BBC HomeExplore the BBC
This page was last updated in May 2005We've left it here for reference.More information

3 December 2009
Accessibility help
Text only
BBC SomersetBBC Somerset

BBC Homepage
England
»BBC Local
Somerset
Things to do
People & Places
Nature
History
Religion & Ethics
Arts and Culture
BBC Introducing
TV & Radio

Sites near Somerset

Bristol
Devon
Dorset
Wiltshire

Related BBC Sites

England
 

Contact Us

Like this page?
Send it to a friend!

 
You are in: Somerset » Going Out » Stage
THIS STORY PUBLISHED:
16 May 2005 2041 BST
The Fight for Barbara by D H Lawrence
Paul Stevens
Jason Hughes and Rebecca Hall
Jason Hughes as Jimmy and Rebecca Hall as Barbara
This somewhat overlong, rather turgid work by the sage of Nottingham is ample demonstration of one thing - Lawrence ought to have stuck to what he did best - novel writing.
SEE ALSO

Theatre Royal Bath
Review: Betrayal
Review: Design for Living

BBC News >>>
No rest for winsome director

BBC Wiltshire >>>
"What about Hugo Speer stripper guy?"

BBC Cult >>>
I Love 1996

PRINT THIS PAGE
View a printable version of this page.
get in contact

Written in 1912, this is nevertheless the first occasion on which the play has been staged in its entirety and in truth it shows - the first act especially, is much too long.

The play tells the story of Barbara Tressidor, a well-to-do 20-something who has left her wealthy but boring husband and eloped to Italy with Jimmy, the son of a coal miner she has known for just three weeks. (Ring any bells?)

Her impetuous action sparks a scandal which strikes at the core of polite British society and has a huge impact on her titled family.

A procession of the affected parties make their way to the isolated Italian villa to do battle in the fight for Barbara as we witness the usual display of Lawrentian emotions - jealously, incomprehension, rage, bafflement, confusion, all vie with one another to take centre stage as Barbara's past catches up with her.

Her mother - the unswerving and bewildered Lady Charlcote, is followed closely by Barbara's incensed father - the stuffshirt Sir William Charlcote, before her distraught estranged husband, Dr Frederick Tressider, forces her to question dramatically the new relationship in her life.

Jason Hughes and Rebecca Hall
Jason Hughes is "excellent" as the moody Jimmy

Tortured by the guilt of deserting her devoted, if feeble, husband but passionately in love with Jimmy, Barbara is forced to make a life-changing decision - whether to follow her head or her heart - arguably the central dilemma of all Lawrence's work, of course.

Dramatist Peter Gill from London's pioneering Royal Court Theatre rediscovered the unperformed play in 1967 and The Fight for Barbara was staged at the Mermaid Theatre later that year, although the text used was an edited version, as printed in 1933.

There may yet be a market for that adumbrated version, because, sadly, director Thea Sharrock's is definitely overly long.

That said, the performers do their best to invest new life into a tired and anachronistic work.

Jason Hughes and Rebecca Hall
Rebecca Hall grows "magnificently" as Barbara

Sir Peter's talented daughter, Rebecca Hall, starts off slowly before growing magnificently into the challenging role of Barbara, to give a performance that is both captivating and harrowing.

Jason Hughes is excellent as the moody Jimmy and there is strong support from the versatile Ann Penfold as the wounded mother - Lady Charlcote and Col Farrell as a wonderfully anachronistic Sir William Charlcote.

Stealing the show however, among those who bat for Barbara's former life, is her husband Dr Tressider.

William Chubb's performance is assured, accomplished and makes the best throughout of the situation's inherent irony.

And yet the problem remains.

There is a peculiarly contemporary dilemma about Lawrence's work in that it seems to have aged more in the last 20 years than in the previous 50.

Other authors - one thinks of Austen, Dickens, Trollope - Joyce even, can seem fresh and ripe for TV adaptation in a way that Lawrence no longer can.

Watching this somewhat laboured production one is made all too aware of this shortcoming - society changes - the Lawrence canon doesn't seem to.

>>> The Fight for Barbara runs at the Theatre Royal Bath until 6 August

line
Top | Stage Index | Home
Also in this section
Attractions
Clubbing
So Somerset
Films
Music
Get in touch
Get in touch with the bbc.co.uk/somerset team



About the BBC | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy