "That Kallis is rubbish, I always said so..."

  81. 1557: 
    Commentary

    I'm no weather man, but I feel I have confidence to update the severity of this situation. It's belting down. The rain is so heavy, the groundstaff have called for the Big White Sheet. You know there's problems when they have to get the BWS out.

  82.  
    Twitter

    Laura Mills on Twitter: "Currently bewildered at how we've managed to get Amla out for 9 and Kallis out for 19. Something funny's going on."

  83. 1551: 
    Commentary

    It's raining heavier now, and more sheets have been bought onto the ground. I think we could be in for quite a delay.

  84. 1543: 
    Commentary

    More sheets onto the ground now, they are covering most of the square. I've heard rumours that the rain could be here for the rest of the day. You have to say that it's come at a disappointing time for England, who were just getting back into this game. Much better session for the home side though.

  85.   
    BBC Test Match Special's Phil TufnellContributor

    "England would have been thinking 'crikey what have we got to do,' they'll be happy with that after that first session."

  86. 1538: 
    RAIN STOPS PLAY- SA 163-3

    As I suspected, we are getting a drop of the wet stuff, and it's heavy enough to force the players off. The white wheelie covers are on the track, with green sheets being unfurled to protect the bowlers' run-ups. With the timing of the delay, we're having a slightly early tea.

  87.   
    BBC Test Match Special's Shaun PollockContributor

    "Since Smith it's been all right handers so the bowlers have been able to settle into their lines which does often help with keeping things tight."

  88.  
    SMS

    From Dave: "Minus points to Mr Knight [see 1523] as he has forgotten all about Mr Sobers."

  89. 1537: 
    Commentary- SA 163-3

    These are still great conditions for bowling, but Anderson gives De Villiers a free long hop to get off the mark with a back-foot drive for four. Movement in the crowd - fans reaching for jackets and umbrellas tells me there is rain in the air. Luckily, we're on the cusp of tea, so we may not lose too much play.

  90. 1532: 
    Commentary- SA 158-3

    So, finally, AB de Villiers is called upon to have a bat in this series. A Petersen single brings him on strike to Broad, but he may not have long to survive. I really wouldn't be surprised if we're off for bad light soon. Broad gets excited when ABDV gets an inside edge, but it trickles into the leg side.

  91.   
    BBC Test Match Special's Shaun PollockContributor

    "England have struck again and conditions are working for them."

  92.  
    WICKET- Kallis ct Cook b Anderson 19 (SA 157-2)

    Now then, is the door ajar? England are making inroads in the gloom, and this time it's the prized wicket of Jacques Kallis. The burly Proteas legend aims a cut at a wide one from Anderson, but can only get a thick edge towards Alastair Cook at second slip. The vice-skip, who shelled Petersen earlier today, moves low to his right and completes the catch just above the turf. Good snaffle, huge wicket. Game on.

  93.  
    SMS

    From Mike Ashcroft, Kenya: "Not only the greatest all-rounder of all time, with 12,000 runs at 57 (which compares favourably with the best batsmen) and 300 wickets, could Kallis arguably be the least considered best cricketer of all time?"

  94.   
    BBC Test Match Special's Shaun PollockContributor

    "It's getting very dark here now. You'd think if they had floodlights here they would be on now."

  95. 1523: 
    Commentary- SA 157-2

    The Western Terrace is coming alive now. A 'snake' made from empty beer glasses is being made and an inflatable palm tree is being thrown around. Broad tries a couple of bumpers to Petersen, then is worked to square leg for four. Very, very gloomy at Headingley.

  96.  
    Commentary

    From Patrick Knight, TMS inbox: "I am getting bored of all the talk of 'is Kallis one of the greatest all-rounders of all time?' He is not only the greatest all-rounder but surely has to be regarded as one of the greatest cricketers, being compared with Tendulkar, Bradman, Lara, Holding, Marshall, Richards, Ponting, Walsh, McGrath etc."

  97. 1519: 
    APPEAL - NOT OUT- SA 155-2

    When it's cloudy, call for the King of the Swingers, and England do just that. James Anderson replaces Tim Bresnan here at the Kirkstall Lane End, appealing without success when Petersen is hit on the pads. Petersen prods, Kallis guides and the tourists take three from the over. Incidentally, the King of the Swingers is one of my all-time favourite Disney songs. The Jungle Book is ace.

  98.  
    Twitter

    From CharlieEve5: "Kallis is looking ominously good right now."

  99. 1515: 
    Commentary- SA 152-2

    Down in the Western Terrace, there's a group of blokes all dressed as Jack Russell. The wicketkeeper, not the dog. I can't see if they've got keeping gloves on, but one that has just stood up certainly has a pair of red gauntlets. Unenventul over from Stuart Broad, just one from it.

  100. 1512: 
    Commentary- SA 151-2

    For all this talk of cloud cover and England having a spring in their step, we must remember that Jacques Kallis is arguably the greatest all-rounder ever to don a pair of whites. First he plays the dreamiest of straight drives, then whips through mid-wicket for four more. A top-edged pull gives Big Jacques 12 off the over. Tim Bresnan stands with his hands on his hips, as if someone has just spilled his pint.

  101. 1508: 
    APPEAL - NOT OUT- SA 139-2

    For the first time in a long time in this series, it feels like we're watching a contest. Broad is bowling with three slips to Petersen, who is 71 not out, but opts for some chin music. The Proteas opener aims a pull, but the ball goes through to Matt Prior. England appeal, but it's more in hope than expectation.

  102.   
    BBC Test Match Special's Phil TufnellContributor

    "England will be thinking if they can get Kallis out and get a fresh face to the crease they can get themselves back into this game."

  103. 1505: 
    Commentary- SA 139-2

    Bresnan, now bowling with the replacement ball, is getting a little swing to Kallis, who looks as calm as a koala on valium. Just one from the over.

  104.  
    Twitter

    From MedenBFC: "You never know, we might get JP Duminy padded up sometime this innings!"

  105. 1500: 
    Commentary- SA 138-2

    Do clouds wait? Are they inclined to hang around? England will want the big grey blob above Leeds to remain as long as possible. Another good over from Broad keeps South Africa honest. At the end of the set, England ask a few questions about the ball, and fourth umpire Nick Cook brings out a black briefcase of replacements.

  106. 1456: 
    Commentary- SA 137-2

    Now Bresnan goes past Kallis's edge with a complete jimzooter. It's a maiden from the Yorkshireman, which ends with Steven Finn returning to the field, the Middlesex man is, we're told, suffering from stomach cramps. We've seen more replays of that 'drop' from Kallis, but it looks like he didn't get an edge.

  107.   
    BBC Test Match Special's Phil TufnellContributor

    "You'd be disappointed if you were Amla wouldn't you? In the form of his life and your mate runs you out taking a third. You'd be taking your pads off with a few mutterings about your mate. I think he did get a bit stuffed by Petersen."

  108. 1452: 
    Commentary- SA 137-2

    Has that dirty cloud now residing over Headingley spiced things up a bit? New man Jacques Kallis eases through mid on for four, but is then beaten all ends up by Broad by an absolute howitzer that swings away. Matt Prior failed to take the ball and is that just the hint of a mark on Kallis's bat on the HotSpot replay? Is that a drop? From less than nothing happening in the middle, there's now more action than the Olympic Park after the closing ceremony.

  109.  
    WICKET- Amla run out 9 (SA 132-2)

    Look up the word "bonus" in the dictionary and you will see the definition "Amla run out 9". In a bizarre piece of cricket, Jonathan Trott misfielded a Petersen drive that went out towards the cover boundary, meaning Tim Bresnan had to give chase. South Africa took an easy two, but Amla was far too slow in setting off for the third. Petersen called him through, but when Bresnan's throw reached Matt Prior, Amla was miles out. Awful from South Africa, early Christmas for England.

  110.  
    Commentary

    From Stephen Shuttleworth, TMS inbox: "I remember a slightly different incident in a Test match in Australia on Mike Gatting's tour in 1986-7. England had to score a smallish total to win the first match, which they did. Chris Broad was facing and the wind blew off one of his bails. Although he hit the ball for four, dead ball was called."

  111. 1445: 
    DRINKS BREAK

    There's all sorts of jiggery pokery going on out there. Matt Prior got wind that Petersen wanted a drink, so sprinted to the other end to try and prevent it. The result was, though, a drinks break, which served only to allow the skies to get even darker out there.

  112. 1442: 
    Commentary- SA 130-1

    It's really getting dark at Headingley now, are we in for a drop of rain? The smart money would be on the wet stuff. Amla has not quite got to the Zen-like state he reached at The Oval, slashing at a wide one from Bresnan, but getting nothing but fresh air.

  113.   
    BBC Test Match Special's Michael VaughanContributor

    "The Western Terrace has been quiet today, it's usually about this time they start to rev it up a bit."

  114. 1439: 
    Commentary- SA 129-1

    Nice applause for Bresnan at the end of that over, in which he greeted Amla with a couple of bumpers. Do England think they can unsettle the man with the best beard in sport? The wicket has also bought a change of bowling, Stuart Broad replacing Anderson. The Notts man gets one to jag back at Amla, the ball shaving off stump and evading Matt Prior on its way for four. Lucky. Broad stands next to the batsman, who responds by stroking the most sensual cover drive for four. Grown men could fall in love with a cover drive like that.

  115. 1434: 
    Commentary- SA 121-1

    Who's this rabbit coming in? Who is this walking wicket that will merely be a footnote in a South Africa collapse? Hashim who? Amla, you say? How many did he get the last time he batted? Oh.

  116.   
    BBC Test Match Special's Michael VaughanContributor

    "Maybe that's just the little trigger. England need a three wicket period in 20-30 minutes to really get back into this Test match."

  117.  
    WICKET- Smith ct Bell b Bresnan 52 (SA 120-1)

    This is not a mistake, do not refresh your page. England have a wicket, a wicket they so dearly needed. Tim Bresnan, replacing Finn at the Kirkstall Lane End, is full to Smith on the leg stump, with the South Africa skipper whipping in to the on side, but straight into the hands of Ian Bell, who was lurking at a shortish backward square leg. I'd be lying if I said I was expecting that, but it's certainly what this game needed.

  118.   
    BBC Test Match Special's Michael VaughanContributor

    "The South African batsmen look so determined, they read situations well. There will be the odd good ball, there always is at Leeds but South Africa are coming in on the back of so much confidence."

  119. 1427: 
    Commentary- SA 118-0

    Simon Mann on TMS points out that England are now into their fifth session without a wicket. I wonder what is the longest a team has ever gone without taking a Test wicket. As Anderson is gun-barrell straight to Petersen, the Western Terrace begin to make their own entertainment - Mexican Wave time.

  120.   
    BBC Test Match Special's Michael VaughanContributor

    "Smith's doing exactly what he did at The Oval, slow at the start, laying the foundations, now he's beginning to accelerate."

  121. 1423: 
    HALF CENTURY- 50 FOR GRAEME SMITH

    Smith, the man who England think may have a problem on off stump, leans back and hammers Finn through point for four. As a response, England finally get a South Africa batsman to dance to their tune, Finn causing the skipper to take evasive action from a leather-sniffer of a bouncer. Smith isn't ruffled though, taking a single from the next ball to move to 50. Does this bloke ever get bored of scoring runs against England?

  122.   
    BBC Sport's Mark MitchenerContributor

    MCC, guardians of the Laws of cricket, have issued a statement on the official Lord's website. It quotes Law 23.4 (vi), as we did earlier [see 1221] and points out: "Of course, what the umpire feels is distracting to the batsman is entirely subjective, but Davis was within his rights to signal dead ball - which he did."

  123.  
    dan_bollandTwitter

    From dan_bolland: "Re: Patrick in Cape Town [1405] - Getting as close to the stumps as possible for a fast bowler is a good habit, actually."

  124. 1419: 
    Commentary- SA 112-0

    England may have altered their line to Smith now, the South Africa left-hander working Anderon to deep mid-wicket for a single. From where I'm sitting, the ball is currently looking as likely to move as a darts player who lives next door to a pub.

  125.  
    the_topspinTwitter

    Wisden editor Lawrence Booth: "Well, it's fair to say this is going about as badly as it could possibly go after choosing to bowl first in a Test you can't afford to lose."

  126.  
    Commentary

    From David, Spain, TMS inbox: "Will someone please tell Strauss that nobody will mind if England take a wicket or two!"

  127. 1414: 
    Commentary- SA 107-0

    Finn continues around the wicket, with Smith driving through the covers for a single. England aren't looking much like getting the wicket that they so desperately need, and even the Headingley crowd is a little subdued.

  128.  
    Twitter

    From snoekrats: "Why is no one talking about the Cook dropped catch .That was a sitter. Blaming Smith for all England's problems is too easy!"

    Tweet us with the hashtag #bbccricket to join the debate

  129. 1410: 
    Commentary- SA 106-0

    With a packed leg side, Anderson again dangles the ball outside the off stump to Smith, who is happy to help himself to three through the covers. If England think Smith has a weakness on off stump, he's happy to prove them wrong. At the minute, he looks as untroubled as Bradley Wiggins on a bike.

  130.   
    BBC Test Match Special's Vic MarksContributor

    "Finn is coming around the wicket which should at least rule out the threat of knocking off the bails with his knee."

  131.  
    Commentary

    From Patrick in sunny Cape Town, TMS inbox: "Oh stop whinging about Graeme Smith’s 'poor sportsmanship' - why not focus on Finn’s bad habit of frequently clipping the stumps?"

  132. 1405: 
    Commentary- SA 103-0

    We have a slight scoreboard malfunction, with the electronic board on top of the Western Terrace saying that South Africa are 33-0. Wishful thinking for Andrew Strauss's men. When Finn is full to Smith, the skipper drives, causing James Taylor to chase just as he did in the previous over. Again the ball wins, but there's no dead ball this time. Finn drops short with the next ball, allowing Smith to hammer through point for four more. He really hit that hard. Smith doesn't just hit the ball, he teaches it a lesson.

  133.  
    Commentary

    From Richard Washington, TMS inbox: "Much debate about sportsmanship and the dead ball. In September 2009 [in the Champions Trophy] Strauss denied Smith a runner when Smith was cramping badly. Strauss was within the rules but Smith said he would not forget. Smith has found some symmetry today."

  134. 1359: 
    Commentary- SA 93-0

    England are continuing to pack the leg side to Smith - Anderson is bowling with six men on the on side - but still the Proteas skipper can get a couple through point. It really is like no field I've seen before, two slips, a mid off, then four men in a ring on the leg side, with two men on the boundary.

  135.  
    Twitter

    From tommoinleith: "My club, Murrayfield DAFS CC, has a bowler whose run-up includes a highly distracting MC Hammer dance. I foresee a few 'dead ball' calls on Sat "

  136. 1355: 
    Commentary- SA 90-0

    At this time of Olympic fever, I've been wondering which cricketers would be at home competing in London. Surely James Taylor could be a rowing cox? Maybe the thick-set Graeme Smith could be a wrestler? Grappler or not, the South Africa skipper swivels on a short ball from Finn and gets a couple.

  137.   
    BBC Test Match Special's Vic MarksContributor

    "I thought Finn was the best bowler in the morning session but of course now he has a bit of a dead ball fixation. It's like taking a wicket with a no-ball, you've done all the hard work and you're penalised."

  138. 1351: 
    Commentary- SA 88-0

    It's to be James Anderson from the Football Stand End, but he does not start well, with his first ball being clipped by Alviro Petersen through square leg for four. That takes him to 63. In the distance from me, a group of what looks to be exclusively men have gathered by a door that has the sign The Yorkshire Cricket Taverners' Club over the top. I'd wager that there's a bar in there.

  139. 1347: 
    Commentary- SA 84-0

    The nonsense of the opening session continues, but this time the main loser is poor James Taylor. Finn hits the stumps, dead ball, but the distracted Smith drives handsomely through the covers. Taylor is unaware of the dead ball call and sprints off in pursuit, his dive not stopping the ball from trickling over the boundary. All futile of course. Andrew Strauss can just about see the funny side, and a tiny hint of a smile cracks his face.

  140.  
    BBC Sport's Jamie Lillywhite at HeadingleyContributor

    "Steven Finn has been having a few looseners on the boundary edge, a few loosening deliveries that is, not cocktails. He only has two cricket balls as his marker though, perhaps it would be wiser to practice avoiding the stumps with his follow through?"

  141. 1342: 
    Commentary

    I hope you've lunched well. I suppose the very least you could have hoped for is a better meal than what England had - after the morning they had, the pie, chips and gravy (or whatever it is that professional sportsmen eat) can't have tasted great. Only one thing required in the afternoon: wickets. Steven Finn has the ball, Graeme Smith on strike.

  142.  
    Twitter

    From FlandersPie: So when I don't like a bowler's action a la Paul Adams, can the umpire call a dead ball if I find his action distracting?"

  143.  
    Twitter

    From AndyLycett: "Looks like we are up the paddle without a Swanny."

  144. 1306: 
    Commentary

    That was a tough morning for England, who will probably be having a very sombre lunch right now. Remember what's at stake in this Test - the world number one ranking. We're only one session in, but that was almost an instant replay of what we we saw for two days at The Oval. Lots to ponder while I pop off for some refreshments. See you soon.

  145.   
    BBC Test Match Special's Vic MarksContributor

    "I suggest it is going to be quite a quiet luncheon table in the England dressing room, except perhaps for Graeme Swann, who will be running round saying 'anything I can do to help chaps?' That's a terrific start for South Africa and a very chastening one for England."

  146.  
    Commentary

    From Thomas G, TMS inbox: "Well, I may be called a sore loser, but this business with Finn has put me off the cricket for just a few overs…"

  147.  
    Twitter

    From Bailey_Joel: "Wicket changes everything. Gets us right back in the game. Only 71 Test centuries from Amla, Kallis & De Villiers."

  148. 1302: 
    INTERVAL- SA 84-0

    It's Bresnan to bowl the last over before lunch, the Yorkshireman going past Petersen's outside edge with one that shapes away, but, from there, the South Africa opener is able to cover up and safely get to the interval. That completes a perfect morning for South Africa, who now have not lost a wicket in over four sessions of Test cricket.

  149. 1259: 
    Commentary- SA 84-0

    Was that another play and miss? I think I've got to give Petersen the benfit of the doubt and say he withdrew his bat from one that Broad got to move away off the pitch. As a plane swoops over Headingley, Matt Prior can't gather one that swings late, and they run a bye.

  150.   
    BBC Test Match Special's Shaun PollockContributor

    "The wicket is lower and slower than I expected. When I played at Headingley they tended to have a bit of activity and seam movement and tended to carry through quite nicely."

  151.  
    Commentary

    From Les Williams, Stockport, TMS inbox: "I've umpired lots of matches where a particular bowler will frequently catch the bails with his hand after delivering the ball. This shows that he is bowling wicket to wicket! I have never called 'dead ball' and in my opinion this happens so often that the Laws would specifically state a 'dead ball' situation were it meant to be so. Umpires are there to apply the Laws, not interpret them. It should also be noted that the batting side gets a small advantage from a bail disturbance when it comes to a possible run-out situation."

  152. 1255: 
    Commentary- SA 82-0

    As the trumpeter plays the tune from Chariots Of Fire, Neil Manthorp on TMS says this was a great toss for South Africa to lose. From my position behind batsman Alviro Petersen I can see that Tim Bresnan is getting a hint of swing, but it's not threatening. When was the last time England took a wicket?

  153.  
    Twitter

    From ColinJCraig: "Decision to bowl first probably had more to do with not bowling last (without Swann) than the wicket. Rod for your back Mr Strauss?"

    Tweet us with the hashtag #bbccricket to join the debate

  154.  
    SMS

    From The Lord, watching via BBC live text at work: "Are you telling me that with everything else going on in the crowd that a couple of stumps being disturbed has distracted Smith? Rubbish!! Are these the lengths they'll go to to try & win the series? I never had much respect for Smith as a person anyway & now this is irrevocable."

  155. 1251: 
    Commentary- SA 80-0

    Such has South Africa's dominance with the bat been so far in this series, the sight of an England bowler beating the bat draws applause from the Headingley crowd. Broad goes past Smith's edge in what is a tidy over from the lanky Notts man, a maiden earning more appreciation from this knowledgable Leeds lot.

  156.  
    SMS

    From Martin from Carlisle: "Could this be the worst decision to put a team into bat since Nasser Hussain put the Aussies in at the Gabba in 2002 and lost the Ashes on day one?"

  157. 1247: 
    Commentary- SA 80-0

    Bresnan runs towards me and beats Petersen with one that holds its line, but then Bres, on his home ground, overpitches and is eased through a gap in the covers for a couple.

  158.   
    BBC Test Match Special's Shaun PollockContributor

    "I used to knock the stumps with my hand a few times, it was sore on the fingers but it didn't get called dead ball. I used to bowl some terrible 'pies' every time though, it knocked my hand all over the place!"

  159.  
    Commentary

    From David Pierrie, Kirkham, TMS inbox: "I think Graeme Smith has set a precedent that will work against him – the umpire now has to call dead ball every time Finn clips the stumps, so any runs subsequently scored will be chalked off; hard luck for SA, then!!"

  160. 1244: 
    Commentary- SA 76-0

    The Headingley sunshine simply adds to the beautiful view I have out over the rugby ground opposite. My knowledge of Yorkshire is poor, so I rely on the local expertise of my BBC colleague Kevin Howells, who tells me that I can see the district of Armley and, panning round, Elland Road and Leeds city centre. As Stuart Broad replaces the unlucky Finn, a trumpeter strikes up in the crowd, drawing cheers. Broad was disappointing earlier, but is more accurate here.

  161.   
    BBC Test Match Special's Michael VaughanContributor

    "England should have kept it simple. Blue sky - you bat - but I think they're kind of searching for the answers. I think Graham Onions would have bowled nicely on this wicket though."

  162. 1238: 
    THE SUN IS OUT- SA 74-0

    The sun has reappeared at Headingley, but England are looking a little ragged. Yes they may have had some misfortune this morning, but Bresnan, bowling with only one man saving runs on the off side, is too wide to Smith, who drives for four.

  163.   
    BBC Test Match Special's Michael VaughanContributor

    "England look like a team that think everything is against them. I don't think they've bowled enough balls full, I don't think it has done as much as they thought it would but I looked at it this morning and saw the sun out and thought it looked a good wicket to bat on."

  164. 1233: 
    Commentary- SA 67-0

    Finn again hits the stumps as he delivers the ball, causing such a distraction to Smith that the South Africa skipper is able to rock back and pull for four. Remember though, it's always going to be called dead ball from now on, so the runs don't count. This is going to get farcical.

  165. 1229: 
    HALF CENTURY- SA 60-0

    So, after a frustrating morning, are England in for another long day in the field? They will be if they continue to feed Petersen with long-hops - twice he pulls Bresnan to the leg side for four, the second taking him past 50. After missing out on The Oval run feast, he's cashing in here.

  166.  
    Commentary

    From Gary, TMS inbox: "Is there any chance that Graeme Smith spoke to the umpire about the bail-bashing being distracted, and the umpire(s) told him that the option is to do nothing, or to call it 'dead' and so neither dismissals nor runs will count? And Smith/SA went for the latter?"

  167. 1226: 
    Commentary- SA 50-0

    The sun that greeted us first thing this morning is now firmly behind the clouds at Headingley, but the England bowlers are currently struggling to find any sort of movement. A Petersen single takes South Africa to 50. I wonder what the record of England's bowlers is since Tino Best walked out to bat at Edgbaston.

  168.   
    BBC Test Match Special's Michael VaughanContributor

    "Andrew Strauss will be stood at first slip thinking: 'It should be doing more than this'."

  169. 1221: 
    Commentary- SA 48-0

    If this was a premeditated decision by the South Africans to complain the first time Finn was to hit the stumps, is it clever to put that doubt in his mind? What about the spirit of the game? James Anderson finally gets a rest, replaced by Tim Bresnan at the Football Stand End, with just a single coming from the over.

  170.  
    JohnSunCricketTwitter

    The Sun's John Etheridge: "The Aussies - and David Warner in particular - were complaining about being distracted by Finn kicking stumps during the ODIs. Laws of cricket show Steve Davis' interpretation to be fair enough. Hope Finn is not now thinking more about his knee than where to land ball."

  171.   
    BBC Sport's Mark MitchenerContributor

    "Law 23.4 (b) (vi) states that "either umpire shall call and signal dead ball when the striker is distracted by any noise or movement or in any other way while he is preparing to receive, or receiving a delivery. This shall apply whether the source of the distraction is within the game or outside it."

  172.  
    Contributor

    Former England skipper Mike Gatting with us in the box: "Steve Finn has started something that is going to be very difficult to police."

  173. 1215: 
    Commentary- SA 47-0

    We have our answer, from the first ball of the next over Finn clatters the stumps and Davis immediately calls dead ball. If this is a sign of things to come, Finn's overs could take an awful long time to bowl. As if add insult to Finn's misery, later in the over he's forced to abort his run as Petersen is distracted by a spectator moving behind the bowler. The Middlesex man shakes his head, returns to the end of his run and then delivers the first delivery over 90mph of the match.

  174.   
    BBC Test Match Special's Michael VaughanContributor

    "These are really perfect batting conditions for Leeds and South Africa can put England under real pressure, there are already cracks in this wicket and if it gets that far days four and five could be very tricky."

  175.  
    Commentary

    Former England captain Mike Gatting with us in the box: "Smith had talked with umpire Davis earlier about Finn knocking the bails off, that's really taking gamesmanship to the eighth degree, which is disappointing."

  176.  
    SMS

    From Adam, Brighton: "I'm sorry but the umpire has had a shocker there... Finn hits the stumps at least once an over and if that ball gets hit for four it's not called a dead ball. But if the batsman gets out it must have put him off... Stupid."

  177. 1210: 
    Commentary- SA 43-0

    I suppose another question to pose on this Finn issue is to wonder what will happen the next time he clatters the stumps, because it will happen again. Is it always going to be dead ball? Anderson continues after drinks, beating Smith with an absolute beangurgler, but the skipper survives.

  178.  
    Commentary

    From Chris, Aberdeen, TMS inbox: "Anyone else get the feeling that this isn't going to be our day?"

  179. 1203: 
    DRINKS BREAK- SA 35-0

    There also seems to be a suggestion that Smith may have complained about Finn clipping the stumps before that incident, while our TV colleagues are saying that Steve Davis has got it spot on because the umpire is entitled to call dead ball if the batsman is distracted. I'm really not sure what to think. The fact remains, though, that Smith is still there and South Africa have got through the first hour. Drinks.

  180.   
    BBC Test Match Special's Vic MarksContributor

    "This will take some resolve from England because no matter what they say there was some scarring after The Oval, with only two wickets, and now they've have two setbacks."

  181. 1158: 
    Commentary- SA 39-0

    I think umpire Davis must have made that call very early, because none of the England slips seemed to celebrate. Also, replays suggest that Smith may have been trying to draw the umpire's attention to the fact Finn had disturbed the non-striker's stumps. Another thing to remember though is that Finn had already done something similar a couple of times before. I'm struggling to think why that should have been called a dead ball. South Africa take a single from Anderson's over.

  182.  
    Commentary

    Former England skipper Mike Gatting with us in the box: "He doesn't call it dead ball when it gets hit for four so why's he calling it now? I'd be very interested in the rule on that one."

  183. 1153: 
    Commentary- SA 38-0

    My word, it's all happening here. Finn, as he often does, clips the bails at the non-striker's end as he delivers the ball, with Smith then edging to first slip, where Andrew Strauss holds the catch. Out, surely? Not so, says umpire Steve Davis, who calls a dead ball, presumably because Finn disturbed the stumps. Strauss is straight up to the umpire, asking why Smith is not out, but the decision stands. The England skipper looks angrier than a bloke whose caught his wife with the milkman. I've never seen anything like that before.

  184.   
    BBC Test Match Special's Vic MarksContributor

    "There's no such thing as a straightforward slip catch they say but that is as good as it comes at second slip, on the front foot, it came at a nice pace, around about knee high, he got a bit of hands on it but not much."

  185. 1149: 
    DROPPED CATCH- SA 34-0

    Now then, can anyone remember the last time England took a wicket? A chance that they desperately needed to take has just gone begging. Alastair Cook, standing at second slip in place of the dropped Graeme Swann, shells a straightforward edge from Petersen. The right-hander was playing forward to Anderson, who showed no emotion as the ball hit the turf. How England needed that catch to be held.

  186.  
    Commentary

    From Stephan (no relation), TMS inbox: "Hey ho, how sporting of England to bowl the one failing Saffer batsman into form!"

  187. 1142: 
    Commentary- SA 30-0

    At the end of that over Anderson and Smith exchanged a few words, possibly discussing where's best to have dinner this evening. Here at the Kirkstall Lane End, the recalled Steven Finn replaces the disappointing Broad and is on the money from the off, conceding only a single.

  188.  
    Contributor

    Former England skipper Mike Gatting with us in the box: "You know certain pitches have got traits. I think I'd have opened with Finn, he's five miles an hour quicker than these boys and it's always good to hurry the batsmen up."

  189.  
    SMS

    From Simon, Stockport: "Never fear, Pie Chucker KP is here... On a serious note, I think our goose will be cooked with Swann out. Flower and Strauss certainly aren't playing chicken!"

  190. 1137: 
    Commentary- SA 29-0

    England must have been having extra classes on how to get Graeme Smith out - Tactics Master Strauss having his bowlers Jimmy, Stu, Timmy and Steve staying behind after school to study the blackboard. Anderson has three slips to Smith, but then no other man on the off side except a mid off. Everyone else is on the leg side. Fascinating stuff, with Smith fortunate to inside edge a couple to fine leg.

  191.  
    Commentary

    From David Barker, Peterborough, TMS inbox: "All pace attack, no issues with that! But this is all about the cloud cover and any help a tinge of green on the pitch may offer and having the right pace attack - Stuart Broad may well prove to be the weak link yet again. Far too much of a tail-end bully - we need to win..Finn and Onions every time for me based on recent bowling performances. Time to look forward and stop celebrating the past!"

  192.   
    BBC Test Match Special's Phil TufnellContributor

    "I know it's only half an hour but after the last match at The Oval they'll be wanting a breakthrough."

  193. 1132: 
    Commentary- SA 27-0

    Graeme Smith finally gets the strike and is the subject of a muted appeal when the ball goes down the leg side and through to wicketkeeper Matt Prior. Umpire Steve Davis, with his magnificent belly, is not interested. After Smith pulls for a single, Petersen tucks a leg-stump half-volley away for four. Not a great start from Stuart Broad.

  194.  
    Twitter

    From bemondsci: "Blowers is back! That's made my morning."

  195.  
    SMS

    From Chris B: "If it's picking a side for the wicket, Finn was needed at the Oval and both Broad & Bresnan were below par with bat & ball. Surely one of them should have gone! No Swann is a risk with all the lefties SA have!"

  196. 1129: 
    Commentary- SA 22-0

    A plane flies overhead, cutting through the cloud that has come over Headingley as Anderson begins his fourth over. Jimmy is on the money, causing Petersen to cover up on the off stump. A maiden, but the ball isn't doing much.

  197.  
    Twitter

    From Nizaamc: "JP Duminy will be happy Swann not in side , Been out to him three times in seven innings, not scored much."

  198. 1124: 
    Commentary- SA 22-0

    "Don't bother chasing that," says Mike Gatting behind me. He's right too, as Petersen leans on a long half-volley from Broad and eases a cover drive through the huge gap on the off side for four. When Broad then overcompensates, Petersen clips to square leg for four more, despite the diving efforts of Steven Finn on the boundary.

  199.  
    Twitter

    From Lewis__Baines: "Samit Patel is a horrendous cricketer, he shouldn't be in consideration for England, Tuffers is still more dangerous even now..."

    Tweet us with the hashtag #bbccricket to join the debate

  200. 1120: 
    Commentary- SA 13-0

    The first cloud of the day comes across the ground as Anderson runs in towards me. The Lancashire man twice strays on to Petersen's hips, getting clipped for two, then a single. In five overs, Smith has faced only four balls.

  201.  
    Twitter

    From AdamGreen1979: "Swann had a bad game last time out. I think with his record he deserved to not be shipped out like he was Peter Such!"

  202.  
    SMS

    From Steve C, a Yorkshireman in Rome: "South Africa will have more insight to the wicket than England due to the amount of runs Rudolph has scored on the ground! Many more than any of the England squad. He must like the look of it."

  203. 1116: 
    Commentary- SA 10-0

    Petersen plays slightly across the line to Braod to get a single to fine leg. If he'd missed that he might have been in trouble. As well as that man in the deep, England have four other men on the leg side to Smith, who, sure enough, pushes to the on side, but there's no run.

  204.  
    Twitter

    From RobThompson15: "As Swann is fit, it's a weak selection. If they wanted to pick Finn, Bresnan had to go. SA left-handers breathe a sigh of relief."

  205.  
    Commentary

    Former England captain Mike Gatting joins us in the box: "When the sun's out at Headingley it doesn't do very much. I don't know how much they rely on the forecast but they've almost forced themselves into a corner with the team they picked."

  206. 1113: 
    Commentary- SA 7-0

    There's plenty of empty seats away to my right on the Western Terrace as Anderson begins the third over. I'd heard that days two and three are almost sold out, but there looks to be plenty of opportunity to come and watch some Test cricket today if you so wish. Petersen takes two to square leg and is beaten by the final ball of the over, but there doesn't look to be lots happening for the bowlers just yet.

  207.   
    BBC Test Match Special's Phil TufnellContributor

    Only two slips for Smith, that's obviously a plan, trying to get him to play across the front pad and get him lbw.

  208.  
    BBC Sport's Jamie Lillywhite at HeadingleyContributor

    Each England Test player is given a unique number and today's debutant James Taylor is 653. I have a vested interest in this because my great-grandfather was the first England Test captain. He was given number seven because they did the first Test match in alphabetical order.

  209.  
    SMS

    From Simon, Southport: "Graeme Smith's third England captains scalp heading his way, I fear?"

  210. 1109: 
    Commentary- SA 6-0

    Not sure I've ever seen a deep square leg posted in only the second over of a Test, but that's what Stuart Broad had as he ran towards Graeme Smith. As if to prove the boundary-rider is needed, Smith clips to Jonathan Trott for a single from his first ball. Petersen aims a flat footed drive, but gets only fresh air, then gets a slice of luck when he inside edges for a single. Hint of swing for Broad.

  211.  
    Commentary

    Tim, TMS inbox: "If this is a purely tactical decision then England have made a mistake. Despite it being his home ground - Bresnan should have made way
    for Finn. He looked off the pace in the first Test. You don't leave out the
    top spinner in world cricket."

  212. 1103: 
    Commentary- Eng 4-0

    Early swing for Anderson away from the right-handed Petersen, who gets his first runs of the series with an edge for four to third man. With the talk of Swann being left out, the debut of James Taylor has been a little overshadowed. He gets his first touch of the ball in Test cricket, fielding at point.

  213. 1059: 
    Commentary

    With all the excitement of what was going on before the match, I rather forgot that there is a Test to be played here. Jerusalem plays, umpires Steve Davis and Rod Tucker lead the players on to the pitch. James Anderson has the ball in the distance away at the Football Stand End, with Alviro Petersen on strike. Play....

  214.  
    Twitter

    From DinoGhostQuest: "Good call by England. Swann has chronic elbow problem and was poor at The Oval, Finn's pace and bounce is what was missing."

    Tweet us with the hashtag #bbccricket to join the debate

  215.   
    BBC Test Match Special's Shaun PollockContributor

    "You can understand what they're doing but if the weather does stay fine I think they'll miss Swann on the final day. I don't think it's a panic decision, they're trying to pick the right team for the surface but if it does stay fine they're going to be in trouble."

  216.  
    SMS

    From James on the Wirral: "I'm surprised that Swann's been left out, but England are blessed with a superb pace unit so the attack will still be world class. I think it shows aggression which is what we'll need against South Africa over the next five days."

  217.  
    Twitter

    From paulbroadie: "No Swann? Putting SA in when they wanted to bat anyway? Strauss's neck is on the line here. Let's just hope it pays off."

  218. 1053: 
    Commentary

    Graeme Swann's omission has obviously come as a surprise to whoever produces the official programme - he's on the cover. In one other bit of Swann-related news, I needed directions from that very man to find the press box today. If when we were in the lift together he knew he was being left out, he didn't let on.

  219.  
    Commentary

    From Andy, TMS inbox: "I'm non-plussed at the omission of Graeme Swann and then the choice to bowl first, what is going through Andrew Strauss's head."

  220.  
    Commentary

    England captain Andrew Strauss: "There's a slight tinge of green in the pitch. With the forecast not being good later in the Test we feel it is the seam bowlers that will win this match for us."

  221.  
    selvecricketTwitter

    Former England seamer Mike Selvey, of the Guardian: "James Taylor gets presented with his cap by Athers. ECB money-saving: no VAT on his kit."

  222.   
    BBC Sport's Mark MitchenerContributor

    "Graeme Swann made his Test debut on the two-Test tour of India in December 2008 as the second spinner alongside Monty Panesar. He didn’t play in the “51 all out” Test in Jamaica against West Indies the following spring, but after the “10-ball Test” in Antigua, he replaced Panesar for the replacement Test at the Antigua Recreation Ground – and his omission today ends a run of 43 consecutive Tests since then."

  223. 1042: 
    Commentary

    So what do you make of all that? Are England right to go with an all-pace attack, or will this decision ultimately see them lose their spot at the top of the world rankings? In an era where England team selections have become very predictable, this is a bolt right out of the blue. Dying to hear what you think about this. Tweet using the hashtag #bbccricket, email tms@bbc.co.uk with 'For Stephan Shemilt' in the subject or text 81111. (Start your message with the word 'CRICKET' and don't forget to give your name.)

  224. 1038: 
    Commentary

    A little bit more on Swann's omission for you - that's the first time in 44 Tests that England will line-up without the off-spinner, a run dating back to the West Indies tour of 2009. Yes, he's had some concerns over an elbow injury, but this is surely a huge gamble by Strauss and co.

  225. 1036: 
    Commentary

    Smith says he would have batted first had he won the toss, so the Proteas are reading the wicket a little differently to the home side. South Africa are unchanged.

  226.  
    TOSS- ENGLAND WIN THE TOSS AND FIELD

    Graeme Smith makes the wrong call and England have opted to have a bowl, Andrew Strauss saying there's a bit of grass on the wicket. It's been confirmed that England have left out Graeme Swann, choosing to bring Steven Finn in to the side. It's fair to say that I'm pretty stunned at that news.

  227. 1032: 
    Commentary

    We're still waiting for confirmation, but there's strong rumours that England have left Graeme Swann out in favour of a four-man pace attack....

  228. 1027: 
    Commentary

    We won't have long to wait to find out. Andrew Strauss and Graeme Smith are on the way to the middle for the toss...

  229. 1026: 
    Commentary

    The second thing to tell you isn't really news, more a confirmation of what we already knew. Nottinghamshire batsman James Taylor has been presented with his England cap on the outfield and will make his Test debut in place of Ravi Bopara, who is unavilable for personal reasons. It will be a four-man attack for the home side, but which four?

  230. 1025: 
    THE SUN IS OUT

    So, what news can I bring as I sit in the magnicificent new pavilion at Headingley? Well, the first bit is that the sun is shining. There's a few white clouds in the sky, I think the odd shower is forecast for later, but, for now, we will begin in warmth.

  231. 1024: 
    Commentary

    And the stakes couldn't be higher. After their drubbing at The Oval - a fifth defeat in nine Tests this year - England will lose their place as the world's number one side to South Africa if they are beaten here.

  232. 1022: 
    Commentary

    Yes, while a few may be distracted by the festival of "faster, higher, stronger" that comes around once every four years, we at Headingley prefer to focus on a contest that began before the 2012 Olympics and will still be going when the Games are done.

  233. 1020: 
    Commentary

    At the 1900 Paris Olympics, the cricket competition was contested by only two teams; Great Britain and a France side made up entirely of British ex-patriots. Great Britain won. On the eve of the 2012 London Games, a touring South Africa side took on an England team that included a few chaps that may have once been eligible for South Africa. In that two-team contest, England would have been lucky to win a bronze medal.

Share this story

Live Scores - England v S Africa

 

  • England drew with South Africa
  • England: 425 & 130-4 (33.0 overs)
  • S Africa: 419 & 258-9 (67.4 overs)
  • Venue: Headingley

England 2nd Innings

Close
View full scorecard
Pietersen c Tahir b Philander 12
Cook c Rudolph b Steyn 46
Strauss c and b Duminy 22
Trott not out 30
Prior run out (Smith) 7
Bell not out 3
Extras 1nb 1w 8lb 10
Total for 4 130